Newbie 2019 | Game Over!

[Porkens]

So that was an all town wagon?

[GeniusGamer]

Here are a few more reads. I’m almost done.

• T-Bone: He did some questioning in the beginning, as well as explaining stuff like quoting, how elimination works, or why he thinks that you shouldn't analyze activity. He really,
  really
  stuck to his claim that the Micc slot was scum instead of switching to an easier target, which to me is a town-like move. Unfortunately though, he didn’t really share thoughts on anybody else. That is bad, apparently, but doesn’t seem alignment-indicative. I see T-Bone as one of the most town-like players in this game.
  
  
• ItalianoVD: At the beginning, he was mainly joking around, but what sticks out to me was his vote for Redados. It was for having an early reads list. Not only is there is no problem with having early reads, but it
  helps us find scum
  , so I found that pretty scummy. He said that it struck him as a “Look At Me, I’m So Town,” but I don’t see that. Reads lists are what help us share thoughts about each other and decide who’s scum. Italiano also seemed to think that the only types of content are questions and fluff. Not true. But he was very active and shared lots of thoughts. I don’t know for sure, but I think Italiano is scum.
  
  
• Porkens started with a vote for Redados due to unvoting me when I had two votes. Suddenly, they changed their vote to Shelly for not talking less than a day into the game. Despite this, they were confused by Shelly voting for someone who hadn’t posted right after. Very hypocritical. They let loose a barrage of questions, without sharing any of their thoughts. While it’s good to ask questions, Porkens expressed what seemed to be an inability to share their own thoughts. Pretty scummy. Once they realized that, they started to slow down with the asking and provide their own thoughts. They later turned their focus back to claiming that Shelly is scum and questioning me for finding MiniMegabyte suspicious. I also think that Porkens may be scum.

[Porkens]

Where did I express an inability to share my own thoughts?

[Redados]

Hey guys, starting to meta dive Hat Guy/word321's open game 784 to try to get a meta read on him. One thing that sticks out to me is that he looooves meta. He's quoting games and stuff just like he's kind of mentioned here. Just on initial observation.

I am confused on why you and Shelly both call him Hat Guy and have everyone else's name down perfectly. I feel this is something I need to look into because I legit can't remember half this stuff but word321 sticks in my mind.

I'm not sure, he's in my mind as Hat Guy. I think it might be replacement thing because you're in my head as Sunflower Guy too, I can't remember your username either, I have to check every time. I was able to remember everyone's username initially but my brain gets confused by replacements.

[ItalianoVD]

Well I guess I will get the wagon started on Shelly.

VOTE: Shellyc

Since Word is already at 2 I figure to put pressure on this slot and see what happens.

[SJReaver]

I guess his avatar is more memorable than his name.

It's Sunflower Gal, by the way.

[Redados]

Gotcha! I may forget, it would be helpful if you could put your pronouns in your profile although not necessary of course

[GeniusGamer]

• Micc/Word321: Micc didn’t actually do much. He walked through his RVS vote for me with MiniMegabyte. He did leave the RVS pretty fast with a vote for ItalianoVD. He made it clear that people couldn’t be called lurkers on the first day, and supposedly tried to pocket T-Bone once he started posting. He did provide a reads list though. Like T-Bone, I find it odd that he didn’t vote for his stronger scumreads. He was eventually replaced by Word321. Word321 started by asking T-Bone some questions, casting suspicion, and voting. He also asked Redados some questions. I don’t really understand most of his posts though. I do think the slot could be scum though.

[GeniusGamer]

Where did I express an inability to share my own thoughts?

Throughout the beginning of the game, all you did was ask questions. You did not say what you thought about any particular posts, disclose who you thought was town or scum, or clearly point out suspicious actions.

[Porkens]

Nobody asked.

[GeniusGamer]

...You literally just asked.

[SJReaver]

No, Porkens was saying that they didn't give our their thoughts because no one asked for them in the beginning. They waited to be prompted.

[Porkens]

Find me a question about my reads that I didn’t answer.

[SJReaver]

I'm more interested in your current thoughts.

You haven't voted, so I assume you're weighing the possibilities. Are you waiting for someone else to respond to events?

[Redados]

I'll VOTE: Shelly as well.

[GeniusGamer]

Oh.

You answered all of the questions about your

reads

, though it’s fine to provide info unprompted. Also, ISO-ing you again, I realize that you never answered Italiano’s question in post 123 (why were you answering questions directed at other players, but when I did it, it was apparently wrong). When prompted about it, you simply explained why Shelly likely said what she said, instead of acknowledging the hypocrisy.

[Porkens]

unless someone claims a different power role, the masons are outed are clear.

Given that, I’m looking at the super-fast wagon on town. I’m betting there is one scum there.

I think italiano’s reaction to the mason claim and fallout seemed townish. That leaves mini and shelly. I can see either of them as maf. I’m deciding which at the moment.

[Porkens]

I

wasn’t

answering the question.

[GeniusGamer]

I

wasn’t

answering the question.

Yeah, that’s the problem. You were asked a question and you didn’t answer it.

[SJReaver]

• MiniMegabyte: As I said earlier, MiniMegabyte wasn’t really advancing the game in most of her posts. She pushed T-Bone for his laser focus on the Micc slot much later in the game. Honestly, I’m currently getting newbie town vibes.

In terms of suspicion, how would you rank the four people on your wagon: Porkens, Italiano, Mini, and Shelly?

[GeniusGamer]

I don’t think MiniMegabyte would be a good elimination today. I don’t know if I’ll have enough time for a full explanation of my read, but I do think Shelly would be a good vote for today.

VOTE: ShellyC

[Redados]

That's E-2

[GeniusGamer]

• MiniMegabyte: As I said earlier, MiniMegabyte wasn’t really advancing the game in most of her posts. She pushed T-Bone for his laser focus on the Micc slot much later in the game. Honestly, I’m currently getting newbie town vibes.

In terms of suspicion, how would you rank the four people on your wagon: Porkens, Italiano, Mini, and Shelly?

From least suspicious to most suspicious:

• MiniMegabyte
  
• Italiano
  
• Porkens
  
• ShellyC

[Porkens]

I

wasn’t

answering the question.

Yeah, that’s the problem. You were asked a question and you didn’t answer it.

I wasn’t answering the question which was directed at Shelly. I was saying “I think shelly is scum and the reason she called the wagon on town because she is scum and

knew

it was on town.” That’s the “other interpretation.” To which, by the way, she agreed.

[Porkens]

VOTE: shelly