Mini Theme 2155: SIN: This Impurity must be Cleansed!

[BananaCucho]

I don’t want to flip either jackel or starbuck atm.

I don't wanna flip Catboi, why are you even voting them?

From what I can tell, reactionary from one specific post

[BananaCucho]

i also haPpen have 4 tiers
catboi and norwEe share the same tier for me
there may or may Not be addItional playerS in that tier
it is not tier 1

[Porkens]

I see no good reason why catboi made that ultimatum.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Did you just crumb what i think you did?

[BananaCucho]

Did you just crumb what i think you did?

Saintass

[NorwegianboyEE]

You know, we might actually just be better of killing scummy inactives, because if they're not gonna play then mafia will just kill active town and we'll end up with a super unmotivated game in the end and scum thrives in that kinda environment.

[catboi]

I see no good reason why catboi made that ultimatum.

There are an extremely limited number of people who could claim to have made the extra kill, and I'm not sure a vig fits in the picture with the roles we already know of. I'm concerned the extra kill was not from a town player.

[BananaCucho]

You know, we might actually just be better of killing scummy inactives, because if they're not gonna play then mafia will just kill active town and we'll end up with a super unmotivated game in the end and scum thrives in that kinda environment.

The question I have is how long do we allow Starbuck to come back and play the game before defaulting to them basically rolling over

[BananaCucho]

I see no good reason why catboi made that ultimatum.

There are an extremely limited number of people who could claim to have made the extra kill, and I'm not sure a vig fits in the picture with the roles we already know of. I'm concerned the extra kill was not from a town player.

This logic checks out

[Porkens]

And forcing that hypothetical town player to claim today accomplishes what?

[BananaCucho]

And forcing that hypothetical town player to claim today accomplishes what?

Helps us solve the game tbh

If they have a second shot, I wouldn't claim. But if they already used it, they definitely should have claimed a long time ago. Btw, shared insights on site meta regarding vig shots (1x, 2x, etc) would be appreciated

I agree with the logic that waiting to claim later is more scummy than townie

I am definitely of the opinion that a vig does not exist, given that the shot makes absolutely no sense from a town player. There were way better options to shoot today that could have helped us towards solving this game

[BananaCucho]

Maybe later.

This kind of stuff just comes across to me like scum who thinks he can’t be caught.

I have no interest in flipping starbuck today.

I am not fully opposed to a mass claim.

Staring to get low grade pings from a couple others

Rat didn’t want his corruption to be lowered, bell. Any insight on that?

Porky, I would like to get some more insight on this. Who (other than catboi) has been pinging you today?

[BananaCucho]

Bee's ISO for day 2 is not good

[BananaCucho]

Bee/Starbuck/Porky

Throw a dart in there, I feel like we have a pretty high chance of hitting scum

[NorwegianboyEE]

Bee/Starbuck/Porky

Throw a dart in there

Well Banana cake.
Do it.

[redtea]

what I don't understand is why people think with 4 days left that we're definitely carrying these votes to the end of D2.

banana you're at odds with catboi on when a seeming to be increasingly unlikely vig should claim. If there is one they're liable to follow the bigger common tr's advice.

[redtea]

Oh
Huh
Or are we

[NorwegianboyEE]

what I don't understand is why people think with 4 days left that we're definitely carrying these votes to the end of D2.

What makes you think that? I highly doubt a lynch on anyone else is going to happen.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Or wait, maybe i misunderstood what you were trying to say there. You're pretty confusing sometimes.

[redtea]

What's y'all's reasoning for not including Jackel in the elimination pool anymore?

Sorry, I try. Helps when I use quotes but sometimes I get a little over-confident with my coherence. Or I'm on mobile, as I am now.

[BananaCucho]

Bee/Starbuck/Porky

Throw a dart in there

Well Banana cake.
Do it.

[NorwegianboyEE]

What's y'all's reasoning for not including Jackel in the elimination pool anymore?

I've still got them in my elimination pool. But wouldn't mind hearing what other people have to say regarding them.

[BananaCucho]

What's y'all's reasoning for not including Jackel in the elimination pool anymore?

Sorry, I try. Helps when I use quotes but sometimes I get a little over-confident with my coherence. Or I'm on mobile, as I am now.

This is my personal pool, I expect everyone to have differing opinions on it

IMO alligator is a player who probably found themselves in a bad spot early and has been trying to turn it around. Day 2 I'm raising the bar and she's meeting the expectation for me. She seems to be putting forth an effort to solve the game. Day 3 we'll raise the bar more.

[NorwegianboyEE]

So if they breathe they will be qualified to rise above the bar?

[BananaCucho]

So if they breathe they will be qualified to rise above the bar?

That's definitely not fair for alligator at all