Mini Normal 2128: Normal Mafia - Game Over!

[SirCakez]

Votecount 3.5

mavsfan41 (3) - iDanyboy, TheTrollie, bob3141
Malakittens (2) - Allomancer, mavsfan41
bob3141 (1) - Bambi Jay
Bambi Jay (1) - Cat Scratch Fever
geraintm (1) - Malakittens
TheTrollie (1) - geraintm

Not voting (0)

(expired on 2020-04-26 23:25:00) remain until day end

With 9 players alive, it takes 5 to reach a majority.

[mavsfan41]

Fine, now one wants to get on the bob train. No one wants malakittens.....

Vote: Bambi Jay

[bob3141]

Fine, now one wants to get on the bob train. No one wants malakittens.....

Vote: Bambi Jay

but why bambi jay.

You have yet to explain why you scum read him yourself.


You migth of listed him with germa but you never explained why.


Oh and why if you are town giving up and a bob and mala lynch. Did you choose bambi over germa

[TheTrollie]

VOTE: mala

wanted allo and mavs to respond before voting

[TheTrollie]

that said - I do agree with bob here that mavs looks like a squirming scum happy to vote wherever - I just don't get why he wasn't like that when i gave him the opportunity to do so earlier.

[mavsfan41]

VOTE: mala

wanted allo and mavs to respond before voting

I already voted malakittens and you made several posts without voting there.... what gives?

Trollie/Bambi/bob?

Your 968 suggests that you’d hypothetically follow my vote but not now? (And not on bob3141 why, cause he’s you scum buddy?) Come on....

[iDanyboy]

I don't see how a Mav/mala team works with that vote, I'm not feeling a Mala lynch and I'm confident in my read on Mav and would rather we get him.

[geraintm]

I don't see mavs and danny both being scum together, and I said why in 996. I said it couldn't be mala+bambi+mavs based on mala agreeing with your 957, assuming it doesn't make sense for scum to try and bus both of their partners. However, now that I look back, the "I'm leaning trollie if one of these are town" does cast doubt. Given that she's voting gerain, it's very possible she planned on lynching gerain, and then pivoting to you rather than lynching the other two. So I guess mala+bambi+mavs could very well be a possibility.

I mainly came up with these teams based on interactions that I thought looked like two scum and then looking at who they could be paired with. The first two scumteams came from Bambi/Mala interactions and the second two came from Trollie/Bob interactions. I'm not actually sure why I put the last scumteam in, to be quite honest. I just thought mavs was scummy enough that he deserved to be a suspect and I constructed the only one that made sense with him in it.

Now that Mala+bambi+mavs is on the table, however, I take back what I said about it can't be mavs+bambi. That's another scumteam to suspect based off of Bambi/mavs interaction.

So the new list:

Mala+Bambi+Trollie
Mala+Bambi+Dany
Trollie+bob+Dany
Trollie+bob+Mala
Mala+Bambi+mavs

man, it looks like you put a ton of work into all of this. i'm glad that I am off your scum list, but you are putting an awful lotof effort into creating teams of 3 scum which, considering that no one in this game has found one scum yet thinking you have found 3 seems very optimistic.

but, you aren't voting me so you do you

[geraintm]

It might feel like that's what happened but all that you said is 'I dig it and' and 'I'm sorry for not seeing it earlier - Mavs is def scum.' so from my point of view it seems like your just chasing wagons and didn't want to be on the bambi wagon. Looking back thought my theory doesn't make much sense unless it's specifically a [bob,bambi,trollie] team.

I like that you agree with my thinking that trollies is chasing wagons.
most people seem to be playing venn diagrams trying to find scum, I prefer trying to actually spot people being weird.

[bob3141]

VOTE: mala

wanted allo and mavs to respond before voting

I already voted malakittens and you made several posts without voting there.... what gives?

Trollie/Bambi/bob?

Your 968 suggests that you’d hypothetically follow my vote but not now? (And not on bob3141 why, cause he’s you scum buddy?) Come on....

To the man with no answers

To the man that loves fip flops

Mav how has germa gone from no read to scum read and now no longer scum?

[bob3141]

I cant see me voting for anyone else but mav day 3

As no way a town player would do what mav is doing now

[geraintm]

I've just had a lightbulb moment. I am very sticky in my reads, and they are often out of sync with people. this goes across loads of games.
then, come the end of day I always feel pressured to placing a vote so that the day doesn't end in a no lynch, and I get bounced into a terrible terrible vote.
I don't know how to avoid this

[bob3141]

I've just had a lightbulb moment. I am very sticky in my reads, and they are often out of sync with people. this goes across loads of games.
then, come the end of day I always feel pressured to placing a vote so that the day doesn't end in a no lynch, and I get bounced into a terrible terrible vote.
I don't know how to avoid this

And you are saying

[mavsfan41]

I don’t like Geraintm’s most recent posts.

Vote: Geraintm

[b/]

[mavsfan41]

Damnit!

Vote: Geraintm

[TheTrollie]

Mavs is literally driving me insane. It's like another person took over the slot all of the sudden.

Couldn't pry him off his Bob vote with a crowbar and now he's hopping around like a madman

[geraintm]

I don’t like Geraintm’s most recent posts.

Vote: Geraintm

[b/]

really? it was just an aide-memoire to myself, nothing more than that. it had zero commentary about this game in its current state

[TheTrollie]

I just reviewed my scum-read interactions again...I think it is very possible that scum-strat right now is:

"we're crushing. town is screwed if they don't hang us up today, let's just bus the shit out of each other to cause crazy WIFOM tomorrow no matter what happens D3"

Because that is a very plausible strategy for scum at this point, I don't buy allo's assessment of the interactions. I think it is very possible that it is a Mala/Bambi/Mavs, Mala/Danny/Mavs, or maybe even Danny/Mavs/Bambi...there are others but I'm just suspecting most of those are not on Allo's list bc they violate the assumptions hes working with. You could I guess sub Gerain in for bambi in most of those - but like I said back in that wall of interactions, of my scumreads, gerain is the one not really adding to the WIFOM madness I am feeling. Bambi isnt either but thats cuz bambi isn't posting which is a whole other issue.

That is just to say - I don't buy that you can eliminate the possibility that scum is tactically putting us in a situation where we are fucked in the head after one of them flip, and mass bussing.

[mavsfan41]

@Trollie: I think you’re way off with your assessment. However, I see your potential scum groupings and see iDanyboy is in a handful of them. So in that case:

Vote: iDanyboy

[Allomancer]

Either mavs is scum messing with us or he's just completely given up trying or both.

[iDanyboy]

I’m not sure you can believe he is town now, can we please just lynch him already.

[Malakittens]

I’m down to vote Mavs

I’d put him to L-1, but i know trollie will just prob hammer.

I dont really like mavs’ flailing Rn

But please for the love of god can we look at gera for a possible lynch

And idk why Bambi is mia

[SirCakez]

Prodding Bambi Jay.

[mavsfan41]

I’m down to vote Mavs

I’d put him to L-1, but i know trollie will just prob hammer.

I dont really like mavs’ flailing Rn

But please for the love of god can we look at gera for a possible lynch

And idk why Bambi is mia

Cat Scratch Fever went mia. Which reminds me....

Vote: The Cat Scratch Fever Slot

[Bambi Jay]

I went MIA because staying silent at the moment is for the best for me. At this point if I talk imma just get myself lynched instead of letting town get the correct lynch or mislynch. Either way, whoever gets lynched will probably bust the game open. I'm open to Mav and stuff too.