Large Normal 223 | New Beginnings | GAME OVER

[Titus]

with the risk of 3 confirmed your prob going to have to kill in them ?

Best way to survive a myriad of conftown is to get yourself placed in.

Maybe I'm crazy but a scum rolecop communicates his results.

And he no doubt could. But would have settle for outing them in thread

Agreed. Which if you're correct that's a valuable source. If I'm correct, then no crumbs = profli scum.

Do you agree?

[bob3141]

proffi can not be scum with gobble. why would gobble be traitor then>

[Titus]

proffi can not be scum with gobble. why would gobble be traitor then>

Loss mechanic. White flag partially. Reduce scum power by forcing a game of telephone. Pretty ingenious actually.

[profii]

@JJD - Just to mention, I now have a notekeeping thread, obviously if you want you can read it post game. It's not that exciting yet but I'll probably go page by page like your game to break the game into bite size chunks

This is as close to a crumb you will get from me
When gobbldegook said he gunsmithed me I figured he was paranoid about me as I didnt give much away in the hood so wanted to check me and essentially make us like masons

So I believed his claim and just used my hood thread as a note keeping place from when G claimed gunsmith

So I said this as a reference to reveal I have a PT - ie the hood thread

I think its more subtle than trying to shoehorn in some weird expression like "heard a weird noise coming from next door last night" or whatever

[profii]

Also JJD posted that if Tchil was a scum tracker and he died, not only do scum lose a tracker, but town gain one which is a huge swing in the game

So we have to decide - is that feasible given the claims so far or if there is a tracker lurking , do we want them to CC

[profii]

Rick, whats your read on Kop?

Strong town PR.

I get it

[bob3141]

proffi can not be scum with gobble. why would gobble be traitor then>

Loss mechanic. White flag partially. Reduce scum power by forcing a game of telephone. Pretty ingenious actually.

doesnt that defeat the point of scum not knowing who the traitor is

[texcat]

Titus, Gobble clearly crumbed that he was traitor in 2143, and his first post of the day was 2028 which I think could be a crumb of his role cop results, but I'm not sure how to interpret the italized oven.

[profii]

Who knows titus well enough to answer this:

The theory that I could be scum in a hood with the traitor is pretty out there - I am sure most would agree.

So do we think Titus is posting this because she is considering a crazy mechanic or has some paranoia over my very close to conf-town status

Or

Is titus the sort of player to raise a crazy theory to appear paranoid, ie does Titus, as town, usually come over a bit more rational with these sorts of theories?


Personally, I think this is town motivated paranoia but I haven't played much and I dont recall playing with Titus (sorry if we have played before!)

[profii]

Titus, Gobble clearly crumbed that he was traitor in 2143, and his first post of the day was 2028 which I think could be a crumb of his role cop results, but I'm not sure how to interpret the italized oven.

I dont understand the 2143 reference

[Titus]

proffi can not be scum with gobble. why would gobble be traitor then>

Loss mechanic. White flag partially. Reduce scum power by forcing a game of telephone. Pretty ingenious actually.

doesnt that defeat the point of scum not knowing who the traitor is

That assumes that's the purpose of the traitor.

@Profli, I'm well known for checking out confirming logic. I'm not voting you for a reason, you're not confirmed town though.

[Titus]

Titus, Gobble clearly crumbed that he was traitor in 2143, and his first post of the day was 2028 which I think could be a crumb of his role cop results, but I'm not sure how to interpret the italized oven.

This supports profli town

[profii]

proffi can not be scum with gobble. why would gobble be traitor then>

Loss mechanic. White flag partially. Reduce scum power by forcing a game of telephone. Pretty ingenious actually.

doesnt that defeat the point of scum not knowing who the traitor is

That assumes that's the purpose of the traitor.

@Profli, I'm well known for checking out confirming logic. I'm not voting you for a reason, you're not confirmed town though.

I'm assuming you are town unless half the player list jump in and say you are some kind of scum genius that would do this

I said very near to conf town which isnt unfair I think

[Titus]

Tbh, some would say I am.

What about Garmr?

[Garmr]

Tbh, some would say I am.

What about Garmr?

I would say Garmr is Town

[Titus]

VOTE: Garmr

[profii]

Tbh, some would say I am.

What about Garmr?

Hes on my reading list I'll get back to you

[Garmr]

VOTE: Garmr

Big Brain

[Garmr]

VC please

Garmr, you know I don't read on subbing in?

Yeah but I want to be confirmed town.

Why would my read make you conftown?

Because you never read me right in the numerous games we played. Was waiting for you to vote me

I can finally be confirmed town.

[davesaz]

Oven ... cook cooked baked baker roast cake cookie done burnt hot heat heater...
Anyone else have some free associations for that word? Any non English translations that would be meaningful?

[davesaz]

Actually kinda on the fence if I want answers to that. On one hand scum have a pt to be discussing it and town may need to counter with combined brainpower otoh don’t want to out a role...

[Carcalilly]

I already felt as if profii was town before the whole shpeel

I don't believe in wolf Titus. The stuff on her seems more pushy then necessary.

[Carcalilly]

y'all should take a solid second and deeply consider the normal guidelines before hanging someone up as conftown.

[davesaz]

I got the first half of that last one but not the 2nd half -- hanging up a conftown as in scumreading / lynching someone who should be conf, or confing someone prematurely based on something that should be contrary to guidelines?

[Garmr]

Random power role- I don't think we should lynch garmr today becuase of my role.

Everyone else- Lets run a counter wagon on garmr against probable scum and pretend there isn't any case on judge.