Starry Night [Game Over]

[Gamma Emerald]

Let's leave Creature behind

Why

[Oversoul]

1. OkaPoka
4. Firebringer
5. SXTLHGaiden
2. Alisae
5. Gamma Emerald
7. Bitmap
9. Shiro

Excuse me
Is this a "these people aren't worth much as town" list or a "these people might be scum" list?

Both

Policy lynch or policy leave pre-dance? Two very different things.

They're pretty much the same thing, not "very different things"

Yes, they are. We aren't lynching anyone right now, are we?

MariaR, did you invite unwnd to play this game?

I don't get the point of this question

That's ok. It isn't meant for you.

These people can leave the game pre-dance and I think we would all be better off for it:
1. OkaPoka
4. Firebringer
5. SXTLHGaiden
2. Alisae
5. Gamma Emerald
7. Bitmap
9. Shiro

That's a big poe

Not really. It's predance + 3 lovers pairs, if they all pair up.

[SXTLHGaiden]

Self-serving post

MariaR - Maybe
Alisae - ?
Kagami - Taken
popsofctown - Rejected lmao
Gamma Emerald - Maybe
Creature - No
Bitmap - No
Cephrir - Taken
Shiro - Likely Taken

I need a stronger read on maria/Gamma

cataloging who you might dance with?

[Oversoul]

Self-serving post

MariaR - Maybe
Alisae - ?
Kagami - Taken
popsofctown - Rejected lmao
Gamma Emerald - Maybe
Creature - No
Bitmap - No
Cephrir - Taken
Shiro - Likely Taken

I need a stronger read on maria/Gamma

If your choice isn't MariaR that's suss

[Oversoul]

Let's leave Creature behind

Umm no

[Bitmap]

I will get to this tomorrow.

[Dunnstral]

I don't think MariaR has done anything you could call her town for

Let's leave Creature behind

Let's leave Creature behind

Umm no

Think he's the scummiest lady slot

With Alisae being null and the only reason to leave that slot behind is "lurker" which isn't inspired and doesn't force anybody to take sides on anything

[unwnd]

Self-serving post

MariaR - Maybe
Alisae - ?
Kagami - Taken
popsofctown - Rejected lmao
Gamma Emerald - Maybe
Creature - No
Bitmap - No
Cephrir - Taken
Shiro - Likely Taken

I need a stronger read on maria/Gamma

If your choice isn't MariaR that's suss

Spoiler:

Maria is great, I think she's very perceptive and gives good advice. I enjoy her candid attitude towards things and her kindness despite my own doubts. I have nothing but good things to say about her as a person, but in terms of Mafia we don't always see eye to eye. I probably wouldn't be the best in terms of reading her.

[Gamma Emerald]

1. OkaPoka
4. Firebringer
5. SXTLHGaiden
2. Alisae
5. Gamma Emerald
7. Bitmap
9. Shiro

Excuse me
Is this a "these people aren't worth much as town" list or a "these people might be scum" list?

Both

Why do you not consider Oka worth much as town? Sure he's weak currently but I know he has potential, he's had me spooked as scum before. Tbh I think you might just be showing preference to those you've played with more here, as some of the newer folks seem to be in your PoE. Why isn't unwnd in there?

[Gamma Emerald]

Self-serving post

MariaR - Maybe
Alisae - ?
Kagami - Taken
popsofctown - Rejected lmao
Gamma Emerald - Maybe
Creature - No
Bitmap - No
Cephrir - Taken
Shiro - Likely Taken

I need a stronger read on maria/Gamma

If your choice isn't MariaR that's suss

Wut

[Oversoul]

You think

LUPIN's

slot is scummier than Bitmap?

Pedit: It is a two way road, unwnd. Unless I am mistaken, I do not think she has claimed a read on you yet. A PT would help her with that and since she brought you here, she's the person I trust with being able to read you because so far you're inscrutable to me. I think town only really loses with you + MariaR pairing if you're both scum, which is negative utility for scum, so I don't think town really loses at all in that situation.

[Dunnstral]

I don't think Bitmap is scummy so yes

[Oversoul]

Why do you not consider Oka worth much as town? Sure he's weak currently but I know he has potential, he's had me spooked as scum before. Tbh I think you might just be showing preference to those you've played with more here, as some of the newer folks seem to be in your PoE. Why isn't unwnd in there?

Oka seems all over the place. Same with FB. I find distractions to be anti-town by their nature. He should probably be in there, but ideal world unwnd is with MariaR who I think is pretty town so far

[unwnd]

You think

LUPIN's

slot is scummier than Bitmap?

Pedit: It is a two way road, unwnd. Unless I am mistaken, I do not think she has claimed a read on you yet. A PT would help her with that and since she brought you here, she's the person I trust with being able to read you because so far you're inscrutable to me. I think town only really loses with you + MariaR pairing if you're both scum, which is negative utility for scum, so I don't think town really loses at all in that situation.

You're kinda right actually, I've been trying to consider what Dunn has been saying so I've remained hesitant on the idea. What's your take on Maria thus far before I jump the gun?

[Gamma Emerald]

Why do you not consider Oka worth much as town? Sure he's weak currently but I know he has potential, he's had me spooked as scum before. Tbh I think you might just be showing preference to those you've played with more here, as some of the newer folks seem to be in your PoE. Why isn't unwnd in there?

Oka seems all over the place. Same with FB. I find distractions to be anti-town by their nature. He should probably be in there, but ideal world unwnd is with MariaR who I think is pretty town so far

Why is unwnd + Maria ideal???

[Gamma Emerald]

Also following your logic how am I a distraction?

[Gamma Emerald]

I really don't want unwnd + Maria to happen until OS backs that shit up

[Oversoul]

Also following your logic how am I a distraction?

I don't feel like you ever really scumhunt. Don't worry, if I am being objective I would also put myself on that list.

[Gamma Emerald]

Also following your logic how am I a distraction?

I don't feel like you ever really scumhunt. Don't worry, if I am being objective I would also put myself on that list.

Excuse me? What games give you that impression? And I want you to look at my ISO so far and tell me what you see.

[popsofctown]

DV and Ceph is XOR because scum don't dance with scum unless they are terribad and I know at a minimum Ceph is not terribad

[Oversoul]

I think it's less normal to assume everyone who seems experienced is some kind of weird alt or a banned user. MariaR invited me to this game lol

If this was anyone but you I swear...

I don't want to speak for both of them, but these types of things imply people who know each other fairly well. That is what I am basing my opinion on.

[Oversoul]

Also following your logic how am I a distraction?

I don't feel like you ever really scumhunt. Don't worry, if I am being objective I would also put myself on that list.

Excuse me? What games give you that impression? And I want you to look at my ISO so far and tell me what you see.

Don't take it so personally

[Shiro]

i was asleep shiro, how are you doing?

That.... Is, strikingly not as amazing as my dragon slaying visions were. Regardles, I was reading everything up to now and I can say that I townread everyone halp D:

[Firebringer]

well in my dreams i save dragons from the abuse of humans who try to kill them. dragons are misunderstood shiro.

also do u agree to my conditions on us dancing?

[Shiro]

What was the condition, I might have missed it since I skimmed some stuff I am at work.