Gameshow Mafia (Reroll): Game Over

[Titus]

Out for the day.

[themilkcartonkid]

I feel like bef oka is a bad vote and it should be creature chemist. I cant sort either of them

Why is Creature/Chemist a better vote?

Because bef and oka risks two kinda sortable whereas creature chem is two unsortables. I dont give a crap if we hit scum here, the goal is to eliminate mislynches and lynchbait while not letting scum get away with wifom. (The correct play is to pair with obvtown to not be lynched, if they tried to wifom their way out of it by pairing with a mislynch to misdirect us towards lynching a good town player and mislynching, we would just say nah and lynch the obvious pair)

[NanceFloor]

I feel like bef oka is a bad vote and it should be creature chemist. I cant sort either of them

Why is Creature/Chemist a better vote?

Because bef and oka risks two kinda sortable whereas creature chem is two unsortables. I dont give a crap if we hit scum here, the goal is to eliminate mislynches and lynchbait while not letting scum get away with wifom. (The correct play is to pair with obvtown to not be lynched, if they tried to wifom their way out of it by pairing with a mislynch to misdirect us towards lynching a good town player and mislynching, we would just say nah and lynch the obvious pair)

I think only one because I think Chemist is town.

[themilkcartonkid]

How? How can you possibly know that based on the little they've actually posted?

[NanceFloor]

How? How can you possibly know that based on the little they've actually posted?

RC thinks so too and so do others. Granted, it isn’t a strong read but nothing he has done so far has pinged me. I have no clue wrt to Creature however.

[themilkcartonkid]

But I want to know how

[NanceFloor]

Spoiler:

It’s late and I don’t feel like critically thinking but I remember thinking a couple of Oka posts were townie

186 in case I forget

Spoiler: 0verki11 notable posts

I thought Chennis was town; he was not on my original lynch list (separate statements). I just dislike his play/style. Honestly, I'm very disappointed at this playerlist, I was much happier with the first one. If I noticed how much it changed I probably would not have stayed in.

VOTE: Mbaki
idk if this is scum 8ball its still a good lynch for town

This is a wolfy perspective because I think scum are more likely to be focused on the 8-ball setup because it's more important for them to lynch it

I have 2 reads already with decent confidence.

VOTE: 8ball

I now have 4 reads.

The mentioning of reads but no shareing seems useless.

Code: Select all

OkaPoka
Time Devil (TemporalLich + Baezu)
Shoshin
Confirmation Bias (??? + ???)
NanceFloor (Nancy Drew 39 + Dannflor)
Creature***
chennisden
Chemist1422
0verki11

We are lynching on this list today. No, not being here does not necessarily mean a town read. If you vote off this list I will be irritated.

Trying to control votes so early on despite not doing much themselves + no real reasoning at all.

I thought Chennis was town; he was not on my original lynch list (separate statements). I just dislike his play/style. Honestly, I'm very disappointed at this playerlist, I was much happier with the first one. If I noticed how much it changed I probably would not have stayed in.

Like wolfy af, lynching someone because you dont agree with their playstyle is unneeded

We have 4 days. Please relax Chen.

Oka lynch is cool. I

think

Shadow is town, for some pretty garbage reasons.

I am not placing a vote. I will be voting by end of day, do not worry.

Disagree with Shadow read, and I dont see a reason not to vote

I don't like the vote for one post+case later thing at all tbh

Yeah I don't really like the slot, plus overall seems less aggressive than I've seen them lately.

Spoiler: TD ISO Part 1

Creature is town

I didn't think it completely through but the basic idea behind a quick lynch would be like rolling the dice and sacrificing someone before scum has a chance to setup a lynch on the 8ball target.

Mechanically it might be fine but wouldn't scum setting up a lynch on the 8ball target be somewhat obvious in hindsight?

Creature is town

Explain how you got that from four posts.

- Dann

It was a joke

-b

Backtrack

i think nancefloor is scummy but i also don't want to push them for reasons

Please do

i think nancefloor is scummy but i also don't want to push them for reasons

And I 100% agree with you on this

The second quote just seems weird with it without the first one, doesn’t seem like they’re trying to understand RC’s perspective at all, in the first one too

@Time Devil, you never actually gave the reasons why you’re sr us. Do you actually have any you’d care to share with the class?

~ND

If you're seriously death-tunneling us because you misinterpreted 250, you're obviously scum trying to push my lynch.

Don't tell me that that's not what 410 says. You've been caught.

You also seem to be very defensive, and your reads have little substance.

-TL

I don’t really know how to feel about this post, something bothers me about it but I don’t know what

Spoiler: Chenn ISO part 1

brighteyedfish please move your vote to something more productive.

your excuse seems like a wishwashy thing scum says.

I like the pressure here but iirc it’s never followed up on

also idc if 8ball is scum, we lynch scum

I kinda like this perspective but I’m not an expert in this game’s mechanics

i really don't want to use this

but nancefloor slot seems to have benefited soo much from this exchange while doing so little

Feels genuinely solvy

im not gonna take sides

also nance scum.

I don’t know why I quoted this

the mbaki lynch list is terrible though

it blatantly is controlling the lynch without providing any reasoning

More solving

You’ve also seen town me a few times now, I believe, so what makes you see that differently?

Looks advantage seeking, if you know what i mean. agenda based.

anyway if you are town kill scum with me.

Backing up their reads, which I like

Your reads have had no evidence and are incredibly non-committal and broad.

Same as above

Based on their first 25 posts I think they’re town so far, but I’ll keep y’all updated while I keep going through

I also remembered I should probably look through spew

But I want to know how

[themilkcartonkid]

Okay, so the huge iso pist

[Chemist1422]

hi I got little sleep last night and am trying not to fall asleep

I’m gonna go back to the chenn ISO but AMA rq before that

[chennisden]

dw im town

[OkaPoka]

why is having nuanced reads = scum?

[RadiantCowbells]

neither creature nor chemist is unsortable...

[BNL]

Vote Count 2.2.4

OkaPoka/BrightEyedFish (4): chennisden, Clemency, RadiantCowbells, Time Devil
Creature/Chemist1422 (3): Ankamius, mbaki, OkaPoka
chennisden/Titus (1): BrightEyedFish
Ankamius/Clemency (1): JohnnyEnglish

Not Voting (7): themilkcartonkid, Creature, Taly, NanceFloor, Chemist1422, 0verki11, Titus

With 16 players alive, it takes 9 to eliminate a pair.

The deadline for elimination is 9 May 11:00am UTC-4, or in (expired on 2019-05-09 11:00:00)

Mod Notes:

Taly

has been prodded

[chennisden]

iirc creature is really easy to meta read

[OkaPoka]

is he town meta here?

[chennisden]

i havent played with creature a lot so take everything i say with a grain of salt

not rly, he usually posts more, but this isnt his scum meta

[OkaPoka]

so what is his town meta and scum meta that makes him so easy to differentiate

[BrightEyedFish]

@Oka

How many of the 4 players currently voting us are scum?

[RadiantCowbells]

well there's me

[RadiantCowbells]

and as anyone who is ANYONE knows

RC is always scum

[OkaPoka]

Nice try BEF

[BrightEyedFish]

Nice try BEF

I was being serious.

[OkaPoka]

An integer number between 0 and 3

[OkaPoka]

(inclusive)

[BrightEyedFish]

I'll even go first:

OkaPoka/BrightEyedFish (4):

chennisden

,

Clemency

,

RadiantCowbells

,

Time Devil

50%