Newbie 1943: Crosswords (Game Over)

[TemporalLich]

I am still willing to vote Cyan, but he's now just a compromise lynch.

I don't recall Sera repping out.

Either way, Cyan and Sera are unlikely to be SvT

[Spangled]

And, after a few hours, I won't be able to check this site again until about 4:00 tomorrow (my time; about 9 hours from now), so I kind of need a wagon and a case to form now-ish if we're not going to lynch Cyan.

[Spangled]

I am still willing to vote Cyan, but he's now just a compromise lynch.

I don't recall Sera repping out.

Either way, Cyan and Sera are unlikely to be SvT

She hasn't posted in five days (or something); if that isn't grounds for replacement I don't know what is.

[TemporalLich]

My main case against Sera is still the fact she manipulates me into claiming by setting me on L-1 (see 472) when

she didn't even want to L-1 vote me

(see 455). And 451 makes it look even worse.

She doubled down on my vote with 490 btw.

464 is also a bad defense.

pedit: okay I guess, gonna flip back just in case

VOTE: Cyan Talon

[cyrus62]

fine if i have to i will but im going wait i rather lynch sera

[TemporalLich]

we don't have time cyrus

[cyrus62]

mod can we get a vote count

[Spangled]

mod can we get a vote count

At this point I’m pretty sure 3 people (myself, TL, adorable) are voting Cyan.

[cyrus62]

VOTE: Cyan. after seeing i have no choise i vote cyan not that i wanted to

[Thespio]

Hey guys, apologies for the delay, went clubbing last night and left my phone at home. Ill review the game, before I do anything anyone wants me to look at specifically?

[cyrus62]

7 hours till end of day 1

[TemporalLich]

Cyan is at L-1

[TemporalLich]

by my calculations, there are 5 votes on cyan

[TemporalLich]

nevermind, there are 4

[Thespio]

Spoiler: Post 5

Hello! I'm your resident SE!

What's your experience with Mafia?

This is actually a big scum tell for SEs, they want a position of power so they start out trying to be proper and not with a RV in RVS. if you dont believe me look at other completed games.

Spoiler: post 21

Sup

same general concern here, but its less a concern as they aren't flaunting their experience.

Spoiler: post 31

there are other ways to do that, you don't ever have to rvs vote.

another scummy post. Nothing like criticizing a RVS Vote.

Spoiler: post 48

VOTE: Phone0Ix

Scummy but also could just be a newbie. someone who doesnt know how to play and doesnt want to die so they are trying to avoid the limelight.

At this point Robb is 1 off from dying, seems odd scum didnt end it here. it would cut off all early discussing and kill a townie... seems odd.


Also, Phone0Ix, you should not have cop claimed if you are town. WTF is this nonsense? if you are cop you created a situation where you die and basically anything you say if you live is useless unless we lynch you and prove you are cop. In a faster paced game you absolutely can claim D1, because you can be overlooked and more people have PR, but at max 2 of us do. which means you have screwed the pooch here. it makes it look like you are role fishing.

Spoiler: post 103

Here's a preliminary lead rist:

[Town]

cyrus62

- easily the town leader, ISO feels great

Adorable

- has a decent case on town!robb in 85

Spangled

- a few posts, but I give a weak TR here

RedFlavor

- eh, not feeling much here

Cyan Talon

- I'm not feeling anything here

connorcompton

- I can't be expected to read a player based on one single post

Phone0Ix

- Scum claimer (see 42) and self-voter

Robbnva

- I'm just gonna say Robb is scum

[Scum]

this is fake. looks fake, its skin deep, its sad.

-----
everything robb does looks bad.
-----

Spoiler: post 127

no office intended Adorable but you do realize if you drag the day out and rob still gets lynch and flips scum instead of town you look bad right? just saying not ment to be harsh.

Ok so this is just as bad as what you are making Adorable out to be. Pushing an early lynch and them flipping town masks scum, since theres a whole wagon of people to sort through, why did you bother to post this?

Spoiler: post 161

When I’m gone please pay attention to the back tracking by temporal. He doubled down on me but now two people are advocating I could be town and he backs down without a fight or without any reasons

never mind...

VOTE: Robbnva

At this point I am fairly certain TemporalLich and Robb are scum. there is so much support. You got Temporal fitting every scum tell for an SE, you got robb posting LAMIST posts. This is where I would look at this point.

Spoiler: post 227

When I’m gone please pay attention to the back tracking by temporal. He doubled down on me but now two people are advocating I could be town and he backs down without a fight or without any reasons

Like he said this negated my read.

Why?

He did exactly what I said he did. Why is pointing out the truth suspicious?

I see scum motivation from that post. You're trying to paint me as LHF so you can get me lynched.

most fake looking fight ever!

Spoiler: post 245

gonna shift my vote because I'm thinking TL/Robb is TvT and because of 243 maybe.

VOTE: Cyan Talon

Reading his ISO, 177's read on cyrus doesn't feel genuine and the rest feels lukewarm. Mulling between this and RedFlavor (entire ISO is lukewarm at best) tbh.

oh look, he forgave robb even though he just sr him after a 10 post fight... odd...

-----
have we moved beyond the cop claim? why did this not cause a bigger splash?
-----

Spoiler: post 340

i have to ask red why is temp scum and temp why is red scum or phone scum for that matter

That's indicative of refusing to effort and honestly not playing naturally.

Sounds like you're suggesting a policy lynch to me...

@mod, could we have D1 paused until a replacement for connor is found or similar?

Day will be paused until a replacement for connorcompton will be found

I found this odd too, im standing by a Temporal SR


This is where IM at now, taking a break for a moment.

[Thespio]

VOTE: TemporalLich
Goddamn I looked for at everyone, Im putting my vote here until I am done, so shifty.

[Thespio]

Looked at everyone^

[TemporalLich]

I'd like to point out you just voted a un-CCed cop

[Thespio]

What are the pros and cons of no lynch D1?

Pros:

Power roles get to act?

Cons:

Town loses valuable info that is gained by a mislynch or scum lynch
The game goes to evens and it becomes harder to obtain lynches
Scum still get a nightkill so a D1 NL goes to pretty much D1 with a strong townie dead

A lynch hurts scum and helps town every time. scum already know who is town, we dont, even if a townie dies its better then a NL

[TemporalLich]

yeah, a D1 NL is obviously bad for town

[Thespio]

You claimed cop?

[TemporalLich]

You claimed cop?

yeah, see 525

[Thespio]

You claimed cop?

yeah, see 525

Thats a pretty soft claim, there are a different roles that dont coexist, that looks like you are PR claiming not cop claiming, so this is a hard claim now?

[TemporalLich]

You claimed cop?

yeah, see 525

Thats a pretty soft claim, there are a different roles that dont coexist, that looks like you are PR claiming not cop claiming, so this is a hard claim now?

yeah I've officially gone from a mediumclaim to a hardclaim

[Thespio]

You claimed cop?

yeah, see 525

Thats a pretty soft claim, there are a different roles that dont coexist, that looks like you are PR claiming not cop claiming, so this is a hard claim now?

yeah I've officially gone from a mediumclaim to a hardclaim

I dont buy it even a little, your an SE why are you claiming even a little, if you knew someone was fake claiming as a cop, why not investigate them at night make sure they arent town and hard claim D2?