Witches' Halloween Ball [Game Over]

[SirCakez]

Well, apparently SirCakez loves quadrupleposting, so this is it.

Good night

die potato

Also have Dunn mentioning my name serveral times. I'm only up to page 25 for quotes. Anyways going to bed, might be why i'm so pissed off because i havent been sleeping well again,

ty for this post, makes me feel better about you.

TL;DR

lol
I kinda skimmed the wall and it was pretty bad. A lot of fluff and "this happened then this happened" but not actually much real content. At least they dropped some reads.

[SirCakez]

eyy i have page top
great spot to drop that readslist requested!

From most town to least town

Town

RC (duh)
LLD
Maria
DVA

Town lean

Brian Skies
Chibi
Fire
Mala (very barely)

Unsure

Sakura/Kokichi (can't read either)
Dunn (same as Gamma pretty much)
Gamma (can't remember jack that they've posted tbh)

Scumlean

Celestia (barely due to that bad wall dropped on the previous page)
Shortaru
Karma

Scum

Moment

[Brian Skies]

I would dance with Princess.

[RadiantCowbells]

pretty sure the people scumreading shortaru are just bad.

[shortaru]

I'm trying to stay engaged, but things are getting a bit repetitive.

@Radiant, when will the lynch order be worked out?

[DVa]

Page 26
MariaR getting involved here is not good and she is attacking our confirmed town RadiantCowbells. Whereas Sakura Hana’s emotional and upset response seems due to maturity levels, I believe MariaR’s responses are from more mafia places because there is no emotion and no motivation for MariaR to get involved with an argument against our town leader.
Page 27-28
Not much except this plan for 4 pairs and I do not understand much but I will follow because smarter people know this set up clearly!
Page 29
I start to worry with so many people calling people “locked” town that someone here has to be wrong but everyone is speaking with such confidence and authority that it is hard to tell who is overestimating their abilities :\ I do not want to follow any “locked” reads I would like everyone to have open reads and think that they could be changed or maybe aren’t 100% correct when the game hasn’t even begun

So Celestia I'm curious about this section of your catchup post. First, Maria is a very capable player and I'm not townreading her atm, so I don't feel I'm biased against your position. But I also am curious about your reasoning here. First you say that Maria is "attacking our confirmed town RC" -- but I don't get this impression from what she's saying on page 26. Can you be specific or quote the posts you felt were unfair criticisms?

Second, you later on page 29 say that you're concerned about players being locked as town. But in this moment you are *specifically* objecting to Maria being 100% locktown and directly responding to LLD's 710 right? Or do you also disagree with RC's "locktown" reads of me, Sakura, or (not-so-locked?) shortaru?

Celestia, out of the men, who do you have as your strongest townread? Is your scumread of Maria strong enough you would say she should not be paired and excluded from the dance, or do you have another female scumread that is on par with Maria?

[RadiantCowbells]

i'm having second thoughts about dva and its making me sad

[DVa]

Hey Cakez, can you expand on the nature of your reads for these 4 players: LLD, Fire, Shortaru, and Karma?

Are your reads for those players based on tone or based on content? Can you point to the posts that are townie for LLD and Fire, and the posts that you see as most scummy for Shortaru and Karma?

[DVa]

i'm having second thoughts about dva and its making me sad

Why the second thoughts fam?

[RadiantCowbells]

doesn't feel like nayone's contesting the game from scum side

[ChibiBear]

I'm trying to stay engaged, but things are getting a bit repetitive.

Yeah, since we've pretty much already agreed on how this setup should be played, I don't have all that much to say.

I will obviously advocate for myself to be part of the 3-4 pair townblock but I won't object to being paired with a scummier player to be lynched/leave early on since there are more of us than them and it's worth the risk imo.

If the consensus reads end up being worse than we had expected and we end up in a tight spot, I'm unlikely to be of much help. I have a habit of making it to endgame and then getting extremely paranoid which is especially bad in this sort of setup where I actually have the power to easily screw the game up because of it.

[Brian Skies]

i'm having second thoughts about dva and its making me sad

doesn't feel like nayone's contesting the game from scum side

If you're so confident that Shortaru has to be town, then why do you think DVa-scum decides to be so hesitant of accepting him as a partner?

[DVa]

doesn't feel like nayone's contesting the game from scum side

Well, that could be because:
I'm wrong about an important read somewhere (not unlikely)

They're hoping they will get a pairing in the 3rd bracket (not unlikely and possibly related to the first)

Their wincon is basically getting scum in either the second or third bracket right? Like this game is basically coalition the way we're doing it

[ChibiBear]

doesn't feel like nayone's contesting the game from scum side

Yeah this is starting to concern me. Other than Fire not wanting to play along with the matchmaking, everyone else seems on board.

Best case scenario: We've got such a solid plan that the scum have nothing they can do.
Worst case scenario: There is 1 or more scum who are being widely town read and they're waiting for us to mislynch a bunch of people and then screw us over in the endgame.

[Firebringer]

pretty sure the people scumreading shortaru are just bad.

no u

wait i don't scumread shortaru.....

wait what are u townreading shortaru for? I have no feeling either way.

[RadiantCowbells]

Like

chibibear is ultrahardtown for me as well

I kind of want to put chibibear as #2 girl and DVa as #3

[shortaru]

i'm having second thoughts about dva and its making me sad

doesn't feel like nayone's contesting the game from scum side

If you're so confident that Shortaru has to be town, then why do you think DVa-scum decides to be so hesitant of accepting him as a partner?

This is a fair point.

[Firebringer]

Yeah this is starting to concern me. Other than Fire not wanting to play along with the matchmaking, everyone else seems on board.

i mean i can't be the only one who thinks the matchmaking thing is just the definition of anti fun and silly, there has to be less try hards in here than just me.

[Sakura Hana]

Getting paranoid?

[Brian Skies]

Like

chibibear is ultrahardtown for me as well

I kind of want to put chibibear as #2 girl and DVa as #3

Okay.

[Sakura Hana]

I've had a bad feeling since the beginning with how quickly people are townreading people.
Pretty sure I mentioned I had concerns with LLD and MariaR at some point.
There's also the thing with DVa being a lil different and more aggresive this game than BoR, but she said it's because of different role.

[Sakura Hana]

Like if you guys are sure they are town then sure, coz im aware my reads on D1 suk, but i rather speak up than not.

[Firebringer]

Who else is scumreading LLD and wants to join my LLDScum club

[shortaru]

I kind of want to put chibibear as #2 girl and DVa as #3

My only objection to that is...

I have a habit of making it to endgame and then getting extremely paranoid which is especially bad in this sort of setup where I actually have the power to easily screw the game up because of it.

[DVa]

I've had a bad feeling since the beginning with how quickly people are townreading people.
Pretty sure I mentioned I had concerns with LLD and MariaR at some point.
There's also the thing with DVa being a lil different and more aggresive this game than BoR, but she said it's because of different role.

maybe also something to do with not being dead before page 10 lol