Magical Girls UPick - Heart of Shadow (Game Over)

[Katsuki]

Hey RC, if you ever think I'm going to read a game that pumps out 60pgs over the span of a single weekend, you're sorely mistaken.

I'll work my magic when the game becomes more playable, but not before then.

[Lady Eventide]

Hey RC, if you ever think I'm going to read a game that pumps out 60pgs over the span of a single weekend, you're sorely mistaken.

I'll work my magic when the game becomes more playable, but not before then.

And if you are shot in the night?

[Katsuki]

Then fun things will happen.

I'll take this opportunity to say that if there is some retard out there who would ever consider vigging me, don't do it N1. I can easily break this game so scum if you're gonna NK, come at me.

[Lady Eventide]

... @Katsuki: I think it is relevant to note that your current level of contribution compares unfavorably to both Chaos Wind and Cafe Stiles. You barely have more presence than

Croag.

I don't really care how much of a hotshot scumfinder you supposedly are; lurking to lategame like this is unacceptable behaviour, and T&E are right to call you on it.

[Lady Eventide]

Then fun things will happen.

I'll take this opportunity to say that if there is some retard out there who would ever consider vigging me, don't do it N1. I can easily break this game so scum if you're gonna NK, come at me.

Nice wine, plus a personal attack and a blatant attempt to direct night actions. Really not seeing anything here that endears you to me.

Go on, please tell this "retard" why you deserve a free pass.

VOTE: Katsuki

[gameplay506]

Can you like
Pressure people without changing your vote every 2 pages?

[Hidden Happiness]

I'm saying this as a list mod not a player. I strongly suggest you stop using the R word.
~Celica/Maria

[Tana and Ephraim]

Tana and Ephraim are very much in their scum ranges and have done almost nothing that I’ve seen to make me warrant a townread on them

So this is how you're going to be like huh
-Tana

[Cafe Stile]

I know there's a wagon on us but let me catch up then I'll entertain the wagon if it really was for anything other to get us to post, ok

just so y'all know Maika is a little inexperienced and gets cold feet when she wants to post something and I'm just really lazy or at work

- Hideri

[Lady Eventide]

Can you like
Pressure people without changing your vote every 2 pages?

Actions speak louder than words. Votes are town's primary weapons; leaving them idle is not a good thing.

[Tana and Ephraim]

I swear to god if people keep trying to read me like this.

What's wrong with it? The point is if at the end of the day, the read is correct, no?
-Tana

[Tana and Ephraim]

Actually on second thought, I realize that you might have said something bad and not something else, so you dont have to answer that question.
-Tana

[Tana and Ephraim]

But if you dislike it that much then I'll try to find another way to read you.
-Tana

[Cafe Stile]

evidence that I'm reading.

Tana and Ephraim (Sakura Hana + RadiantCowbells) [X]: arrogance 401 reminds me of town, i like the pops push, I'm ok with the interaction with SS, but there's definitely some hokey: i.e. FoTM.

Bitmap [X]: lean town - I liked her grasp on eventide + I think the culling of discussion on game play is fair.

RCEnigma [X]: i think voting, inactive is typically scum as in 452.

Dannflor [X]: mmm, weak town read, but 533 interests me. does scum dan take a consiliatory tone towards his scum reads? his flop between SS-town vs scum makes me wary but could be cause he's a nice fellow.

Sailor Senshi (Shiro + Krazy + Nancy Drew 39) [X]: Nothing AI imo. But I'm town reading for [redacted] reasons

Gamma Emerald [X]: town, like the action of 383 attacking LLD, I also think pages 18-19 attacking bitmap is town driven, as agreement with most of the people. I liked his mediation - that was in good faith. Might be my strongest town read at the moment.

popsofctown [X]: lean scum, vote switch galore, hop on bitmap was no good imo. Other reasons here or there

Titus [X]: town, push lurkers, solid interaction with rc, etc.

Lady Eventide (Evenstar + Lillaire)[X]: scummy. but weak scummy, as discussed by bitmap and Dann. I thought "liliare felt bad" was town, but still nothing substantial by any means.

gameplay506 [X]: 714's summary is lame, but it's probably a town summary.

Whoever was saying this post is villagery, uh what?
Too lazy to read into contexts, but these reads are safe reads, and the reasoning are mostly weak or wishywashy
Just - I don't get the sense that this is a post made to show progress on reads, but more like "yo im here im doing things" that comes more from scum

hmm

Eventide's vote on SS is pretty shoddy. being pressured leading to spat is a terribly weak reason to scum read people... what do you want, that after being pressured you just lay down and die?

I don't think gameplay is scum, but please don't use personal RL stuff as a point of attack.

If Eventide would flip scum, Titus's (hello titus!) attack on gameplay is very much chainsaw.

That last line pings wolf
It doesn't do anything in terms of pressuring Eva, and Titus is his townread. It doesn't make sense for town with those sets of reads to shade Titus and Eva here
Titus attacked on gameplay before Eva even posted so it wasn't even correct

~~~~~~~~~~~
gameplay is locktown for us until further notice
~~~~~~~~~~~

hmm

Eventide's vote on SS is pretty shoddy. being pressured leading to spat is a terribly weak reason to scum read people... what do you want, that after being pressured you just lay down and die?

I don't think gameplay is scum, but please don't use personal RL stuff as a point of attack.

If Eventide would flip scum, Titus's (hello titus!) attack on gameplay is very much chainsaw.

Pressure leading to

personal attacks and threats of reporting

is very much a scumtell. Pressure leading to

debate and defense

is

not;

it's the fact that it got personal very quickly that's pinging me. Personal arguments don't say shit about the gamestate, and therefore mafia want to cast any disagreement with them as a personal issue, not a legitimate argument based on real evidence. I've straight up called a townie a bitch and an asshole to cover for a scumslip I made. I'm not

proud

of that, but it's a thing that I did.

-Evenstar

not necessarily related to this quote but I get the sense that Eva being open to their past meta is a lot different from when she played wolf and muddied the entire game with AtE and shit

[Cafe Stile]

RCEnigma feels really underwhelming compared to Krazy's game

[Cafe Stile]

I did read other (finished) games of yours and the specific tell that I was referring to earlier in this thread was from -not the MU game that you linked-.
However it is also present in that game so I feel a lot safer simply citing 'reasons' as I have been doing to date.

Uhh has there been an elaboration of this or do we gotta wait for a season 2

[Cafe Stile]

The fact that both LLD and Katsuki have expressed intent to lurk is beyond concerning and I don't think either slot should be left alive past even day 1 if they are lurking.

Which head made this post?

That was E, all untagged posts are E

I wanna say Gamma paying no attention is town indicative lol

[Dannflor]

I think that's just Gamma, I've seen that kind of posting as both alignments. I think he's town here regardless though.

I'm home now and drafting up a reads list. I'll answer any direct questions if anyone has them while I'm working on it though

[Cafe Stile]

hotto take Chemist in Page 39 is bad but a townie bad

[popsofctown]

Why did you RVS someone you haven't played with before? Most people do the contrary?

I honestly don't think I'll solve the game with this I just feel challenged about making a question

[Dannflor]

I picked someone random who already had a vote on them with the hopes of maybe building a super early wagon.

[popsofctown]

*wolf noises*

[Sailor Senshi]

Tana and Ephraim are very much in their scum ranges and have done almost nothing that I’ve seen to make me warrant a townread on them

So this is how you're going to be like huh
-Tana

Dont listen to the voice Sakura, we know you are town, have a hug.


This was my brief messege, remember folks Shiro loves you, goodnight



SS Venus

[Titus]

Can we just vote Bitmap or Lady? Thanks.

[Bitmap]

no