Mini Normal 2128: Normal Mafia - Game Over!

[BBmolla]

meh. I don't like the Skellen vote atm. Their content seems pretty town imo.

VOTE: iDannyBoy

[Bambi Jay]

That was @BB by the way, and yeah Pedit is what we use here Trollie. You come back recently? Did quarantine make you go "fuck it let's play mafia again."?

Hope you like it and stick around here then.

[BBmolla]

Oh actually your case is super valid yeah I'll switch there let's run them up

VOTE: Skellen

[TheTrollie]

Alright, who are you after then? I'd scroll and look at the VC but I wanna see your sales pitch.

BB doesnt have a sales pitch - he's voting the lurker who very well may end up being scum cuz i do see BBs argument but whoever im voting (dont care enough to go back and check skilla or whatever) has an actively scummy post

pedit - yes that is exactly right. this is my first game in like ....years. idk how many ill check. quarantine came - my entire industry got shut down and I literally was like "fuck it ill play some ms in my free time"

pp edit thanks bb :*

[Bambi Jay]

Dannyboy. Hmm. Lemme look into that I guess.

Past knowledge of him BB?

Pedit: Dangit man I was ready to read up on that. Sigh.

Guess I'll read Trollies case then.

[BBmolla]

no past knowledge of Dannyboy they just seem to be the low hanging fruit scum

I always like to try to start there

[Bambi Jay]

From what I saw, Skelly (which autocorrected to Smelly, lol.) Was a skeptic of something and resisted something quickly, thereby making her scum? Did she respond to that?

[TheTrollie]

fwiw i just looked and i think my last game might have ended april 2017 - almost exactly 3 years wowzer.

No response.

I'm not sure i love your summary of what the case is - The case is that in order for her to criticize me for feeling that Allo's potential towntells were fabricated, she would have to read allo as town. If she read allo ask scum even slighly, she would naturally also get that I thought Allo's posts were scummy and that those potential towntells were BS. But then she goes along and votes Allo in her next post. It stinks of scum going through and reading trying to poke holes and "scumfind" where she can because her two inqusitions don't match up to a single narrative of what her take on the game was as she read - she either thinks I'm stretching to make a case that Allo is scum or she agrees that allo reads scum

[Morning Tweet]

no past knowledge of Dannyboy they just seem to be the low hanging fruit scum

I always like to try to start there

Read some of Dany's games. He always posts infrequently and looks like low-hanging fruit scum, you're exactly correct there so take it as u will

[Bambi Jay]

Ehh. From just the ISO I'm sure Smelly can have a chance to explain herself to you, since your case is 138 and her last post is 122. I want more outta her and everybody before we focus on one target. Though Tweet's confirmation on Danny is interesting.

[Espressojet]

Oh, hey, it's Bambi Jay!

[Espressojet]

Pockets in pockets

[Bambi Jay]

Hey better EJ, how's it been?

[BBmolla]

no past knowledge of Dannyboy they just seem to be the low hanging fruit scum

I always like to try to start there

Read some of Dany's games. He always posts infrequently and looks like low-hanging fruit scum, you're exactly correct there so take it as u will

cool im okay with him dying then anyway

[geraintm]

I'm a Miller

Not enough pizzazz. I'm not convinced.

Tap tap tapping tap
Tap tap tapping tap
Tappity tappoty tap tap
I'm a miller

Jazz hands!

[geraintm]

I will post more tomorrow, just working at home and kids off school.making it awkward

[Bambi Jay]

Make the kids do your work. Problem solved.

[Espressojet]

I think Graintm is crumbling miller

[BBmolla]

crumbing miller is an absurd concept, if you're a miller you just claim it, crumbing it will literally get you lynched 9/10 times

[Bambi Jay]

Elsa claimed Traitor as a Miller to confuse the Mafia in a Boon game and lived till the Endgame.

Someone getting away with a Miller crumb is nothing in comparison if the person is good enough. I just, uh, doubt this playerlist would be able to pull that off.

But to be more serious Molla, no jokes, are you actually claiming Miller now or nah? Sarcasm is hard to pull through the internet.

[Allomancer]

How do you claim traitor and not get lynched?

[BBmolla]

nah I was joking I am not claiming Miller.

I have done it as scum before though.

Just wanted to clarify that if there's a late game miller claim I will autolynch them.

[Bambi Jay]

How do you claim traitor and not get lynched?

Simple. Be a Jay, either Elsa or Bambi will do. Alternatively, know the playerlist and know what you can get away with.

Not recommended for the faint of heart.

[Skellen]

Caught up. I am now leaning more town on Allo. I still feel iffy about his beginning behaviour but going by his explanations about his stance on bob/MT as his treatment of his developing read on bob I feel I can get a grasp on his personality, which adds up with what he was trying to explain to me and how he ultimately acted so far imo. It also feels like an honest attempt to figure bob out. UNVOTE: Allomancer

Regarding bob I can understand what Cat pointed out, but my problem is that I don't really see the scum motivation in the execution of his "tunnel" on MT. It's admittedly mostly subjective bias, because his 1v1s are frustrating to read, but he is smart and pretty self-aware and I would assume he would know as scum when to back off as it became clear that no one really digs his suspicion on MT. It only pushed him into the center of attraction and going by the early game state there wasn't even a need to do that, because there was already Dany/MT going on. Waiting for his input outside of his 1v1 though for a firmer read as I think he is easier to read when he is not involved in one of those.

[Skellen]

@all: I feel as though iDannyboy’s defensive post in 59 started this whole interaction and got more of a scum read on him than Morning Tweet. Thoughts? Am I reading too into that post? Do others read it this way or is this a fruitless endeavor? I’d vote there for more content and pressure iDannyboy a bit but want the lone abstaining player to post!

I don't really think he comes across as defensive in the posts you mentioned. In both 46 and 59 he was rather doubling down on his suspicion on MT, especially in the latter he pointed out how her read on Para changed, which seemed to bug him (that's how I interpret it at least).
I think only his recent post where he responds to the "defensive behaviour" accusation is actually defensive, but that is more because of the context that there wasn't really coming anything else from him besides that - the small question to bbmolla aside.