Animals Upick [Game Over]

[PenguinPower]

[April Ludgate]

It seems that if my target gets janitored, i heal and watch. If not, i do nothing.

It seems as if the target was to be janitored, they are doctored and watched.

@Farside - why did you say “when would they flip?” They would flip when they die. Doctor protects people from dying.

[April Ludgate]

Votato also assumed that scum would be the one to have a janitor, which might have higher town equity. I feel it’s fair to assume town or even third party might have a janitor of some sort.

[PenguinPower]

Why would town have a janitor? There is no third party.

[April Ludgate]

No clue, I don’t know setup spec. Anti town role. It’s a upick.

Then I guess I’m the off one. It’s okay, I like being the off one.

[April Ludgate]

I’ve got suspicion on Farside.

[April Ludgate]

886 really rubs me, and not in the right way

[PenguinPower]

Like - I can see the role fotahdo claimed being a town role. I just don't believe his progression of not understanding -> understanding his role is genuine.

[April Ludgate]

One could even say...the wrong way.

[April Ludgate]

Like - I can see the role fotahdo claimed being a town role. I just don't believe his progression of not understanding -> understanding his role is genuine.

This I’m okay with.

[HoldenGolden]

886 really rubs me, and not in the right way

What about 886 bothers you?

[April Ludgate]

886 really rubs me, and not in the right way

What about 886 bothers you?

Farside

[HoldenGolden]

886 really rubs me, and not in the right way

What about 886 bothers you?

Farside

Gotta admit that's quite a compelling case

What about 886 bothers you?

[farside22]

A janitor (doesn't allow a flip)

Yes, this is what it does. I don’t get what you’re saying in this entire post.

Let me bring up Votato’s description

It seems that if my target gets janitored, i heal and watch. If not, i do nothing.

It seems as if the target was to be janitored, they are doctored and watched.

@Farside - why did you say “when would they flip?” They would flip when they die. Doctor protects people from dying.

Janitor per wiki

"cleans up the body" after its kill, thus preventing players from learning anything about the player when they flip. At daybreak, it is simply said that the player died with no information about their role or their alignment.

He says he is a doc/watcher. A doc protects a player from dying. Both idea's cancel each other out.
One protects. One provents a players alignment/role to be know. Can you tell me how that is possible for both to be true?
He says it doesn't work unless he is successful so my question being if successful does that mean the person remains like that permanently?

[farside22]

fine. I'm a town night 1-3 combined janitor-doctor watcher.

My role explains the pieces. I didn't really realize how much i didn't understand it until i had to explain it. It seems that if my target gets janitored, i heal and watch. If not, i do nothing.

the wording changed too when he described the role claim to how it works.
I mean I would be outguessing the mod but I would have written the role as a modified watcher/doctor and let it be known in the how it is modified in the action column.
Anyone know typically how crazy writes things out?

[Blatant Scum]

Votato also assumed that scum would be the one to have a janitor, which might have higher town equity. I feel it’s fair to assume town or even third party might have a janitor of some sort.

I don't think that it might be fair to assume that third party has a janitor in confirmed 17 players, 13 town, 4 scum settings.

[PenguinPower]

Yet another reason why I don't believe him.

The way he worded it originally means he watches janitor/doctor actions during Nights 1 through 3. His explanation would have been for a Night 1-3 Janitor Combined Doctor-Watcher.

[Blatant Scum]

fine. I'm a town night 1-3 combined janitor-doctor watcher.

My role explains the pieces. I didn't really realize how much i didn't understand it until i had to explain it. It seems that if my target gets janitored, i heal and watch. If not, i do nothing.

the wording changed too when he described the role claim to how it works.
I mean I would be outguessing the mod but I would have written the role as a modified watcher/doctor and let it be known in the how it is modified in the action column.
Anyone know typically how crazy writes things out?

Yay, another PM digger! Nice to meet you!
I think janitor-doctor watcher makes no sense, because the janitor modifier works on both, doctor and watcher. Not just doctor.

[April Ludgate]

I just feel like Farside is actively saying the role is something that it isn’t?

I already explained how I took the role, and I’m unsure why people are fighting against it.

My cosmic penguin seems to understand the role itself, but he seems to be the only other one, and that’s what is weird to me.

He claimed Janitor Doctor Watcher, and the Doctor watcher only goes through if the target was to be janitored?

Am I incorrect on this somewhere? What’s the issue?

If the person wasn’t going to be janitored, which implies death in its own right, then nothing happens, as usual.

What am I missing?

[April Ludgate]

Votato also assumed that scum would be the one to have a janitor, which might have higher town equity. I feel it’s fair to assume town or even third party might have a janitor of some sort.

I don't think that it might be fair to assume that third party has a janitor in confirmed 17 players, 13 town, 4 scum settings.

Don’t expect me to read the rules and know there isn’t 3rd party! That’s your guy’s job!

[Blatant Scum]

also the scum tab in the image is clearly a joke because who has a browser open with only two tabs?? Let's be real guys

FOS:

Calvin and Hobbes

[Blatant Scum]

How I understand Farside, she didn't understand how "janitor" and "doctor" roles could possibly work together. It was before potato explained his fake claim.

[April Ludgate]

It seems that if my target gets janitored, i heal and watch. If not, i do nothing.

It seems as if the target was to be janitored, they are doctored and watched.

@Farside - why did you say “when would they flip?” They would flip when they die. Doctor protects people from dying.

What I’m not understanding is the part where Farside says “when will they flip?!”

They would flip when they die? I don’t understand why that’s even a comment.

My understanding of the role he claimed is that if someone were to die and be janitored, and he targeted them, he would protect them from dying in the first place thus making the janitor no flip a non issue because the player wouldn’t have died. He would then receive a watcher result.

If he doesn’t receive a watcher result, he’d get No Result, and he’d know that his action didn’t go through?

The question I’m asking is if it’s a fake claim or he actually doesn’t understand the role.

And unless I am mistaken about what the role does, then all of you guys are also misunderstanding the role as well, even after he stated what it does.

[April Ludgate]

Am I wrong on the order? That’s possible. I read backwards because it makes more sense to read things backwards then upside down.

[April Ludgate]

I feel like he’s effectively a Cop that gets their result from targeting a Janitored target