In post 1639, Nancy Drew Shogunate wrote:cheeky is emotionally impure scum because she didn't completely turn into a sociopath like the rest of us. so when she is pure sounding, even if you think her stances are not good, she is town.
I have no idea what these words mean. Like, what specifically sounds pure? Where would she have turned into a sociopath this game?
Nancy Drew Shogunate wrote:I'm waiting for chara to get towny and haven't seen it yet. RC's posting was up and down and there's a whole lot I don't like before we started fighting. I explained those at the time and they're in my ISO so I'm not repeating myself too much, but he allowed himself to make associative reads that either went unexplained or made no sense to me, and a lot of his scumreads were bad pushes from my point of view. he tunneled elsa all game and when elsa finally claimed 3p, he switches to me because I was defending elsa and so "death to greg haggar" or whatever charming thing he says. in what circumstance would me townreading a lone 3p scummy? I'm not gonna bother talking about those posts anymore but I found them very scummy.
chara has a strong scumgame anyway. until it becomes something blatant I'm not gonna townread this slot.
Premise: None of chara's posts have been towny.
Rebuttal: Post 1575 is one of if not the most gamesolvey post in this game made by anyone. The stances are solid, the reasoning is good (Not necessarily correct, but certainly town motivated imo), the timing is excellent. They were under no pressure to make it, but chose to put it out there anyway.
Premise: RC was bad and all over the place early game.
Rebuttal: Every game in which I have ever seen RC play mafia as town. He's all over the place until he decides to deathtunnel someone. Always. Sometimes he's even all over the place WHILE deathtunneling someone.
Premise: RC deathtunneled you after claims took away his scumread on Elsa.
Rebuttal:
Premise: Chara has a good scumgame.
Rebuttal: Good for them? If I never townread a player who had a good scumgame I'd lose even more of my games to stupid derptunnels on town who did something stupid. I don't need to do that more often, I'm good enough at doing it as it is.
I know toogeloo from a game he replaced in and played wonderfully towny the whole time he was there. his posting here is bad. lacks content and passion. this is a slot that's active lurking btw, for those of you who like reading into shit like this.
First of all, lynx please.
Second of all, what sounds bad? Where? Why?
Third, the concept of toog shouldn't be a townread because "one game he was really towny as town" is
Fourth, he hasn't been actively lurking since
Page 22. There's a case to be made that he was lurking lurking recently (as in, the last 3 RL days) but there is most certainly content in his ISO.
Fifth, I actually expressed reasoning on this read, which is not addressed at all.
So, to boil down your post, Chara should be null because combination of RC! and CHARAISGOOD!, Cheeky should be town based on a magical emotional Pinocchio style inability to make genuine posts as scum (assuming that is what you meant), and Toog should be scummy because you have a single game of meta with him that says he should be more town than this. I find this to be unsatisfactory as an attempt to sell me any of the reads mentioned, particularly given a lack of evidence to go along with any of it. If you genuinely think I'm wrong, you might have more luck if you were to focus on a single read and tell me why I should believe that particular read is wrong.
Alternatively, if the point you're trying to make is that you find my entire reads list is likely to be fabricated, put your money where your mouth is and say so. Tell the town why it is more likely I made the reads up than that they are genuine.
