Mini Normal 2130: Mafia From Home [Game Over]

[profii]

To be fair I think that is probably the most effective way I've seen a game leave RVS

[Firebringer]

Flavor: New tips on how to kill at home: Send cute cat pictures to the target. They will die of cuteness.

Vote Count 1.01

Anotora(1): Zantetsu,
Battle Mage(2): Luca Blight, Churros
UnaBombah (2): Egix96, 72offsuit
proffi (1): UnaBOmbah,
Saudade (3): proffii, Anotora, Riabi
Riabi (2): Looker, NorwegianboyEE,
Zantetsu (1): Battle Mage



Not Voting (1): Saudade

Time Until Deadline (expired on 2020-04-14 20:00:00)
With 13 Alive, It Takes 7 to Lynch.

[profii]

I believe profii. Easy Day 1.

UNVOTE: Looker
VOTE: Saudade

I've decided I'm going to town read this. It took some consideration

[Egix96]

@Egix: Why did you get rid of the Growlithe?

Because I like this image better, of course (It looks like my irl dog)

Unvote, Vote: Zantetsu for being a bit overly aggressive and defensive for page 2.

I'd be interested in hearing what others have to say about this vote.

I do think you're being quite aggro in 27, 35, but on the other hand I think you make a decent point in second half of 33.

[Egix96]

Spoiler: offtopic @nbee

What's the deal with Churros anyway? I've only had them once

in Japan

, and they were so greasy, and oozing with fat. I almost felt a bit nauseated when i tried them.

Hmm, that might be the problem. They do them much better in Spain.

[Luca Blight]

I believe profii. Easy Day 1.

UNVOTE: Looker
VOTE: Saudade

I've decided I'm going to town read this. It took some consideration

Can you explain your thought-process behind this?

[Luca Blight]

Riabi’s questions/confusion feels somewhat genuine. Light TR there.

[Luca Blight]

Although I’d like to know why he voted Saudade when he seemed entirely unsure how to take the claim.

Jesus this site is slow recently btw.

[Luca Blight]

Although I’d like to know why he voted Saudade when he seemed entirely unsure how to take the claim.

This site seems really slow atm.

[Luca Blight]

Sausage makes this early mason claim in every game of his. Just pretend you're impressed and say he's a funny boi. That should make him feel validated.

Yes it was my impression that it was a joke too. But I think it would have been better to let the players involved talk their way out of it then deflate the situation yourself.

Don't you think it would have been better for Saudade to answer for himself?

Unless I'm mistaken, you didn't actually ask Saudade anything...

In fact, I don't really understand why you didn't, when you were very adamant that you wanted Profii to confirm there were no masons in the game, for some reason??

Unvote, Vote: Zantetsu

for being a bit overly aggressive and defensive for page 2.

I don’t like or agree with any of the reasoning in this post.

[profii]

I believe profii. Easy Day 1.

UNVOTE: Looker
VOTE: Saudade

I've decided I'm going to town read this. It took some consideration

Can you explain your thought-process behind this?

Initially my knee jerk reaction was why would you town read me not Saudade, but then I figured that normally a claim -> counter claim scenario is typically L-1 on scum, scum make something up, counter claim conflicts it.

Also, if I was scum counter claiming and Saudade flips town mason, then I get lynched straight after, granted that would give scum a couple of night kills, but it means the game would just end up at 2v9 so it makes no sense for me as scum to do that.

[NorwegianboyEE]

To be fair I think that is probably the most effective way I've seen a game leave RVS

That's a pretty good point. Now how about u vote Riabi.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Riabi’s questions/confusion feels somewhat genuine. Light TR there.

How is it genuine??

[72offsuit]

Hi everyone, how’s it going y’all? Just popping in to show that i am indeed reading the game and participating in the discussion. I see we’re all making RVS votes, well that is totally cool. I can do that too, as evidenced by my vote below. Always such a good time playing together with the brilliant players at Mafia scum tehe~
Hope you all have a nice day and a big greeting to you all~!
VOTE: 72offsuit

Having fun?

[72offsuit]

I'm pretty sure the post immediately before it is all the context you need.

Yep. post 19. Meta related.

[72offsuit]

Watch me wagon scum d1 again peasant

Sausage makes this early mason claim in every game of his. Just pretend you're impressed and say he's a funny boi. That should make him feel validated.

Stupid weeb didnt you learn after last game

Forgive me my liege.

You better kiss his ring and shine his shoes.

[72offsuit]

Can we chill with the claims for now? Half the scum's kill list has perhaps been established now for no real reason or benefit.

This feels really forced and LAMISTY

Ano: -0.5 scumlean: dirty-fly-in-your-soup

[Riabi]

Although I’d like to know why he voted Saudade when he seemed entirely unsure how to take the claim.

Jesus this site is slow recently btw.

Because if he is town, it seems like a dumb thing to say.

My vote is currently staying on him because he appears to be avoiding direct questions about what he's doing, and I think that's anti-town.

[Riabi]

Can we chill with the claims for now? Half the scum's kill list has perhaps been established now for no real reason or benefit.

This feels really forced and LAMISTY

Ano: -0.5 scumlean: dirty-fly-in-your-soup

Agreed.

[Luca Blight]

Riabi’s questions/confusion feels somewhat genuine. Light TR there.

How is it genuine??

The way he continually asks about it when he hadn’t received a direct answer seems like he genuinely wants to understand (although if scum don’t have day chat this could be NAI thinking about it). I also found his meta research of Saudade to ascertain motive for his claim townie.

[Luca Blight]

Although I’d like to know why he voted Saudade when he seemed entirely unsure how to take the claim.

Jesus this site is slow recently btw.

Because if he is town, it seems like a dumb thing to say.

My vote is currently staying on him because he appears to be avoiding direct questions about what he's doing, and I think that's anti-town.

So right now are you leaning towards him being scum or a ‘bad’ townie?

[72offsuit]

Riabi’s questions/confusion feels somewhat genuine. Light TR there.

Why do you think confusion is town-indicative?

The only confusion meta i could find for Riabi was in a scum PT in game Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... ct[]=24200

Post 354: Wait, I'm confused... we killed both max and saint?
Post 375: Ahh, that makes sense. Ok. Dunno why I mis-read that.
Post 383: I'm not sure how that counter claims Bashir... walk me through that?

Scatterings of replacement out as town, in mini normal 2130, Newbie Trees game, mini normal 1775 no confusion meta there that I could see.

All the games are pretty old, 2016 or earlier.

[Riabi]

Although I’d like to know why he voted Saudade when he seemed entirely unsure how to take the claim.

Jesus this site is slow recently btw.

Because if he is town, it seems like a dumb thing to say.

My vote is currently staying on him because he appears to be avoiding direct questions about what he's doing, and I think that's anti-town.

So right now are you leaning towards him being scum or a ‘bad’ townie?

More or less. I think I'd use 'unhelpful' rather than 'bad', however.

[Egix96]

Can we chill with the claims for now? Half the scum's kill list has perhaps been established now for no real reason or benefit.

This feels really forced and LAMISTY

Ano: -0.5 scumlean: dirty-fly-in-your-soup

Hmm yeah. On top of that, it kinda feels like something that scum would be more likely to have on their mind?

[UnaBombaH]

Already sorry for falling off for a moment here.
Will try to scavenge an inkling of a read soon.

Until that however, I will give you list of players that I feel like I can read correctly once I get enough actions to analyze:

profii
Luca Blight
Saudade

The rest of the list feels barely familiar, if at all.

I do not think anyone in this game actually knows what I'm capable of doing as town (or appreciates it?), but then again, I'm only starting to get back in to this thing.
profii has played with me the most out of the whole playerlist, I think, but based on the latest game they do not think much of me as a scumhunter..
And fair enough, they did win!