Mini Normal 2128: Normal Mafia - Game Over!

[iDanyboy]

Any big disagreement with my list or something anyone want to discuss

[Morning Tweet]

Why's BB and Paragon scummy?

[mavsfan41]

@iDanyboy: I see in your most scummy rankings you have geraintm. Why is this? The others I can see as lurkers with BBmola’s sheeping vote while lurking to be scummy. Sure geraintm is lurking but he does play useless townie day 1 and has been consistent. This I see as scum behavior but in the same terms of my read as bob as town cause his gambit was too reckless for scum, I see this in the same sorta way with geraintm’s it’s day 1, let’s get through this and btw I’m not going to really help too too much say 1. Lurking scum does this but doesn’t actually say this. Thoughts?

Also, bob’s 338 alleges Bambi is lurking scum. But I can see by your rankings that the lowest group is comprised almost exclusively of lurking scum types and is absent of Bambi meaning you don’t have the same read as bob. I don’t read her like bob has but what is your read there? I can see bob’s case but so far they read like someone who was a replacement in a slow moving game (considering the amount of prods, this seems to fit that).

As for you list, I’d move Espressojet up to neutral as I’m more familiar with him and was frustrated by his lack of contribution in day 1 but know that’s how he is. Morning Tweet id move down to unsure. Geraintm id move up to unsure. Mavsfan41 id move up cause he seems like a cool dude. Allomancer and Paragon I’m so torn on. Allomancer strikes me as more town but paragon doesn’t strike me as scum. His play style is his own and I can respect that. But it makes it hard to read a serious push from him or get a solid read cause that’s prob a play style both scum and town could easily pull off and therefore his style is NAI.

[iDanyboy]

Paragon

I didn't like his early push on me, with the fact that I've been on his scum list for the entire day phase but he hasn't tried to push me. I think it's because the other people on his list where getting pushed more than I was so they were easier votes.

BB

Isn't trying to solve the game and his vote switch up in Post 200 and Post 202 pinged me the wrong way and I don't like him trying to revisit the bob wagon, I don't think it's a good direction to go it.

Geri

You're right, I don't know why I put him that low, I would probably move him up to the scummy section but it comes down to Post 253. I don't know why his voting you but this post makes it seem like there's a good reason to park his vote there and that he couldn't find anything more scummy than is RVS vote.

Bambi

Only reason I put her as unsure is because of Post 346.

Espresso

Don't like that he has stuck to his self vote and I found Post 308 really weird.

[Allomancer]

@dany can you explain your read on me?

[iDanyboy]

@dany can you explain your read on me?

I don't like you push on Bob, it's not a very strong read though just above null.

[TheTrollie]

I like iD's reads actually.

I think it's highly likely that there is at least one scum in {allo, skellen, BB}.

VOTE: BBMolla

[SirCakez]

Skellen did not pick up their prod and will be replaced.

[BBmolla]

I'm a mason, hard claiming, not a gambit.

[BBmolla]

VOTE: iDannyBoy

[BBmolla]

If Trollie is going to abandon his endeavors for no reason I will too

[Morning Tweet]

town - mavs, allomancer
lean town - cat, paragon

i vote outside o here

that claim came quick. what do you hope to gain from it?

[BBmolla]

I don't want to deal with trying to prove I'm town for 5 more days and then we have to rush to lynch someone else

I'm not playing well lately so it was an uphill battle I don't feel like facing

[bob3141]

BBmola why claim after only two votes. Hopefully there is a protective that will prevent you from dying.

Reminds me of an earlier game where the masons claimed day one after only get a few votes

[mavsfan41]

Unvote

I like iDanyboy’s reads as well. Keep it up!

BBmola

Was that an OMGUS vote on iDanyboy? Don’t like that after he gave solid content. I second Morning Tweet’s questions. Claiming with 2 votes (mine is the 3rd) is overly defensive. (Bob posted about this point while I was writing this. So it when I looked up the vote total.)

Why do you think iDanyboy is scum and voted him? His list and his responses to defending his list seemed pretty town to me.

[mavsfan41]

EBWODP: I Saw bob’s post while I looked at the vote total at the time of the claim.

[Morning Tweet]

I can't help but feel effortposting is town indicative of iDany

i like that he gave reads and went into detail with em, but I don't find myself in agreement with all of em

[BBmolla]

Why do you think iDanyboy is scum and voted him? His list and his responses to defending his list seemed pretty town to me.

Hi whole read on me is awful and nonsense and he seems scummier than anyone else in the game

Basically just that

[TheTrollie]

UNVOTE:

Will wait for skellen replacement to come on to probably put my vote back there.

[Espressojet]

I'm a mason, hard claiming, not a gambit.

Lolwut

[Espressojet]

Why do you think iDanyboy is scum and voted him? His list and his responses to defending his list seemed pretty town to me.

Hi whole read on me is awful and nonsense and he seems scummier than anyone else in the game

Basically just that

I would agree

I think his whole read list is just pieced together from popular and easy opinions

[Morning Tweet]

I would agree

I think his whole read list is just pieced together from popular and easy opinions

i agree that I don't like his reads, like I find the reasons listed for the scum slots actually townie or null at best

although I think there's a chance this is town dany regardless

[SirCakez]

Madoka replaces Skellen!

[Espressojet]

although I think there's a chance this is town dany regardless

If I didn't think this as well, I'd have moved my vote

[Espressojet]

Welcome Makoda!