A Story Revisited (Anything uPick): Day 6

[THE MEME MEN]

To be clear, NSG is confirmed "not-group-scum" not "confirmed town." If we do have SK, then NSG is not eliminated from that pool. But I'm still not sure we actually have SK over vig so I'm fine not touching that until we finish off the group scum and if the game is not won at that point.

Few thoughts -- there's no reason to think "dreaming god" in any way shape or form is town indicative for LA? I mean claiming her role name does not make her town?

Why would Ari be targeted by nihilism? Creature makes sense, {last night's target makes sense}, Jingle.... kinda makes sense? But if the nihilism effect is a groupscum action, then why would they target Ari? Did Ari ever claim or imply an investigative role? I think if scum ever no-nihilism'd, then Ari would be the likely fake in that group.

Like, if Ari was targeted by groupscum with nihilism, then that would seem to be town indicative, but I don't know WHY they would target him given his play, lack of attention to the game, and no implied or softed investigative ability (unless I'm forgetting something?)

I think those are the two slots I'm most interested in rn

-rh

[Porkens]

NR got a double vote on me because I did not agree to disclose my role. There was no question of targets.

[Porkens]

To be clear, NSG is confirmed "not-group-scum" not "confirmed town." If we do have SK, then NSG is not eliminated from that pool. But I'm still not sure we actually have SK over vig so I'm fine not touching that until we finish off the group scum and if the game is not won at that point.

Few thoughts -- there's no reason to think "dreaming god" in any way shape or form is town indicative for LA? I mean claiming her role name does not make her town?

Why would Ari be targeted by nihilism? Creature makes sense, {last night's target makes sense}, Jingle.... kinda makes sense? But if the nihilism effect is a groupscum action, then why would they target Ari? Did Ari ever claim or imply an investigative role? I think if scum ever no-nihilism'd, then Ari would be the likely fake in that group.

Like, if Ari was targeted by groupscum with nihilism, then that would seem to be town indicative, but I don't know WHY they would target him given his play, lack of attention to the game, and no implied or softed investigative ability (unless I'm forgetting something?)

I think those are the two slots I'm most interested in rn

-rh

This really looks like scum faking parody cop to me but whatever.

[Creature]

Can we use a strike list?
1) The MEME Men
2) Northsidegal
6) Gamma Emerald
10) Profii
12) Porkens
14) Vecna
15) Lady Angel
18) Jingle
19) Nero Cain
20) Creature
21) jjh927
22) Aristophanes
23) Shoshin

[Creature]

Like, strike out the conftown

I'll probably strike out who I feel is unlikely to be scum

[Creature]

1) The MEME Men
2) Northsidegal

6) Gamma Emerald

10) Profii
12) Porkens
14) Vecna

15) Lady Angel (may strike if role clarified)

18) Jingle

19) Nero Cain

20) Creature
21) jjh927

22) Aristophanes

23) Shoshin

[Creature]

I'm thinking probably Gamma, Nero or Ari

[Jingle]

I think Ari is the right choice, FWIW, but I could well be wrong. Hence, massclaim.

I just don't see a world where you were roleblocked by town last night.

And yeah, SK hunting is a backseat priority at best.

[Porkens]

1) The MEME Men
2)

Northsidegal

6) Gamma Emerald
10) Profii
12)

Porkens

14)

Vecna

15) Lady Angel
18)

Jingle

19)

Nero Cain

20)

Creature

21) jjh927
22) Aristophanes
23) Shoshin

[Jingle]

Shoshin isn't conftown, and in fact if we lynch two more antitown without the game ending she is confscum.

We just shouldn't care about her alignment until we flip at least one more scum.

[Jingle]

Profii is publically confed, Porkens.

[Porkens]

Thx

[Creature]

Shoshin isn't conftown

I know, I striked out those I townread mechanically or not

[Creature]

Actually I think Nero is also likely town, so it's between Gamma and Ari

[Creature]

I'm hoping it's just one scum left so we can end this game already

[Creature]

I don't want to wait another one week long night.

[Jingle]

Ehh. At least the dayphases are fast now.

[Creature]

We took quite long to lynch Nico.

[THE MEME MEN]

Worried about the nihilism targeted claim but Gamma doesn't smell like last scum standing atm

VOTE: Ari -Shiro

-RH

[Creature]

Massclaim order: Ari > Gamma > Nero? > ???

[Jingle]

We took quite long to lynch Nico.

5 days. Should have been 3.

[Creature]

idk, long nights keep confusing me

[Jingle]

Docket:

People who targeted Meme claim their action.
People who haven't claimed, claim.
Potential Guilties.
Lynch Ari?

I'll be back when everyone has checked in.

[Lady Angel]

NicoRobin has been lynched! She was

NicoRobin, Scum Demander of Action

.

Spoiler: NicoRobin

Is it done yet?

Welcome, NicoRobin! You are NicoRobin, Scum Demander of Action. You are a Conditional Rolecopping Tracker Conditional Triplevoter.



Make the damn uPick! (Conditional Role Cop Tracker):

Each night you may petition one player to tell you their night action and target

. If they choose to do so, you will learn their night action and target.
You Promised! (Conditional Triplevoter): If not, your vote will become triply effective against them.

You win when the Town have been removed or nothing can prevent this from happening.

Night 5 has begn and will end about this time on the 8th.

The underlined line is what I'm referring to. Just based on how the english language works it gives off the impression that it asked for both. The fact that scum have seemed to be after each other's throats all game also means that I wouldn't put it above NR to target her team if someone else coordinated it.

I'm sticking by my original claim: "Dreaming God, Dreamer of Dreams" with "Dreaming God" as the role name. I'm a 1-shot Dreaming God who could only act night 1. I have no reason to lie about any of this.

My reads right now are:

A - Mechanically cleared + myself:
10) Profii - Confirmed by Mastina
15) Lady Angel

B - Likely Town:
2)

Northsidegal

- Cannot be aligned with NR. NR flipped scum. While there doesn't appear to be a serial killer in this setup, there might be a possible other indie who isn't town-aligned. Not worth looking into unless we lynch all the scum and the game doesn't end.
1) The MEME Men - See above. Scum probably doesn't hard bus twice and Invisibility's role is unlikely to power scum.
23) Shoshin - Town unless it's a seven scum setup, which we can find out about later. If we lynch six scum and the game doesn't end she's mechanically not town.
20) Creature - Town by play, and I believe his role, especially since outside of me it's been accurate.
21) jjh927 - Likely not scum with NR.
14) Vecna - Gut feeling, and I really doubt a role with that obvious and that annoying of a PR is scum.

C - Null/people of interest:
18) Jingle - I townread his play, but I can't shake the feeling that the varsoon situation involved him somehow, plus the thing with NR's role.
19)

Nero Cain

- I have no idea how to read Nero.
6)

Gamma Emerald

- I have no idea how to read Gamma.
12)

Porkens

- Scummy play mostly, the vote for Meme Men was really bad, and the thing with NR's role. However, he was confirmed to be targeted by NR which makes me question my read here slightly.

D - Scumreads
22)

Aristophanes

- has done nothing of note and contributed very little at all to scumhunting. Seems to mostly be trying to appear posting without actually doing anything.

VOTE: Aristophanes

I guess I'll lynch from the bottom up?

I've underlined all the unclaimed players, which in them we have to fit:

Loud Babysitter - Possibly doesn't exist, only Jingle and NR have mentioned being targeted by it.
Vig or possibly SK that smites people for inactivity - confirmed to exist. May possibly be connected to Shoshin's role but that's just me tinfoiling.
Nihilism Roleblocker that prevents them from talking about it right after - Likely to exist. Has targeted Aristophanes, Meme Men, and Jingle so far. Possibly more that I'm missing. Likely does not belong to Aristophanes.
Redirector - Confirmed to exist if Creature isn't lying, which seems likely. NR's result on Mastina/Jingle/JJH was a disaster and seems unlikely to have been influenced by it, considering she tried to blame a redirector on Meme and Creature later, making it seem like her usage previously was an excuse.

@Meme, would you have happened to cop anyone last night?

[THE MEME MEN]

Nihilism Roleblocker that prevents them from talking about it right after - Likely to exist.

Has targeted

Aristophanes,

Meme Men

, and Jingle so far. Possibly more that I'm missing. Likely does not belong to Aristophanes.

@Meme, would you have happened to cop anyone last night?

???

-rh