Gay Dance! [Donezo]

[Bingle]

I really don't think the gay version is more townsided than the original

The pairings are significantly less informative since generally half the pairings are basically forced.

I talked about this in our PT, which I support releasing if that was ever a question, but my problem with gay dance is the not insignificant potential for all scum to be in the same dating pool. Which means that during predance they're pretty well forced to interact heavily and introduces a level of swing that is inferior to normal dance, a setup which I already think is balanced based on town being bad at logic which is a pretty meh setup marker imo.

[Gamma Emerald]

tbh tho, i think i dont belong in the normal dance games.
After what i did on the last one.

What?
I think the only person banned from those is Nancy Drew (for shit reasons but whatever)

[Sakura Hana]

Also im sorry for doubting you Oka!

[Bingle]

The gay version is superior, cuz it's gay. I need no other reason.

bi dance would be strictly better than gay dance. Less exclusive

[chennisden]

having tantrums when being SRed works.

Your AtE was a lot like when i make an AtE as scum.
(I should know i've AtE'd a great portion of my mafia life).
But i didnt know how to explain it.
Heck i never know how to explain my reads except in rare circumstances.

if it helps i was making it hard to explain on purpose.

[Firebringer]

I think the only person banned from those is Nancy Drew (for shit reasons but whatever)

strongly disagree on shit reasons.

[chennisden]

but hhhhhwatever

[Sakura Hana]

i mean my history of dance games is:
Summer Waltz:
Me: "I think as long as i can assure my pair is town, we win, and i think my pair is town"
Pie: "I think DGB could be scum"
Me: "I LEAVE THE DANCE"

Witches Halloween:
Me gets scumread.
Me:"UGH THIS ALWAYS HAPPENS, IM QUITTING MAFIA"
RC: "Just pair with me and die with me on the intermission"
>Rest is history

Gay Dance:
>Bitmap flips town
Me: "FUCK IM GETTING PARANOID"
Me: "I LEAVE THE DANCE"

It's not a good track record.

[Gamma Emerald]

I think the only person banned from those is Nancy Drew (for shit reasons but whatever)

strongly disagree on shit reasons.

Her emotion there was genuine and saying otherwise is fucking disgusting, don't be like Corinne Kaplan in Survivor Gabon telling someone to take anti-depressants so their grief over their dead relative can be genuine, hell no

[Alisae]

having tantrums when being SRed works.

don't do this it doesn't make the game fun for everyone and it doesn't feel good when you win

[chennisden]

having tantrums when being SRed works.

don't do this it doesn't make the game fun for everyone and it doesn't feel good when you win

if you dont cross the line it's okay imo

and "the Line" is EASILY definable.

[chennisden]

btw im fine with releasing all pts im involved in.

[Bingle]

quote sigged, chenn. Your move.

[Firebringer]

I think the only person banned from those is Nancy Drew (for shit reasons but whatever)

strongly disagree on shit reasons.

Her emotion there was genuine and saying otherwise is fucking disgusting, don't be like Corinne Kaplan in Survivor Gabon telling someone to take anti-depressants so their grief over their dead relative can be genuine, hell no

ummm i don't care if she was genuine? her behavior was unacceptable and i think she had plenty of opportunity to recognize that and apologize for what she did and instead pretended everyone else was in the wrong.

as i said, its fine if you empathize with her because you believe her emotions weren't manufactured but its not cool for u to think her behavior was acceptable regardless if it was real or not. Because either way it wasn't.

[Sakura Hana]

having tantrums when being SRed works.

don't do this it doesn't make the game fun for everyone and it doesn't feel good when you win

I don't like it, it just happens coz im an emotional person, and that's why i didnt join Starry Night.

At least here scum tried to pocket me instead of ML me.

[Blake Belladonna]

I really don't think the gay version is more townsided than the original

The pairings are significantly less informative since generally half the pairings are basically forced.

I talked about this in our PT, which I support releasing if that was ever a question, but my problem with gay dance is the not insignificant potential for all scum to be in the same dating pool. Which means that during predance they're pretty well forced to interact heavily and introduces a level of swing that is inferior to normal dance, a setup which I already think is balanced based on town being bad at logic which is a pretty meh setup marker imo.

This I didn't think of. It is a very good point.

[chennisden]

quote sigged, chenn. Your move.

yeah i goteem

[chennisden]

ah, the beauty of the irony of my post

[Alisae]

having tantrums when being SRed works.

don't do this it doesn't make the game fun for everyone and it doesn't feel good when you win

if you dont cross the line it's okay imo

and "the Line" is EASILY definable.

after awhile and during the times I was dealing with a lot of depression and hated everyone, when I randed scum and I got scumread thats what I resorted to and it didn't end well for me almost ever and I never had fun.

[Sakura Hana]

I mean, you wouldnt imagine the ammount of times mafia's made me cry.
It's a PTSD at this point.
Yet somehow i keep coming back.

[Bingle]

Mafia is a zero sum fun game. The trick is to ensure every one else is miserable. That way you have all of the available fun.

[pienyan]

^I'd be scared of playing that card tbh.

P-edit: And people wonder why I quit, too.

[chennisden]

if it helps i think u played well!

all i'd say you shouldn't have done was
1) randomly paranoia pie for no good reason (this is the BIG and obvious one)
2) tunnel on me being scum. like yeah i was scum but ur playing to lynch me not to get postgame credit when i mislynch the last t/t pair. in fact i think it gave me a couple of things: 1) paranoia on ur pair 2) a scapegoat for "these r bad reasons for SRing me" (fb helped too) and 3) made it plausible i wouldn't be NKed.

[chennisden]

that was @ sakura.

[chennisden]

pie don't quit because of me

you were fun