Newbie 1967 | GAME OVER

[RadiantCowbells]

no i mean your townread on it

it is of itself meaningless to me, neither scum indicative nor town indicative

what i struggle with is finding it outright town indicative.

[skitter30]

Idk in vaccum i think that's more likely to come from newbtown than newbscum, it belies a certain level of ~carefreeness~ imo

[RadiantCowbells]

Arkias is not at all new to forum mafia.

[skitter30]

Like i said i have no idea what their experience level is

That puts a diff spin on it tho

[BigFatDonald]

Does anyone have any strong scum reads?

[RadiantCowbells]

I have a relatively strong scumread on Arkias.

[BigFatDonald]

I have a relatively strong scumread on Arkias.

I think George bailey is scum

[Arkias]

Arkias is not at all new to forum mafia.

I have legit played 2 games, and I'm not far along on either.

I played in the KoL Forums

years

ago, back when the meta was

every single person gets a role

. Im only decent at Tos/ToL. But with this pushing, Imma go ahead and

VOTE: RC

[skitter30]

Arkias is not at all new to forum mafia.

Why do u think this?

[GeorgeBailey]

Does anyone have any strong scum reads?

No, but I think I have two town reads. You and Skitter. Your entrance feels really Newb!Town. Idk if Scum playing off as Newb would really go through the effort of asking for Profile Pic, asking definitions, etc. Feels like Newb!Scum would stay quiet and ask their partner in the PT. And it seems like Skitter is trying really hard to move the discussion to a more serious one. Scum is probably enjoying the confusion/'apathy'.

[RadiantCowbells]

Forum oughtn't have been in the phrasing but I still think that's a scummy as fuck reaction and it's only helping my feeling that you're scum.

[GeorgeBailey]

I think George bailey is scum

ouch, can you expand on why you think this?

[RadiantCowbells]

Arkias is scum dudette.

[RadiantCowbells]

VOTE: Arkias

[Naerys]

Huh
I dont know anything about arkias so idk

I'm not getting great vibes off of naerys

That´s fine.
I am not getting great vibes off of bugspray.

[RadiantCowbells]

Honestly I was already not too happy about your slot Skitter but you not seeing this makes me feel even worse and if I hadn't just errantly scumread you in dead threads 3 times in a row for not seeing a read when I thought that it was obvious that you should I would probably be calling you scum right now for it.

Arkias feels incredibly muted. There's a lot I can't say about this read because of site rules. But I am like 85-90% confident that this is scum.

[BigFatDonald]

I think George bailey is scum

ouch, can you expand on why you think this?

Nevermind i dont even have a reason im a big noob

[GeorgeBailey]

Nevermind i dont even have a reason im a big noob

Er, could you at least tell me what you were thinking at the time? If you keep calling people scum, then rescinding it, it doesn't really help. What at least made you say that?

[eth0s]

Official Vote Count 1.05

Lynching

With 9 living players it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Arkias (3):

bugspray, PvtUrist, RadiantCowbells

BigFatDonald (1):

Sera Masumi

Sera Masumi (1):

GeorgeBailey

Naerys (1):

skitter30

RadiantCowbells (1):

Arkias

Not Voting (2):

Naerys, BigFatDonald

Deadline:

(expired on 2019-12-03 13:20:00).

Mod notes:

n/a[/area]

[RadiantCowbells]

I do like in the context of this game think that we have a striking tendency to never catch the same scum so I'm not really passing judgement on it.

But I think that you should be able to understand where my read comes from and townreading them for calling themselves scum in the readslist seems really level 0.

[RadiantCowbells]

Like it -feels- like you're rejecting the read outright and looking for reasons to reject it moreso than that you're actually rejecting it because that's the way the reasons go. And I know I've felt this way before and been wrong. But yeah I just don't get where your pov comes from and I'd appreciate a better explanation of it?

[skitter30]

Does anyone have any strong scum reads?

No, but I think I have two town reads. You and Skitter. Your entrance feels really Newb!Town. Idk if Scum playing off as Newb would really go through the effort of asking for Profile Pic, asking definitions, etc. Feels like Newb!Scum would stay quiet and ask their partner in the PT. And it seems like Skitter is trying really hard to move the discussion to a more serious one. Scum is probably enjoying the confusion/'apathy'.

Oh this is lowkey townie, i think

[RadiantCowbells]

I agree

[skitter30]

Honestly I was already not too happy about your slot Skitter but you not seeing this makes me feel even worse and if I hadn't just errantly scumread you in dead threads 3 times in a row for not seeing a read when I thought that it was obvious that you should I would probably be calling you scum right now for it.

Arkias feels incredibly muted. There's a lot I can't say about this read because of site rules. But I am like 85-90% confident that this is scum.

Ok, not sure i see your read tbh

Can we both collectively try not to take over the thread given newbie game etc?

(Not saying you are rn just asking like in general)

[skitter30]

Nevermind i dont even have a reason im a big noob

Er, could you at least tell me what you were thinking at the time? If you keep calling people scum, then rescinding it, it doesn't really help. What at least made you say that?

He's done the rescinding thing a couple of times now, when pressed