Mainstream Mafia II: D&D Edition [FIN]

[Iconeum]

all of what, 3 votes?

[Miss Lane]

If I'm scum, why would I come forth without a ton of pressure with a semi-redirector claim

If I'm cult, why would I come forth without a ton of pressure with a semi-redirector claim

All while being hyped I ate a NK that didn't go through (probably)

there was a ton of pressure
trying to deny it is silly

[Miss Lane]

all of what, 3 votes?

i forgot that votes are the only way to apply pressure in mafia, sorry it's my first game

[Iconeum]

This pretty much comes down to

-Lynch confirmed Orcus-flavoured killer (killer for sure, highly likely the Orcus)
-Lynch someone else and hope you catch the cult recruiter

[Iconeum]

I strongly believe in the 1-bird-in-hand philosophy here

[Miss Lane]

even if there wasn't pressure, scum gain from claiming early, especially since there are very fast lynches this game once someone is confirmed or looks particularly scummy
i don't remember seeing a single L-1 followed by intent followed by hammer this game

[Iconeum]

The only player who's agressively trying to counter a lynch in a SK, is someone who claimed to be in a faction with said SK.

You decide.

[Miss Lane]

scum have nothing to lose by claiming early (only town does) at least as long as there's no vigs or SK

conveniently, the vigs died last night and scum are trying to lynch SK right now

[Miss Lane]

The only player who's agressively trying to counter a lynch in a SK, is someone who claimed to be in a faction with said SK.

I should certainly hope not, that would be awfully vacant of town.

You decide.

What am I deciding?

[Iconeum]

scum are trying to lynch SK right now

is the concept of town wanting to kill a SK so out of this world to you that you genuinly don't want to believe that can come from town?

[Iconeum]

The only player who's agressively trying to counter a lynch in a SK, is someone who claimed to be in a faction with said SK.

I should certainly hope not, that would be awfully vacant of town.

You decide.

What am I deciding?

not everything i'm posting is directed at you, honey

[Miss Lane]

Whatever happened to the process, by the way?
L-1
Intent
Hammer
It's not difficult
I don't remember seeing it for a while though
Mafia is so vacant now.
We are Town of Salem, just in slow motion

[Miss Lane]

The only player who's agressively trying to counter a lynch in a SK, is someone who claimed to be in a faction with said SK.

I should certainly hope not, that would be awfully vacant of town.

You decide.

What am I deciding?

not everything i'm posting is directed at you, honey

no i mean your sentence doesn't make sense grammatically
please restate

[Miss Lane]

scum are trying to lynch SK right now

is the concept of town wanting to kill a SK so out of this world to you that you genuinly don't want to believe that can come from town?

i think any capable or competent town would be aware of the circumstances enough to know that it's an absolutely terrible kill right now

[Iconeum]

This pretty much comes down to

-Lynch confirmed Orcus-flavoured killer (killer for sure, highly likely the Orcus)
-Lynch someone else and hope you catch the cult recruiter

I strongly believe in the 1-bird-in-hand philosophy here

would love some input from someone who hasn't claimed not-town on this. maybe i'm wrong, y/n?

[Miss Lane]

so yeah, i think the concept of a competent or capable town player wanting to kill an SK is so out of this world that i genuinely don't believe that it can come from town

i don't know where "want" fits into in that sentence, I think you're just shoving words together with negative connotation and hoping something somewhat convincing happens

[Miss Lane]

This pretty much comes down to

-Lynch confirmed Orcus-flavoured killer (killer for sure, highly likely the Orcus)
-Lynch someone else and hope you catch the cult recruiter

I strongly believe in the 1-bird-in-hand philosophy here

would love some input from someone who hasn't claimed not-town on this. maybe i'm wrong, y/n?

Yes, this is what I'm looking for. The whole argument that because I'm 3p, the things I do should be ignored and avoided.

Let's lynch Wooper over Zor again.
Let's lynch Vorkuta over Titus.

[Miss Lane]

would love some input from someone who hasn't claimed not-town on this. maybe i'm wrong, y/n?

This argument worked

so well

for RCE.

[KidAmn]

Also, re: KidAmn's weird "mod confirm" thing? No. Just no.
I replied "is that your final answer?" to more than you last Night.
It had nothing to do with your night target. That'd be me overreaching and I won't have that dialogue continue because it straight up didn't go down like that.

Well for-fuckin'-give me for being surprised at receiving a request to confirm my action when it has never happened before

If you don't want people to read into that shit, don't do it

[KidAmn]

vote: Iconeum

I'll be keeping Elements locked up until either he dies, I die, or the town decides they've had enough of this bullshit

I'll be back to this when I'm feeling less sour over some bullshit

[Iconeum]

why am i scum?

[Iconeum]

The reason we are not lynching Elements is because Miss Lynch’s role essentially makes it so that the SK takes two lynched to die. That is not a good use of our resources.

Am I wrong in saying that 2 lynches back to back outside of town are simply good? I'm aware that killing cult recruiter is obviously best lynch, but without more intel it's still shooting pretty blind.

Lynching back to back in a killing role and 3rd party that becomes a killing role might not be optimal, but it's pretty damn good.

In a vacuum this is true. However that also exposes the town to 2+ more cult recruited and 2+ more nightkilled. So effectively, instead of being a +2 in town’s favor (getting rid of 2 antitown roles) it’s actually -2 in towns favor.

But it remains true unless you specifically hit the cult recruiter. And you can do nothing about the kills anyway, except killing off entire factions.

[Iconeum]

And if you want to kill off entire factions, then the point of cult keeping recruited stands.

[Iconeum]

I'll be keeping Elements locked up until either he dies, I die, or the town decides they've had enough of this bullshit

This could be good tho. That would allow a lynch elsewhere and hope to hit cult/scum

[RCEnigma]

Sorry, I forgot I was a claimed 3p. I should have pushed Wooper and defended Zoraster so that you guys would have done the opposite. Sorry, RCE. I got it backwards.

Dude fucking hop off it.