Guns & Roses III [Game over]

[Datisi]

but datisi would fearkill menal? no?

I *think* so but this does potentially fit with the missing N2 kill if it was on me

also it really doesn't

your ass would've been dead N1

[Bingle]

But... I don’t want to be conftown. Can I just claim rose instead and be pseudo conftown by virtue of the fact that there’s no reason scum me would ever not claim gun here?

(Yes, I’m a gun)

[Datisi]

holy shit Gamma!slot is the gun lmao

[Bingle]

As conftown I reserve the right not to claim who I shot which night. Now, who is what night rose?

[Datisi]

Datisi - N3
Mena - N2
Ico - N3
Amrun - N3
alimdia - N3 then N4
DW - N1

[Bingle]

Is there actually a missing scum kill N2? Cause that would make mena conftown, I think.

[Bingle]

Ah, nvm. GL was potentially a failed shot N2

[Datisi]

Aaron died N2. And it wouldn't I think, since we don't know (1) how many shots scum had for N2 (2) if they shot GL that night (also N2 Rose)

pedit: yeah that

[Bingle]

This setup is so much easier if I replace in after I’ve already lost.

[Bingle]

Okay, quick skim of the few pages I have seems juicy. I’d like in no particular order: current read lists, group consensus as of yesterday preflip, lynx to the alim claim/reclaim, an explanation of the Amrun ate over fakeclaiming discussion, and the scumteam to claim.

We likely lose regardless as a single scum gun has the power to fuck us, so I have to assume all scum are spent or roses.

[Amrun]

Bingle are you not gun? Because I’m going to jump off the roof of my office building if you’re not.

[Datisi]

alim claim, reclaim

current reads in a vacuum go sth like
{alim}
{Icon, Mena}
{Amrun}
{DW}

with the conditional that if either of Mena/Amrun flips scum the other is p much conftown

group consensus was p much: gamma = scum i think?

[Amrun]

Bungle, sorry, if you’re town, you’ve probably lost because I think they’re setting up to mislynch me and I don’t really have a valid defense except actually being town so just. Dhakkahdysbsbs

[Bingle]

Eh. I’m conftown, so I get whatever lynch I want if I feel strongly.

If you’re town I might figure that out. I might not. I make no promises.

[Amrun]

Up until today got so fuckingfucked, I thought scum was datisi/gamma(Bingle)/one of {dw, alim}.

Now, my heart is telling me datisi is not scum and I’m just going with it, I still strongly TR Icon, and I think Bingleslot must be the lying gun, so my scumteam by necessity is {menal, alim, DW}.

But my reads have been garbage all day so Whatever. I’m so fed up.

[Amrun]

Eh. I’m conftown, so I get whatever lynch I want if I feel strongly.

If you’re town I might figure that out. I might not. I make no promises.

Can you please confirm you are the gun, and what night? Your predecessor said he was a rose.

[Bingle]

I’m the gun, there’s no reason for me to put night.

[Bingle]

Hot take, soft preference on lynch order is Ico > Datisi. Thoughts?

[Bingle]

Alim, why did you change your claim?

[Bingle]

Actually, fuck it. I’m night 4 and I’m going to shoot alim tonight. I don’t see a reason that scum picks late game gun/rose when the odds are better if they can trim the game early. If alim doesn’t die they should be treated as conftown in my absence.

[Bingle]

0-1 scum in mena/Amrun means 2-3 scum in Ico/datisi/dw/alim.

Dw feels like the unpopular consensus, but is being pushed by both Ico and datisi, which means he’s very unlikely to be pushed by a pure wagon. The fact that it’s a well, I guess wagon makes it an unlikely bus.

Alim is getting shot tonight.

Does anyone feel strongly about any of these points being wrong? If so, why?

[Amrun]

Couldn’t alim still be scum claiming that rose? Am I missing something?

And yeah I mean I generally agree with your solve, but it’s pretty broad.

We have to lynch scum here or risk game ending so I’m more worried about who we lynch today which wasn’t likely to be alim anyway.

Earlier I was feeling DW because I see very few solves where she isn’t scum.

[Bingle]

Why would scum pick N4 rose?

[Datisi]

I'm kinda reading Icon as Town atm, why is he your preferred wagon?

[Bingle]

His decision about gamma being gun read as the most fake to me. It's not a strong read, but I'm 50/50 off of random chance and it's as good a starting place as any.

I'm open to being convinced on scumreads.