Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[Alchemist21]

Also just to clarify my current thoughts on Sakura. The scumread got stronger when it seemed like they were fake engaging with me. It’s gotten weaker from the last several pages to the point it’s practically null.

[Sakura Hana]

You're still scummy for discarding Cop though.

Is it because you really believe that discarding cop is something scum do.
Or because you WANT me to be scum just coz i discarded cop.

[Xtoxm]

mafia cards 20
ww cards 18
alien cards 9
SK cards 4
cult cards 2 (+cultists)

cop is still a pretty valuable role, compared to the other investigatives
i actually didnt realise there were so many ww cards, i expected it to be more mafia weighted

[Xtoxm]

discarding cop makes her a pretty strong NK target tbh, she must have had 3 powerful cards

[pinturicchio]

mafia cards 20
ww cards 18
alien cards 9
SK cards 4
cult cards 2 (+cultists)

cop is still a pretty valuable role, compared to the other investigatives
i actually didnt realise there were so many ww cards, i expected it to be more mafia weighted

I agree with this and what Alch commented, but Alien roles are pretty dope too so who knows?

I just think it's a little hypocrite to call someone out for discarding cop and not calling out the other player who discarded an investigative.

[TemporalLich]

I'm not going to lie, if I got the role that says town or not town I would have discarded just to Piss people off.

Yeah you'd probably cause chaos and discord with a bloodhound discard. And likely eat rope or lead.

Conspiracy Theorist checks for Aliens. Who ever takes Alien cards for their alignment?

Maybe you really wanted to be a scumbo but the luck of the draw was against you.

Also just to clarify my current thoughts on Sakura. The scumread got stronger when it seemed like they were fake engaging with me. It’s gotten weaker from the last several pages to the point it’s practically null.

ISOing Sakura makes me think Sakura is town, but I can't ignore the Cop discard.

Is it because you really believe that discarding cop is something scum do.
Or because you WANT me to be scum just coz i discarded cop.

I mean you don't really need Cop if you flip red... so...

[Sakura Hana]

discarding cop makes her a pretty strong NK target tbh, she must have had 3 powerful cards

One of my cards i already claimed that i used for my alignment was wrong place at the wrong time townie.
But at the time of me making me choices i didnt realize i could discard that for the same combination, since my first thought was that i would never use it for it's ability instead of it's alignment and so i used it for my alignment.
Which means that my role is choice was between X and a Town Cop.

[Irrelephant11]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

[Sakura Hana]

but Alien roles are pretty dope too so who knows?

Aliens were made for Greater Idea, not Greatest Idea, the point of aliens is that they get a nerfed factional, for really unique and strong abilities. I agree with alchemist's point there.

[Alchemist21]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

Can you or cloud talk to me about Performer? I tried to look back at Cloud’s sr but I don’t really get it.

[Irrelephant11]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

Lol Elsa belongs in the second list

[pinturicchio]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

Hold on a second buddy

[TemporalLich]

yeah I'd easily switch my vote to Elsa right now

[Irrelephant11]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

Can you or cloud talk to me about Performer? I tried to look back at Cloud’s sr but I don’t really get it.

His posts feel entirely empty to me, aside from a few townreads in one of his first posts I couldn’t really “get”

[Irrelephant11]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

Hold on a second buddy

I’m holding
Now what

[Sakura Hana]

I agree with alchemist's point there.

I think i misread something, coz this part doesnt make any sense lol.

[Sakura Hana]

I agree with alchemist's point there.

I think i misread something, coz this part doesnt make any sense lol.

Oh wait no, nvm, it makes sense, dont mind me.

[Xtoxm]

i just want to tttt to check in and let us know if hes shooting today so we can lynch elsa and get some info
such as how many kills per night we have, and whether im going to be here tomorrow
before i put too much thought into this game

[Irrelephant11]

Alchemist rings towny to me sometimes and scummy to me sometimes
He’s in my “lynch before lylo if the read doesn’t clear up but don’t lynch yet” pile

[Vedith]

I agree with alchemist's point there.

I think i misread something, coz this part doesnt make any sense lol.

This post makes lack of sense

[Vedith]

I agree with alchemist's point there.

I think i misread something, coz this part doesnt make any sense lol.

This post makes lack of sense

Dont mind me it does

[Irrelephant11]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

I guess I should explain these
Shadow cc’ing Elsa and full claiming reminded me of my own Elsa-cc (an inner monologue of “ugh FINE I’ll full claim because this scum needs to die!”)
Sakura’s claim that his alignment comes from WPATWT townie has not been cc’d, and I doubt he’s scum who chose WPATWT as his *role*
Xtoxm’s posts always feel forward-moving, unlike many players who have rehashed previous conversations or contributes basically nothing

Performer’s posts feel empty, as I’ve said
Davesaz posts feel IIOA-y

[Alchemist21]

Alchemist rings towny to me sometimes and scummy to me sometimes
He’s in my “lynch before lylo if the read doesn’t clear up but don’t lynch yet” pile

Perfectly balanced as all things should be.

[pinturicchio]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

Hold on a second buddy

I’m holding
Now what

Still don't get it?

Are you townreading Elsa?

[Irrelephant11]

Townreading shadow, Sakura, xtoxm right now (and Elsa, obvs)
Scumleaning Performer, davesaz

This game moves fast I forgot how hard large games are to keep up with

Lol Elsa belongs in the second list