Vedith is Town.In post 481, Slaxx wrote:@AP/TGP: Any town reads?
DD is "stupid" Town.
Mqueen is "probably" Town.
LabRat "feels" Town.
Not sure what to make of yours or Moment's postings yet.
Everyone else is probably null, except TGP who is a scum lean to me.
I picked him precisely for the reason you kindly pointed out. He wanted everyone to be paired up with someone but wasn't even active enough to be offered or to make an enlightened offer.
Vedith said redtea + AP/TGP, so it made sense to pick one of the two. I think RedLab mentioned Mcqueen earlier?
My "loose" thoughts are if Vedith (who is
So, I offer to pair with TGP, and hopefully he accepts, and we probably get lynched or NK'd (the NK depended on who else was paired with whom, if any). 2 "suspected" slots resolved.
I didn't see him rejecting, because -as you pointed out- he was advocating "the need" for those PTs. His rejection not only denies him (if town) a chance to sort me better, but also forces a lynch on one of us (if he's town that was a really bad move). In fact, even if he SRs me he should have still accepted. (Actually my whole lackluster play was in waits for someone to offer me a dance to accept).
As for you question about Aronis, I explained it and I honestly doubt I can do a better job here, but I will try. Aronis wasn't present in the game earlier. He had just started reading AFTER I had offered TGP the dance. Even if he SRs me and TRs TGP, voting me at this particular point means IF RGP accepts he is effectively voting his TR as well. If TGP is null to him, then he wants to see if TGP accepts or declines to form a better read on him, i.e. he still doesn't vote me yet. The only way he votes at this very situation is if he knows in advance that he won't be voting TGP by voting me.
But why didn't he wait? Because he knows he will be asked to explain why he voted the person who offered over the one that rejected the offer. It was better -from his PoV- to find a reason to be on that person BEFORE the rejection to justify his vote. Someone who had virtually not caught up doesn't decide to cast a vote on precisely the one person who had just offered to dance on someone without waiting to see the outcome or even questioning that person as to why they offered the dance to their chosen target. It all doesn't make sense from a town PoV no matter how you try to slice it.