Newbie 1976 - Game Over

[Ph0enix]

Phoenix, how long have you been playing mafia?
Before joining here?

I've played a bit IRL and a bit online. That's about it.

[NorwegianboyEE]

@Phoenix
You seemed like a very good player for having signed up so recently, so i had to ask.
I checked your newbie 1973 game. And it seems relatively similar to here, with your analyzation and stuff.
Pretty sure you're town.

[NorwegianboyEE]

If we assume you're town, it does make Map Wolf and Non Imh's vote on your wagon a bit suspicious. Since the wagon built up pretty quickly.

[Datisi]

ph0enix is a good birb

i need non to appear and start talking

[Datisi]

hmmmmmmm

Map what's your opinion on ph0enix slot now?
Ph0enix any reason you're not voting?

[Ph0enix]

Ph0enix any reason you're not voting?

The player I suspect the most currently is GBJ and I'm giving him the chance to explain himself before I vote him.

[Saladman27]

So in 260 Salad says that the only slot he's scumreading by that point is Non's. In 281, though, he pushes my slot to claim and 311 I interpret as an intent to hammer. It seems there is a bit of a contradiction here.

@Salad, if Non was your only scumread, why didn't you push Non's slot or convince the others that what follows may be a mislynch, given that you didn't find my slot scummy? You don't question Datisi's answer to your question in 260, either, even though the answer was "things and stuff". You didn't ask Norway to elaborate on his answer, either. You just deemed the answers to be satisfactory, for some reason.

@Norway: What was concerning you when it comes to my slot?

Also, Map Wolf and Non Imh were quick to hop on the Jackson wagon as well. Hmm...

p-edit: @Datisi: Your answer in 261 as well.

Non was not my only scumread, I was saying the only reason why I scumread Non, which I no longer do. I wanted a claim because, some bullshit reason. I'm a newbie at heart and whenever L-1 happens it's just instinct for me to ask for a claim.

[Saladman27]

I still SR GBJ. I just don't know who his partner is.

[NorwegianboyEE]

I still SR GBJ. I just don't know who his partner is.

What do you think of a theoretical GBJ/Non Imh team?

[Non lmh]

oh bother, mah reads
{jackson/map wolf/norwegian/(gbj-non)}
{naerys/datisi}
{kanna/saladman}

[Non lmh]

hiss
VOTE: Datisi
still townread Saladboy?

[NorwegianboyEE]

oh bother, mah reads
{jackson/map wolf/norwegian/(gbj-non)}
{naerys/datisi}
{kanna/saladman}

Jackson isn't in the game anymore, and you haven't answered any of the hundreds questions directed at you since your latest post.

[Datisi]

hiss
VOTE: Datisi
still townread Saladboy?

Yes

Now you can answer 294, explain your reads, *and* clear up why you wrote gbj-non in your readslist?

[Ph0enix]

Non was not my only scumread

"I only scumread Non’s slot bc of the inactivity and

no one else seeming (to me) scummy.

"

It's one of the two, it can't be both.

Non was not my only scumread, I was saying the only reason why I scumread Non, which I no longer do. I wanted a claim because, some bullshit reason. I'm a newbie at heart and whenever L-1 happens it's just instinct for me to ask for a claim.

Why don't you scumread her anymore? Do you think she's contributed in a meaningful way with her recent posts? Cause I think her recent posts are as good as being inactive.

I wanted a claim because, some bullshit reason. I'm a newbie at heart and whenever L-1 happens it's just instinct for me to ask for a claim.

I fail to see how that's a valid answer.

I still SR GBJ.

Correct me if I'm wrong, but that is the first time you mention scumreading GBJ after 260. There's a contradiction again.

oh bother, mah reads
{jackson/map wolf/norwegian/(gbj-non)}
{naerys/datisi}
{kanna/saladman}

Please justify your opinions on the players when providing a readslist. I can also put the names of the players in one of 3 rows and call it a day. You didn't even bother to see that Jackson's not in the game anymore.

VOTE: Datisi

Also, what??? At least say why you vote her.

[Naerys]

I actually have to appreciate Ph0enix´s analysis, it is very nice.
Right now, there are 3 people whose posts are for me very vague - GBJ,Non, Saladman.
RN i do not have really much to add, tbh.

Based on qutoes Ph0enix posted, Saladman looks very scummy. Also i do not really understand some points Non made in one of previous posts...

so I'm in my own way keeping myself on the table if needed since if I'm playing right, not one of you should be outright townreading me yet

and

I'm not used to standing by and letting people I think are town get killed off. Given the format, I understand why it happens and why I should start getting used to it but that doesn't mean I have to like it. My current plan is to more or less play as I want until I qualify as an SE and then and only then bite my tongue and play along with lynches I disagree with. That said, I'm still not all too confident and would like to hear from Jackson's slot before deciding on what next I'd like to do.

It seems like Non does not wish to be townread, but also claims to dislike possibility of mislynch

[NorwegianboyEE]

I still SR GBJ. I just don't know who his partner is.

Have you tried looking in the mirror?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Well, to Saladman’s credit, he has been voting GBJ pretty much all day. So a GBJ/Salad team seems unlikely.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Naery’s seems like she could be town. At least townier than my biggest scumreads.
Non Imh’s slot is bad, but i don’t know if it’s scum bad or bad bad. Slightly leaning newbtown.
GBJ is quite scummy. But i might want to do a vote analyzis when i wake up tommorow to check how many people have been willing to vote him.
Kanna is another slot that’s starting to worry me. Scum that’s taking it easy because we’re on the wrong track perhaps? I don’t like her inactivity lately.
Map Wolf i have a slight TR on, but Phoenix is worried about the slot. I’m double guessing myself a bit on this one.
Phoenix is town. No reason to doubt that yet.
Saladman is like a second lead, unlikely to be scum with GBJ. But independently scummy assuming GBJ is town.
Datisi i still got a townlean on.

[Map Wolf]

hmmmmmmm

Map what's your opinion on ph0enix slot now?
Ph0enix any reason you're not voting?

The stuff he has posted seems townie in tone. I'm not as concerned about pressuring him now.

[Non lmh]

What the fuck?
Your previous posts were simply calling GBJ fool or scum. But now you're ready to sacrifice yourself because you think he's so incredibly townie you need to rush to aid against a mislynch on town!him?

I didn't focus on him in our last game, all I wrote down then was 'bros don't turn into snobs unless there's a side chick involved' I got lucky.
I don't think he's townie, I think we're both fools, and thus town, if that makes sense, except I'm better

[Kanna]

Hey Phoenix! Liking your catch-up too

[Kanna]

Ngl, my opinion hasn't changed much over the last few pages, I just want to lynch GBJ. From meta, I know he 1) lurks as scum, 2) he can be protown as town, 3) he got caught as scum last time for trying to be townie so it makes sense why he could be trying something different this time

[Kanna]

Have also seen a bit of resistance against the slot; namely Map, Non, so I don't think it's as "easy" as I thought

[Kanna]

Actually, can I ask why people individually find GBJ scummy?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Everyone except for Non Imh has voted GBJ.
Pretty much everyone has scumread him, Non Imh lightly did too at one point, before he inexplicably changed his tone.