Identity Reboot [post-Round 10]

[Saladman27]

Tridentity on the potato ice cream

please, thanks!

[Ariel]

The "Once threw up due to mistaking mashed potatoes for vanilla ice cream" identity belongs to one of {CreativeMod1, lilith2013, racefan12}. You must solve it before attempting to solve others.

Strangers	Identities
CreativeMod1	A video game they'd never played once mysteriously appeared in their bedroom
Iprobablysuck	Had once sold an entire shelf of comics to fund for a single buffet meal
lilith2013	Has performed a magic trick for an Actor/Actress who has played someone magical in TV/Film
racefan12	Is allergic to cooked pineapple but not raw pineapple
Tatsuya Kaname	Once threw up due to mistaking mashed potatoes for vanilla ice cream

Strangers	Identities
CaptainMeme	Briefly became a tour guide in Havana one afternoon despite it being [Stranger's] first ever day there
Equinox	Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
pablito	Has met the person in charge of their parents' religion in person
Plotinus	Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was
Something_Smart	Their grandad once did a drive by shooting on a wasp nest and later got a visit from police about the disturbance
xofelf	Ushered for a performance featuring Congresspeople

Match Attempts
9
8 ---Line of Assistance Revocation---
7
6
5
4
3
2
1

Confirmed no match

:
Plotinus -> Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
Equinox -> Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was
Tatsuya Kaname -> Is allergic to cooked pineapple but not raw pineapple

Assistance

Double Dip | 4 questions

[Saladman27]

*Ask all 3, What led you to think that mashed potatoes = ice cream?*

[CreativeMod1]

When I was about 10, my older brother was making me some "ice cream" but actually gave me Mash covered in chocolate sauce as a prank

[lilith2013]

It was at an all you can eat buffet. the mashed potatoes were off to the side in its own lane thingy, so I assumed it was ice cream because it had its own section. I put some “ice cream” in a bowl with a bunch of fruit from the fruit section. Fruit and mashed potatoes do not go well together.

[racefan12]

I was in kindergarten, and already was feeling kinda out of it that day, so I wasn't paying much attention when going through the cafeteria line and putting food on my tray. The combination of the flavor being wildly different than i was expecting along with already not feeling great made me throw up.

I didn't eat mashed potatoes for a long time after that.

[Tatsuya Kaname]

bump

[N]

rabble

[CreativeMod1]

Urm... If Saladman isn't playing, is it okay to swap them out with someone?

[Iprobablysuck]

Throw Pablito in there

[Ariel]

Urm... If Saladman isn't playing, is it okay to swap them out with someone?

Yeah, it's an option, just a bit of an awkward one. I'll go ahead give Saladman until (expired on 2020-06-15 22:10:58) to come take a game action before I look into a replacement.

[Ariel]

All right, let me know if you'd like to bail this game out since Saladman has site flaked. (Offer not open to the 10 Strangers still in the round, sorry!)

[StrangerCoug]

May as well be the brave soul that gives it a shot. Somebody's got to do the dirty work.

/in to replace

[Ariel]

Thank you
Game status: The "Once threw up due to mistaking mashed potatoes for vanilla ice cream" identity belongs to one of {CreativeMod1, lilith2013, racefan12}. You must solve it before attempting to solve others. You are 1 mismatch away from unlocking Phone a Friend.

Strangers	Identities
CreativeMod1	A video game they'd never played once mysteriously appeared in their bedroom
Iprobablysuck	Had once sold an entire shelf of comics to fund for a single buffet meal
lilith2013	Has performed a magic trick for an Actor/Actress who has played someone magical in TV/Film
racefan12	Is allergic to cooked pineapple but not raw pineapple
Tatsuya Kaname	Once threw up due to mistaking mashed potatoes for vanilla ice cream

Strangers	Identities
CaptainMeme	Briefly became a tour guide in Havana one afternoon despite it being [Stranger's] first ever day there
Equinox	Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
pablito	Has met the person in charge of their parents' religion in person
Plotinus	Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was
Something_Smart	Their grandad once did a drive by shooting on a wasp nest and later got a visit from police about the disturbance
xofelf	Ushered for a performance featuring Congresspeople

Match Attempts
9
8 ---Line of Assistance Revocation---
7
6
5
4
3
2
1

Confirmed no match

:
Plotinus -> Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
Equinox -> Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was
Tatsuya Kaname -> Is allergic to cooked pineapple but not raw pineapple

Assistance

Double Dip | 1 question

[StrangerCoug]

Double-dip lilith and racefan.

[xofelf]

Cool of you to finish out these identities <3

[Ariel]

Racefan had the incident with misidentifying mashed potatoes!

Strangers	Identities
CreativeMod1	A video game they'd never played once mysteriously appeared in their bedroom
Iprobablysuck	Had once sold an entire shelf of comics to fund for a single buffet meal
lilith2013	Has performed a magic trick for an Actor/Actress who has played someone magical in TV/Film
Tatsuya Kaname	Is allergic to cooked pineapple but not raw pineapple

Strangers	Identities
CaptainMeme	Briefly became a tour guide in Havana one afternoon despite it being [Stranger's] first ever day there
Equinox	Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
pablito	Has met the person in charge of their parents' religion in person
Plotinus	Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was
Something_Smart	Their grandad once did a drive by shooting on a wasp nest and later got a visit from police about the disturbance
xofelf	Ushered for a performance featuring Congresspeople

Match Attempts
9
8 ---Line of Assistance Revocation---
7
6
5
4
3
2
1

Confirmed no match

:
Plotinus -> Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
Equinox -> Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was
Tatsuya Kaname -> Is allergic to cooked pineapple but not raw pineapple

Assistance

2 questions

[StrangerCoug]

Hmm... I know Tatsuya likes anime. I wonder if it follows that he also likes manga.

Tatsuya sold the comics

[Plotinus]

strangercoug should get some extra guesses for replacing in because saladman wasted some of his i think

[CreativeMod1]

Go StrangerCoug for subbing in!!!

Also doubledip and I wasn't included, was my lie that bad? xD haha

[Ariel]

Tatsuya Kaname traded comics for a meal!

Strangers	Identities
CreativeMod1	A video game they'd never played once mysteriously appeared in their bedroom
Iprobablysuck	Has performed a magic trick for an Actor/Actress who has played someone magical in TV/Film
lilith2013	Is allergic to cooked pineapple but not raw pineapple

Strangers	Identities
CaptainMeme	Briefly became a tour guide in Havana one afternoon despite it being [Stranger's] first ever day there
Equinox	Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
pablito	Has met the person in charge of their parents' religion in person
Plotinus	Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was
Something_Smart	Their grandad once did a drive by shooting on a wasp nest and later got a visit from police about the disturbance
xofelf	Ushered for a performance featuring Congresspeople

Match Attempts
9
8 ---Line of Assistance Revocation---
7
6
5
4
3
2
1

Confirmed no match

:
Plotinus -> Filled in as a piano teacher for two weeks despite never having taught any instrument
Equinox -> Petted a cactus on purpose even though [Stranger] was plenty old enough to know what a cactus was

Assistance

3 questions

[Ariel]

strangercoug should get some extra guesses for replacing in because saladman wasted some of his i think

That hasn't been the precedent. I think it's generally understood that the replacement contestant would, for better or for worse, have made different choices than the original contestant. It makes it unfortunate to need one but very kind of StrangerCoug to step in.

[StrangerCoug]

Creative, IPS, and lilith: Tell me about the magic trick you performed.

[CreativeMod1]

Met Ron Weasley at a local music festival that I was performing magic at and went over to him to show him a trick

[Iprobablysuck]

Went to a convention near Pittsburgh and met Kane, who in Wrestling lore has the ability to control hellfire and shit. I did one of the bog standard is-this-your-card tricks, he thought it was cool