Detective Penguin & City of Fogport [Game Over]

[Kagami]

And if you have a role that demands you be killed to stop it, you absolutely, 107% act. That includes Vig.

[Day One Wagon]

Is it bad that I feel uneasy about Jingle?

No. If you don't feel uneasy about Jingle, Jingle has either broken the setup or Jingle is scum going for the power wolf.

I haven't broken the setup and I would never go for the power wolf of the back of Role Call considering the player list is like 70% the same.

What if it's your plan to fool everyone and do something no one expects?

But seriously, I feel like you pushing setup speculation way too far with info we have and we'd be better, if we do more actual scumhunting instead

[Bingle]

Half the town should act. If you have a role that you expect to be in the upper 50 percentile in terms of power, you should act.

That is like the single least effective way to ensure we don't get caffeine endgamed. Congrats.

And if you have a role that demands you be killed to stop it, you absolutely, 107% act. That includes Vig.

:Thorface:

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Back! Now www (where were we)? Ah.. The Wall. I believe that was a gimmick account made by Gorky?
Anyway, Roger Waters must've been high when he wrote this. Calling every single fan of yours another brick in the wall in nonsense. And the irony is the bricks made it a successful record too...

What? The game?? Oh, YES.. the game.. that's a movie by Michael Douglas & Sean Penn, and directed by David Fincher.

Now let me go back to read the rest of the case on me

[Bingle]

What if it's your plan to fool everyone and do something no one expects?

That's why I wouldn't powerwolf this game as scum.

But seriously, I feel like you pushing setup speculation way too far with info we have and we'd be better, if we do more actual scumhunting instead

Sure. But setup spec is the thing I can do easily without devoting a lot of time to this game. I'll scumhunt as I can, but I'm busy rn with RL and prepping for something that I care about waaay more than this game, as cool as it is. #sorrynotsorry

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

You hadn't outed yourself as an alt yet, so I'm not sure how I would have responded to this if you had.

I mean, every player on MS and their uncle know that JJD is AP and AP is A50, but OK, I'll pretend that you thought it was a secret alt.

Disclaimer: I am referring ti the players who have regularly been on the site for the past couple of years. If someone hadn't been playing for 6 years they wouldn't know A50 to begin with.

As for how to respond, I would have expected a chuckle, maybe.. but I guess it wasn't that funny to you in retrospect.

[Kagami]

Scum are going to have 6 kills tops during the period where caffeine matters, Bingle.

Unless town opts to selectively lynch decaffeinated players, then we'll be fine as long as people are at least reasonably selective.

If there's a Doc, which seems pretty likely, that already does a lot to make it very difficult to effect a caffeine endgame.

[Kagami]

Is AP angryPidgeon?

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

As a stranger

Stranger?

Subject: Legacy of the Void -- Dead PT

Almost50's play is not particularly impressive this game. But he is fun to play with.

I don't see how you thought I was fun to play with if you considered me a stranger, but whatever. I consider you an acquaintance ftr, not a complete stranger.

[popsofctown]

Yes as of the post I was discussing I did not know JJD was an alt. So I was dealing with a stranger.

[popsofctown]

You are so proud of how distinctly your alts play so why does it surprise you I didn't know who you were. No one told me

[Chandra Nalaar]

scum-pops

I thought we were talking about marquis

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

If Judge Joseph Dredd wins as a bastard role

My role isn't bastard. In fact it aligns with the Normal Roles Guidelines.

[Judge Joseph Dredd]

Actually, no it doesn't.
I wouldn't be calling it a bastard role though.

[Kagami]

scum-pops

I thought we were talking about marquis

I don't have a strong opinion about marquis anymore, beyond that I suspect almost every individual role claim we've had so far is at least partially a lie.

[Kagami]

I find D1L <--> pops interactions very suspect, but still think Fish is just correct.

[Chandra Nalaar]

Jk sorry I got confused

Yeah your post makes sense too, I'm not so good at the mechanical side of the game as you probably know

I want to push back on your point about read alignment but I'm learning that I am most likely the exception when it comes to that

[Bingle]

Is AP angryPidgeon?

God I wish. Nah, it's an Austin Powers themed Gimmick alt.

Madbird is gone for good because political differences AFAIK.

[Kagami]

Somehow I've never managed to get in a political discussion during a game of mafia.

[Kagami]

I liked AP :<

[Day One Wagon]

JJD, stop

[Bingle]

JJD is AP and AP is A50

Uh. I didn't. And I interact with A50 a lot. Like, a lot a lot.

It seems perfectly reasonable to me.

[Chandra Nalaar]

Somehow I've never managed to get in a political discussion during a game of mafia.

Kagami, what is your opinion of the 1889 Act to Regulate Appointments in the Marine Hospital Service of the United States?

[Bingle]

Somehow I've never managed to get in a political discussion during a game of mafia.

I wasn't around for it, but I was told he got bullied for being a conservative and sitequit. Despite that, he's still on my list of top ten scummers of all time, and probably the individual player who I consider the best at scumhunting, including all of the current bignames like RC.

[Chandra Nalaar]

I liked AP too, but the politics mar my memories. :$