I will never subscribe to a read based on 'tone'.In post 2335, projectmatt wrote:anyway for clarity, i scumread moment largely for tone issues (i articulated it in the post above.)
1) I don't think a lot of players are actually very good at doing this, and most of the time it's mostly because they're just bad at explaining reads.
2) I don't read players on tone anyway.
3) Scum can easily try to substantiate a 'scumread' based on just 'tone' and I've seen them do this.