Mini Normal 2107 (Game Over)

[Elbirn]

Rats

[Eve]

fantastic news

[Montosh]

VC 4.FINAL

Saladman27 (5): UltimatePlank, Eve, Elements, profii, Elbirn (Lynch)

Eve (2):

alimdia, Saladman27

Elbirn (1):

Wake88

With 8 alive, it takes 5 to lynch

Deadline: (expired on 2019-12-09 02:15:00)

[Montosh]

Oh the man of Salad
He wanted a ballad
About his death
To sing with his final breath
But the people of the town, adding some more mystery to the mix
Asked "If you're the 27th man of Salad, then what happened to the other 26?"
That's a fine question and all, but what do you want, a brownie?
Well you get nothing, because Saladman27 was a...

Spoiler:

Vanilla Townie

Welcome, Saladman27, to Mini 2107! Your role is

Vanilla Townie.

You have no special powers.

You win when all mafia members are dead and at least one town member remains alive.

Night 4 begins. It will end in (expired on 2019-12-11 02:00:00). Please submit all night actions by then.

[Montosh]

The night was a place of safety, they thought
No one had committed crimes, well... they'd not been caught
Police! Call the police! We've found a body here!
Said the poor townsfolk, shaking with fear.
Where's the doctor? Maybe there's something he can do?
Afraid not. See, the doctor's through.

alimdia was a...

Spoiler:

Town One-Shot Bulletproof Night 3 Doctor

Welcome, alimdia, to Mini 2107! Your role is

Town One-Shot Bulletproof Night 3 Doctor.

The first time you would be killed at night, you will instead survive.
On Night 3, you may target another player. That player will be protected from one kill.

You win when all mafia members are dead and at least one town member remains alive.

Day 5 Begins!

VC 5.0

Not voting (6):

Eve, Elements, UltimatePlank, Elbirn, profii, Wake88

With 6 alive, it takes 4 to lynch

Deadline: (expired on 2019-12-21 08:00:00)

[Wake1]

OK so that helps explain why there was at least one no-kill, and likely a 2nd.

[Wake1]

Oh shit there's only 6 of us left.

[profii]

What do you mean likely a 2nd ... do you not have faith in your JK

[Wake1]

What do you mean likely a 2nd ... do you not have faith in your JK

We had 3 no-kills, profii, in a row.

Assuming my JK N3 protected you, that means there were still 2 no-kills on days 1 and 2.

...

Then again, alimdia may have used his Doctor ability N3 and stopped the kill, and you may in fact still be Scum, because my Loyal JK ability on you would not have worked if you were Scum.

[Wake1]

I'm thinking we should start here.

VOTE: profii

[Elements]

so you're saying because there's a possibility ali healed someone you're loyal JK must have failed on profii?

[Elements]

VOTE: plank

[UltimatePlank]

I think we massclaim and potentially nolynch today

Tomorrow is mylo potential if we lynch now from a pool of 6

If we nolynch today, we lynch from.pool.of 5 and then it puts us at a lylo of 3 people.

Basically either way we need to get one correct lynch for town to win, but we're statistically better off nolynching today.

1/4 and then 1/2 odds compared to 1/5 and 1/3 (at Mylo)

Or we can nolynch tomorrow, but it doesn't really make senae to not take better odds today also

[UltimatePlank]

I'm thinking we should start here.

VOTE: profii

i dont

[Wake1]

so you're saying because there's a possibility ali healed someone you're loyal JK must have failed on profii?

If he is Scum for the reasons I listed and we do nothing based on this, then what do we do?

[Wake1]

I think a mass-claim is in order.

Perhaps someone could be caught in a lie.

[profii]

What do you mean likely a 2nd ... do you not have faith in your JK

We had 3 no-kills, profii, in a row.

Assuming my JK N3 protected you, that means there were still 2 no-kills on days 1 and 2.

...

Then again, alimdia may have used his Doctor ability N3 and stopped the kill, and you may in fact still be Scum, because my Loyal JK ability on you would not have worked if you were Scum.

I'll try and make this super clear:

NIGHT 1 - no kill - explaination - not locked down but very certain in my mind - Ali was a very strong advocate for the Looker lynch, therefore a highly likely target. He flipped bullet proof. This makes sense. I'm not really going to entertain any other theories unless they are very compelling.

NIGHT 2 - no kill - unexplained - we have no claims to suggest anyone was bullet proof or protected on night 2 so it's a mystery as to why scum didnt kill.

NIGHT 3 - no kill - 2 explainations: 1) Wake Loyal JK on Profii - if we believe the claim, you protected me, I might have been the target. 2) Ali protected Elbirn - Ali flipped town doc, so he is almost certainly telling the truth. But that only means Elbirn MIGHT have been the target, which does not confirm me or Elbirn. My opinion is that at least one of scenarios 1) & 2) actually happened but we can't prove either. There is also a possbility both 1) and 2) happened so both of us are town.

[profii]

I think we massclaim and potentially nolynch today

Tomorrow is mylo potential if we lynch now from a pool of 6

If we nolynch today, we lynch from.pool.of 5 and then it puts us at a lylo of 3 people.

Basically either way we need to get one correct lynch for town to win, but we're statistically better off nolynching today.

1/4 and then 1/2 odds compared to 1/5 and 1/3 (at Mylo)

Or we can nolynch tomorrow, but it doesn't really make senae to not take better odds today also

Do we want to mass claim pre-no lynch and tell scum who the PRs are (if there are any left, it's a mystery obviously)

I do agree with a no lynch today though.

[profii]

so you're saying because there's a possibility ali healed someone you're loyal JK must have failed on profii?

no reason ali healed Elbirn and I sat in jail doing nothing at all

VOTE: plank

what?

[Wake1]

What do you mean likely a 2nd ... do you not have faith in your JK

We had 3 no-kills, profii, in a row.

Assuming my JK N3 protected you, that means there were still 2 no-kills on days 1 and 2.

...

Then again, alimdia may have used his Doctor ability N3 and stopped the kill, and you may in fact still be Scum, because my Loyal JK ability on you would not have worked if you were Scum.

I'll try and make this super clear:

NIGHT 1 - no kill - explaination - not locked down but very certain in my mind - Ali was a very strong advocate for the Looker lynch, therefore a highly likely target. He flipped bullet proof. This makes sense. I'm not really going to entertain any other theories unless they are very compelling.

NIGHT 2 - no kill - unexplained - we have no claims to suggest anyone was bullet proof or protected on night 2 so it's a mystery as to why scum didnt kill.

NIGHT 3 - no kill - 2 explainations: 1) Wake Loyal JK on Profii - if we believe the claim, you protected me, I might have been the target. 2) Ali protected Elbirn - Ali flipped town doc, so he is almost certainly telling the truth. But that only means Elbirn MIGHT have been the target, which does not confirm me or Elbirn. My opinion is that at least one of scenarios 1) & 2) actually happened but we can't prove either. There is also a possbility both 1) and 2) happened so both of us are town.

Alimdia was N3 Doctor, but 1-Shot BP, which was continuous since Day 1. Alimdia could have been hit during any of those 3 Nights I think.

[Elements]

so you're saying because there's a possibility ali healed someone you're loyal JK must have failed on profii?

no reason ali healed Elbirn and I sat in jail doing nothing at all

VOTE: plank

what?

My current views:
The last scum was on the Salad wagon.
They were not the hammer on the Salad wagon.
That leaves the last scum in Plank, Eve, Profii.
Of those three I think Plank is the most likely scum.

[profii]

because...?

[Wake1]

I don't like how we're assuming Elbirn is Town because Wimpy site-flaked.

At first when I Townread him I didn't know he left the whole site.

He shouldn't be Townread just for that.

[Elements]

because...?

to which bit?

[Wake1]

Are we claiming or not?

Do we have any results or not?