I was convinced SM was the SK. We also had a plausible fake RC that at least one of us could have used to avoid being lynched, short of a cop coming out with a guilty result.
This was the 'catchup post' I wrote for HackerHuck once we were able to talk to him (Night 3 I think). I think it is quite a good summary of where we were, as mafia:
Code: Select all
Well, that day could hardly have gone better
[quote="mod"]ZeekLTK, B, Backup Doctor, Lynched D2[/quote]
Welcome HackerHuck. Quick recap for you:
Night 1 we were defeated by the grey screen of death and didn't submit our kill choice in time. The mod selected SeraphicMirth as our target, and there was no kill.
Night 2 I used my investigative ability to see if F1 was in the game (it is, but then F1 was killed at night by us anyway...) and ryanjunk asked if S was in the game. I don't know the answer to that, ryanjunk can fill us in with that result.
We killed kabenon007.
Now you know those two results, that gives one of us a plausible fake RC (of flavour cop, or something along those lines) as we can confirm whether or not 2 keys are in the game (plus your answer once you get it), plus our own 3 keys if required. That gives us quite a lot to go on in terms of faking that role for the rest of the game if one of us needs to.
~~~
Here's my take on the game:
Peers - I believe his claim. That means he is the psychiatrist and will cure the SK if he targets him. He's probably the most dangerous townie in terms of finding us.
liamcool - I think he was clever enough not to reveal everything about his role, which gave me even more ammonition to attack Zeek with, and made my attacks on Zeek ring true. I think his role is either one-shot (so he is now a vanilla townie) or he is a jailkeeper (ie, he protects and roleblocks someone). He'll struggle to make anything stick on us tomorrow, especially if we successfully kill tonight.
SeraphicMirth - I think she is the SK. She has been pretty quiet, and has been keen not to antagonise people. Whenever she has attacked someone, she has backed down once they answered. It makes her look like she is scumhunting when she isn't. Since she isn't mafia, that makes her the SK or some townie power role. Either way, I think she should be our night kill tonight.
KradDrol - Very lurky, and hasn't committed too much. Isn't really a threat right now.
Angelmouse/ryan - I think she was bang on the money with her analysis so far (apart from the ZeekLTK part...), so she could be dangerous. She'd inheriting ryan's actions, so I will attack her on that. HackerHuck, you've pretty much locked yourself out from doing that by saying that ryan strikes you as townie. There's an opportunity there for you to defend Angelmouse/attack me as a way of creating some distance.
ryanjunk has gone very quiet. There is potential there for bussing if necessary, for example if liamcool really can stop all kills tonight. I also need to ask the mod what result ryanjunk got last night, in order for our fake flavour cop claim to work.
Any thoughts?