125 South Park Mafia: Game over

Tam · Post Post #225 (ISO) » Thu Sep 16, 2004 3:29 pm

Talitha wrote:So you really believe that bloojay went to all that trouble to concoct such an elaborate roleclaim... and then
forgot his made up night results
?

Uhhmm, I don't think that's likely, sorry.

So, you really believe that he actually

did receive them and forgot his actual results?

Oh, and if you think about it, it's a damned good roleclaim for scum to make up. It ensures him that he is regarded as very valuable by the town, but also makes sure that the doc, cop and blocker can't all jump up and go, "Hey, I'm the doc/cop/blocker!" because he can always say he isn't a full one, and is incompetent due to his randomness.

I am impressed actually. That was a mighty fine roleclaim.

Very well executed.

Hmmm...so why is that not likely? If he made up a random night action role and made up his results for both nights, he's more likely to slip up than if he actually got the results from the mod. How does it become easier to stick to a lie?

I can see what you're saying, Talitha. It would be a little hard to forget which results you made up if you were scum, but now try and see what I'm saying:

Imagine you have a role like that where you are randomly given your role back each night. Now imagine that N1 you picked Popsiclestix and it investigated him, you were sent results back from the mod that he was an innocent player. Now tell me how easy it is for him to

forget that he knows a player is innocent.

(1)

I just can't picture being told that a player was innocent from my own investigating of them and totally forget that I knew it. That is an extremely important bit of info.

(1) Depending, of course, on how sane he is as a cop.

Talitha · Post Post #226 (ISO) » Thu Sep 16, 2004 6:13 pm

You also have to consider the particular player. I've played a few games with bloojay and in my opinion he's not the type to make up an elaborate role claim. Especially with no pressure on him. Did you look at the context in which he made his claim?

blackshadowshade · Post Post #227 (ISO) » Thu Sep 16, 2004 7:46 pm

No defence Mole? Lurking but not posting? Or just too busy? Either way, you're almost at the hangman's noose ...

BTW, I'll be away this weekend, so don't expect any posts or actions from me in the next two days.

bss out

bloojay · Post Post #228 (ISO) » Fri Sep 17, 2004 12:35 am

Thanks Tally. I'm not sure which way to take that...

I don't see why you all think that i'm a doc/cop/BLOCKER (those who believe me anyway), whne I blatantly said in my original claim that I KILL. So that may very well be what happens tonight.

Talitha · Post Post #229 (ISO) » Fri Sep 17, 2004 9:49 am

Heh, no offense blooj, but if I remember rightly, the times you've been scum in games with me you have lurked and tried to blend in, and certainly haven't made an unsolicited claim!

So I'm pretty sure that you are who you say you are.. and the fact that you've been so transparent and relaxed about your role makes me believe you are pro-town. It also looks like a pro-town kind of role to me. Please only target people who you think are likely scum, mmmkay?

Internet Stranger · Post Post #230 (ISO) » Fri Sep 17, 2004 2:57 pm

Tally, its nice and all that you sit there with Bloojay and give us this dog and pony show, but the rest of us are following YOUR lead and lynching YOUR suspect, Gnome.

So the question is, why arent YOU voting him, despite having like 36 hours to do so?

Talitha · Post Post #231 (ISO) » Fri Sep 17, 2004 3:03 pm

He hasn't squirmed, cried, pleaded or begged anywhere enough for me to get any satisfaction out of lynching him yet!

Oh and he might want to claim.

Internet Stranger · Post Post #232 (ISO) » Fri Sep 17, 2004 4:16 pm

Screw that, you have all the "evidence" that you used to goat us into voting him in the first place.

Who are all the gutless badstards that wont vote for gnome?

Internet Stranger · Post Post #233 (ISO) » Sun Sep 19, 2004 1:58 am

Well? Anyday now.

Talitha · Post Post #234 (ISO) » Sun Sep 19, 2004 9:54 am

OK Gnome, I'll be voting for you in 24 hours, if nothing significant happens in the interim. Consider this a cue.

Mr_Gnome_It_All · Post Post #235 (ISO) » Sun Sep 19, 2004 12:38 pm

Talitha wrote: Oh and he might want to claim.

Actually, no, I don't want to claim. Sorry.

In any case, not much to comment on. Not much has changed here over the weekend while I was gone.

Talitha · Post Post #236 (ISO) » Sun Sep 19, 2004 3:46 pm

You're not even going to give us anything to chew over? Hmmm.

If there's anyone present who sees any reason why we shouldn't lynch this man, speak now or forever may he rest in peace.

blackshadowshade · Post Post #237 (ISO) » Sun Sep 19, 2004 9:35 pm

Well, I'm back, and it looks like the town's been busy ... NOT!

bloojay, I didn't realise that I had typed blocker instead of killer ... just a simple mistake there. However, I had somehow remarked in my head that you should only target scum because two of the roles would be useful against scum, and that's probably why.

Gnome, I see that you continue to add ABSOLUTELY NOTHING to our discussion. I don't know whether that's your playing style or not -- I seem to remember that you've been lynched early quite a lot -- but it certainly doesn't help the town to clam up. Nor have you pointed any fingers, mentioned any suspicions, even after my prompt in post 217 -- in short, you have given us every reason to lynch you.

PeaceBringer · Post Post #238 (ISO) » Mon Sep 20, 2004 12:22 pm

okay so we are stuck here waiting for Gnome to say something or waiting for folks to change there mind here.

It does concern me a little that Gnome is just basically asking us to lynch him.

INput anyone?b

Internet Stranger · Post Post #239 (ISO) » Mon Sep 20, 2004 2:20 pm

I cant comprehend the reluctance to perform a simple lynch.

bloojay · Post Post #240 (ISO) » Mon Sep 20, 2004 2:27 pm

I ain't reluctant. I'll do what everyone is apparently Clamorjng for....

Vote MGIA

Talitha · Post Post #241 (ISO) » Mon Sep 20, 2004 3:00 pm

dammit. You beat me to it.

NanookTheWolf · Post Post #242 (ISO) » Mon Sep 20, 2004 4:54 pm

And so it be told Mr. Gnome it all was lynched, or should I say Santa really. Yes that was his name Santa, all the kids of South Park can now

REJOICE

, because Santa was in the

MAFIA

! Good Job Town, but it still dawns on you that there is still danger lurking out there somewhere ...

GOOD NIGHT!

PLEASE HAVE CHOICES IN WITHIN 48 HOURS OF THIS POST!

NanookTheWolf · Post Post #243 (ISO) » Thu Sep 23, 2004 1:40 am

This morning you find poor Jediknight dead. He was a mason and his name was Jimmy. Now without all the jokes you are just thinking how on earth can we go on, but you get over it soon, and commence with your daily lives.

8 Alive, 5 to Lynch!

Fishbulb · Post Post #244 (ISO) » Thu Sep 23, 2004 1:45 am

Vote: Tam

After re-reading the thread, I'd have to say that Tam is the most likely accomplice to Mr_Gnome_It_All.
Anyone agree? Disagree?

blackshadowshade · Post Post #245 (ISO) » Thu Sep 23, 2004 1:57 am

Well done town!

I have another result, but at this stage of the game, it could be (and I believe) that my results from now on are useless anyway, since we're probably just looking for the godfather.

Anyway, my raw result is that Tam is guilty. If we assume that I'm insane, that means that Tam is innocent or the godfather.

OK, time for me to trawl through the thread again to look for new clues. In the meantime,

Vote: Peacebringer

for the same reasons as we had on day 1.

Internet Stranger · Post Post #246 (ISO) » Thu Sep 23, 2004 2:33 am

You all look so scummy to me

Vote: Tam

blackshadowshade · Post Post #247 (ISO) » Thu Sep 23, 2004 2:45 am

OK, here's my thoughts after reading through the whole thread again.

Role claims and confirmed roles:

Blackshadowshade - (Towlie, Cop - insane?)
Bloojay - (Mephisto, Experimenter - heal/kill/investigate role)
Fishbulb
Internet Stranger - (?, doc)
PopsicleStix - (Officer Barbrady, Cop - naive?)
Talitha - (?, role blocker)
Tam
Peacebringer - (Kenny, townie? - cannot be lynched?)

Bane221 - (Jesus, Killed Night 1, Mafia Framer)
Doomcow - (Mr. Hat, Killed Night 1, Serial Killer)
Mr. Gnome it all - (Santa, mafia goon)
Jediknight - (Jimmy, mason)

From Jediknight's post 200, I assume that the other mason is Timmy. IF we have the other roles that Jediknight mentioned, then the three unclaimed roles are Stan, Kyle and Cartman.

We're going to need night choice information before I shift my vote on Peacebringer, since I see no other obvious mafia godfather. However, I am keeping an eye on one other ...

FOS: Tam

Fishbulb · Post Post #248 (ISO) » Thu Sep 23, 2004 3:37 am

From your list of claims, the one that stands out the most to me is Towlie. The rest are more of the main characters, while I have never seen an episode with Towlie in it. That doesn't mean that he isn't in there, but I think that is the oddest roleclaim.

Also, Cartman could very well be scum; I've seen many episodes where he was the antagonist.

I do see your point on Kenny, though.

PeaceBringer · Post Post #249 (ISO) » Thu Sep 23, 2004 4:50 am

WTF- we get a bad guy in gnome thanks to talitha and suddenly it is let's kill kenny again because it was fun on the first day.

let's see only other information you had was you didn't like the way I post and when came out as kenny you of course quickly lynched me.

I already said I am just town so if you need a safe lynch you can kill me but personally I would rather find the scum.