NY214: Project Pinecone (Game over! Town wins!)

[Raskolnikov]

HWS isn't town for his claim but I'd kind of want massclaim to happen tmrw THEN he outs his informed info

[HeWhoSwims]

I guess I kinda wouldn't live until tomorrow in that case?

[the worst]

Most people have, from the top of my head I only wanted Chick and Duck

But why would I claim this?

[HeWhoSwims]

So I can either know for sure if you're a serial killer or just keep suspecting it! Seriously. If you're town, help me out.

[the worst]

I'm a town vig and that's not remotely important since I'll be sorted by nk anyway. The fact you're preoccupied with SKcasing the vig and not finding groupscum who are the actual threat here is basically the reason I'm still not totally satisfied you're town.

so just confirming. I will not be claiming whether or not I have a modifier, and you being paranoid about whether I'm not a serial killer rather than hunting for actual scum is anti town wincon

[HeWhoSwims]

Serial killer is not town and not my faction soooooo =)

I'm also on the hunt for groupscum and or town so that argument doesn't fly. They say men can't multitask right? But I'd love to prove the opposite

[Gamma Emerald]

We're not no lynching and jingles actually pushing some really scummy shit right now

Yeah now that I think about this I agree whole heartedly about jingle's plan being horribad
like we no lynch and follow the cop when we don't have the roles that can help proven (I'm not very useful, this refers the Ausuka and MOI)? This is just putting the game in scum's hands imo.
VOTE: Jingle

[brassherald]

Gamma can you give me a rundown of your reads right now?

[Gamma Emerald]

can't bring myself to lynch someone who's asking for it
no but really he towntold a little and gamma said he didnt... try to kill anyone last night if I'm understanding what detective does?

I believe it checks if someone ever killed/tried to kill
so it's a little better than tracker wrt finding killers but that's the only thing it does

[Gamma Emerald]

I guess this is cleared by fruit buuuut the play itself by GE isn't that convincing to me - especially the later part of the ISO has way more role/setup discussion than reads forming imo. HitAlt looks better to me. He really wants to out Duck - he knows he killed Dram - which I think is scummier if TW=vig but townier if TW=serial killer.

two misconceptions here
1) I don't have anything to do with fruit
2) HA didn't know who tw killed, he just knew tw killed

[Gamma Emerald]

I uh kinda believe that?

We are massclaiming if we have a modifier or not.

I obviously do because I am Loyal.

okay wait wait wait
Do you know what this is following? Theorizing on Loud doctor. This could possibly be scum. I think we should do this, get HWS to verify it, then lynch him. Thoughts?

[Gamma Emerald]

I'm a town vig and that's not remotely important since I'll be sorted by nk anyway. The fact you're preoccupied with SKcasing the vig and not finding groupscum who are the actual threat here is basically the reason I'm still not totally satisfied you're town.

so just confirming. I will not be claiming whether or not I have a modifier, and you being paranoid about whether I'm not a serial killer rather than hunting for actual scum is anti town wincon

tw might have a point here

[HeWhoSwims]

Loud protective doesn't have to claim at all since I know the modifier is there. Also dram was the only kill tw could have committed GE.

[Gamma Emerald]

Loud protective doesn't have to claim at all since I know the modifier is there. Also dram was the only kill tw could have committed GE.

DID I FREAKING SAY ANYTHING ABOUT THE WORST BEING GROUPSCUM? NO. I almost said something but I dropped it when I relaized "right if he were groupscum the real vig/sk would have shot him"
As for loud modifier, GOOD. Could still be a scum role though, but I'm not concerned about fishing for now.

[Ausuka]

I uh kinda believe that?

We are massclaiming if we have a modifier or not.

I obviously do because I am Loyal.

okay wait wait wait
Do you know what this is following? Theorizing on Loud doctor. This could possibly be scum. I think we should do this, get HWS to verify it, then lynch him. Thoughts?

After thinking about it further I think it's unnecessary and could help scum piece together the last of our town roles when they really don't need that information.

[Chickadee]

Loud protective doesn't have to claim at all since I know the modifier is there. Also dram was the only kill tw could have committed GE.

And by POE, scum could figure it out.

I actually do believe your claim, but I don't believe it to be town. Scum actually benefits a lot from knowing what things town can do and when. I can also see some town utility in the role, but based on your play here, and the defense you've tried to lay down for yourself in your recents posts, I'm not seeing a lot of reasons o believe you're town.

[HeWhoSwims]

How dare I defend myself when I'm about to be lynched as town huh

I for sure will enjoy wondering about tw a lot the next days

How can the protective even be found out? I'm only asking for modifiers on power roles that are already out .

[Gamma Emerald]

How dare I defend myself when I'm about to be lynched as town huh

I for sure will enjoy wondering about tw a lot the next days

How can the protective even be found out? I'm only asking for modifiers on power roles that are already out .

the ones who don't claim modifier
I see the concern but honestly I think the pool is a little large still so not too worried

[HeWhoSwims]

But even if VTs would just claim no modifier the protective can do that too... Because I already know the loud modifier is there without it being claimed. It won't mess up the count.

[Chickadee]

I'm not trying to give you hell for defending yourself. The problem is how you defended yourself.

Can you not lynch me I'm town just lazy

This post means nothing. It's an empty post.

I volunteer as counterwagon bait

It'd feel wrong to not be wagoned three days in a row

Scum hop on this if you want MoI to live

This seems LAMIST as hell tbh.

Maybe tw is BP SK and that's why one of the nights had no kill HMMM

Plausible.

@Ausika I can live with MoI. At this point I think I'm liking you better. And either it flips town and confs people or it it scum. I'm still not over Sky. More detailed stuff later let me vacuum and get my pc.

Here, you use Sky's shitposting to try and turn the tables. It feels like an easy target. Low hanging fruit.

[HeWhoSwims]

The first post was more joking than serious... Do you really expect anyone to defend themselves seriously with just that?

I thought sky was being serious / complaining about being wagoned which didn't sit well with me.

[Raskolnikov]

can't bring myself to lynch someone who's asking for it
no but really he towntold a little and gamma said he didnt... try to kill anyone last night if I'm understanding what detective does?

I believe it checks if someone ever killed/tried to kill
so it's a little better than tracker wrt finding killers but that's the only thing it does

Hey gamma you kinda have to find this out its somewhat of a big deal
Roles are not really supposed to be ambiguous in that way in normal queue (people should generally understand the basic of what their role does) so get this sorted out one way or another

[Raskolnikov]

Huh where did moi and taly go

[Ausuka]

Raskol how do you feel about profii?

[Raskolnikov]

I was thinking he should maybe be the vig tbh but idk
Hws should really be scummier than he is
The gamestate isnt adding up anymore