Perfect Masquerade [Game Over]

[Gentleman 3]

A fresh set of eyes is rarely a bad thing to have in a game that devolved to how it currently is.

No, of course not. But it's a little hypocritical to say "make sure to give me time to get reads out before you kill me-- and also, you shouldn't be listening to the reads of dead townies."

[Lady 5]

L7 is a scumread based off primarily how she is structuring her posts.

Explain.

She talks in words that look like they're solving, but the way she's going about it looks like she's reading off a powerpoint slide rather than actually solving.

[Gentleman 3]

I agree with this quite a bit, and the only thing that would change my mind on this is if L5/G8 flips T/T.

Why would that change your mind?

[Gentleman 3]

She talks in words that look like they're solving, but the way she's going about it looks like she's reading off a powerpoint slide rather than actually solving.

Sounds like a personality thing.

[Lady 5]

A fresh set of eyes is rarely a bad thing to have in a game that devolved to how it currently is.

No, of course not. But it's a little hypocritical to say "make sure to give me time to get reads out before you kill me-- and also, you shouldn't be listening to the reads of dead townies."

No?

I said sheeping town is mot productive in a game like this. I assumed that it would be clear what I meant since you had just told me beforehand that you weren't going to take what I say into account if I reach a different conclusion than G6.

[Lady 7]

I haven’t taken it fully back g7! I’m just concerned that l9 is setting up the game for a scum win.

I guess I’ll have to wait a bit to hear the structuring scumtell. If it is what I think it is, it was a bad tell floating around a few sites a few years ago and should have never been born. But if it’s not gonna hat, I look forward to hearing a new bad tell!

Lady 2 - *hug*. I’m sorry you’re having troubles. I hope you feel better soon. Depression is no fun.

Edit: nope it’s a new one. I’ll have you know my power points are just outlines that I never read from. I think the better description of them came from another player long ago who said it’s like reading a diary of someone’s thoughts as they’re floating around trying to make sense if the game.

I’d never read straight from a power point. I’m no amateur!

[Gentleman 3]

I'm just confused about why it's so important that we let you get your reads in, then.

Pedit: @L5

[Lady 5]

If you don't think my reads matter, then you don't have to humor me in the first place.

[Gentleman 3]

Do you think your reads matter?

[Lady 7]

Or as meaner people say, I just say a lot of nothing

But better people can see I’m getting my thoughts out there, and sometimes I have good thoughts, and from that we can work together to solve the game. Sometimes :/

[Lady 5]

Do you think your reads matter?

This is a non nonquestion in practice.

Whether my reads matter or not depends on whether there's any chance that there will be any results from me putting the effort in to solve. Obviously my reads don't matter regardless of accuracy if this isn't the case.

[Lady 5]

Or as meaner people say, I just say a lot of nothing

But better people can see I’m getting my thoughts out there, and sometimes I have good thoughts, and from that we can work together to solve the game. Sometimes :/

Was the condescension necessary?

[Gentleman 3]

Whether my reads matter or not depends on whether there's any chance that there will be any results from me putting the effort in to solve. Obviously my reads don't matter regardless of accuracy if this isn't the case.

Do you think people SHOULD be listening to your reads after you die, assuming you're lynched next and flip town?

[Lady 5]

That depends on if I have had enough time to determine my accuracy or not.

[Lady 7]

Or as meaner people say, I just say a lot of nothing

But better people can see I’m getting my thoughts out there, and sometimes I have good thoughts, and from that we can work together to solve the game. Sometimes :/

Was the condescension necessary?

Um?

What?

I don’t know how me amused at how people have approached my posts in the past has anything to do with you, but you’re the one who called my actual town thoughts and attempts to read the game and solve it like I’m reading from a power point rather than solving, so Im not sure what your reaction is about here.

[Lady 5]

I guess I’ll have to wait a bit to hear the structuring scumtell. If it is what I think it is, it was a bad tell floating around a few sites a few years ago and should have never been born. But if it’s not gonna hat, I look forward to hearing a new bad tell!

But better people can see I’m getting my thoughts out there, and sometimes I have good thoughts, and from that we can work together to solve the game. Sometimes :/

[Lady 7]

I guess I’ll have to wait a bit to hear the structuring scumtell. If it is what I think it is, it was a bad tell floating around a few sites a few years ago and should have never been born. But if it’s not gonna hat, I look forward to hearing a new bad tell!

But better people can see I’m getting my thoughts out there, and sometimes I have good thoughts, and from that we can work together to solve the game. Sometimes :/

Those don’t even go together. You just chopped things up to take it out of context to try to be offended.

[Lady 7]

I haven’t taken it fully back g7! I’m just concerned that l9 is setting up the game for a scum win

A.
I guess I’ll have to wait a bit to hear the structuring scumtell. If it is what I think it is, it was a bad tell floating around a few sites a few years ago and should have never been born. But if it’s not gonna hat, I look forward to hearing a new bad tell!

Lady 2 - *hug*. I’m sorry you’re having troubles. I hope you feel better soon. Depression is no fun.

B.
Edit: nope it’s a new one. I’ll have you know my power points are just outlines that I never read from. I think the better description of them came from another player long ago who said it’s like reading a diary of someone’s thoughts as they’re floating around trying to make sense if the game.

I’d never read straight from a power point. I’m no amateur!

A and B fro this post go together. B is me acknowledging that it’s not the tell I thought you were going to go with, and then making a bit of a joke about myself.

[Lady 5]

Whatever you say, L7.

[Lady 5]

None of this is productive.

I will be back later.

[Lady 7]

Or as meaner people say, I just say a lot of nothing

But better people can see I’m getting my thoughts out there, and sometimes I have good thoughts, and from that we can work together to solve the game. Sometimes :/

These two go together and continue what people have said about my posts.

[Gentleman 3]

Whatever you say, L7.

Who's being condescending now :/

[Lady 7]

I’m just thrown that something I said as partly self-deprecating is somehow condescending.

[Lady 6]

We are in a really difficult situation. L5 creeps me out. Despite being a confirmed replacement, the tone is eerily similar. I really detest the fact both G6 and G5 died. I really don't like leading early but I feel compelled to take charge here.

Lady 7, I know you didn't like how I phrased things. There's not much I can do on that. The only thing that can be done is continuing to scumhunt. The feeling on you is mutual, but I think you're likely town. If I knew your main, I could assess much easier if the collective was correct on you.

[Lady 5]

L7, I hope it's clear upon me stating it that it's easy to see an immediate response of immediately assuming it's a bad tell that never works, and then later insinuating that I'm a bad player for thinking that a read like that is scummy as condescending.

Because it read that way to me.