Newbie 2027 | Doggos | Town Win

[shellyc]

I ain't self hammering as town.

Wow. that was exactly scum!me's defense when I got E-1 in 2019

[JacksonVirgo]

VC 1.12

shellyc (3)

-

Sceptorus

, Mundivore,PlusJOYED

72offsuit (1)

- Noraa

PlusJOYED (3)

- shellyc, Sirius9121, EchoVision

Nikahang (1)

- Frogsterking

Not Voting (1)

- 72offsuit,

With 9 unfortunate souls alive, you need 5 votes to eliminate.

shellyc and PlusJOYED are at E-2

Deadline:

(expired on 2020-09-08 12:00:00)

Let me know if there are any errors

[shellyc]

Your defense is "kill shelly tmr"; that means nothing
if you're town!plusjoy and im outed scum, why would you just sit there instead of trying to solve

cause im not long for this world and I've placed my faith in the town that your buddy will be found

town needs to find the scum. banking on others is a proscum mindset

[PlusJOYED]

@Noraa your the kingmaker, I've put my hopes in dreams in you. VOTE SHELLYC!!

[shellyc]

Now Noraa, don't get affected by the AtE. Think carefully because they obviously demonstrate a proscum mindset. Vote plusjoy because they're outed scum here

[PlusJOYED]

Shelly trying so hard when they'll get elimed tomorrow and everything they say will be disregarded as scumtalk lol

[PlusJOYED]

I'm gonna take a shower. I'm interested in this now. Thanks for making my claim worth it, shelly. A 1 for 1 is good for town

[shellyc]

They just TMI-ed.

PlusJoy just said I'll get elimed tmr, which will only happen if they get limmed today. they just gave up lol

[Noraa]

I don't like this situation. I don't want to choose. I want to think ur both town >:(

[Noraa]

UNVOTE: 72

[shellyc]

Emblematic of being pocketed by scum

it's an easy choice. just vote plusjoy here

pedit: why would you unvote? we can wait for a 2nd PR claim to disprove (or prove) the claim

[shellyc]

actually nvm an unvote is best here as we're waiting for a replacement

[shellyc]

*since the replacement could be the tracker / cop

[Noraa]

I still wish to stubbornly believe this is TvT even tho the odds of that happening seem a lil too small.....
Im not choosing a side until I hear some se opinions. I want to hear 72's, frogster's, and echo's

[shellyc]

I still wish to stubbornly believe this is TvT even tho the odds of that happening seem a lil too small.....
Im not choosing a side until I hear some se opinions. I want to hear 72's, frogster's, and echo's

wtf we aren't TvT. Noraa is this a scumslip? a sane townie wouldnt think this is TvT

[PlusJOYED]

I don't like this situation. I don't want to choose. I want to think ur both town >:(

I think it"s no longer possible both of us are town.
Shelly and I aren't dumb enough to claim a pr as vt

[shellyc]

I'll take that as a compliment

but you're still scum here

[PlusJOYED]

Yeah I'd like the tracker/jailkeeper to claim now so we know who is scum

[PlusJOYED]

I'll take that as a compliment

but you're still scum here

no u

[shellyc]

Yeah I'd like the tracker/jailkeeper to claim now so we know who is scum

a townie being cc'd would know that their cc is scum, so "we know who is scum" does not make sense

[shellyc]

Btw that might be fishing with PRs so be careful

since I'll die tonight you only get one night of investigative info

[shellyc]

Heading to bed now and please just lim the free scum

[PlusJOYED]

twisting my words again like you've done all game :/

I'm saying so the town knows who to vote. I think a pr reveal here is worth it.

[Noraa]

I don't like this situation. I don't want to choose. I want to think ur both town >:(

I think it"s no longer possible both of us are town.
Shelly and I aren't dumb enough to claim a pr as vt

I'd rather think y'all r dumb just just be patient I want to hear se opinions before I impulsively vote someone and end up finding out I had a hand in killing a pr and then feel terrible that I didn't listen to them

[Mundivore]

UNVOTE: shellyc

Hey everyone, there's a lot of material for me to catchup on. Fortunately, I read through everything last night! I'm not going to provide any original analysis b/c the body of work is simply too overwhelming to pick from, but here are my reads after going over the whole thread.

Likely scum: PlusJOYED, Sirius.

Possibly scum: Sceptorous, Noraa

Possibly town: Echo, Frogster

Likely town: Shelly, 72

The case against PlusJOYED in the last few pages is really strong—mafia lying as doctor in order to get a lynch is about the dumbest thing you can do as scum. One free kill on a townie is usually not worth one free kill on scum in return. So either shelly is town and JOYED is scum, or it's just a bad play where shelly is scum and JOYED is town, and we take those.

I'm quite Sus of Sirius just because of behavior, running around like VI and then lurking about and changing vote to whoever seems like the next active lynch target just feels super scummy to me. The fact that Plus is scum and JOYED scumread them doesn't even make me think that they're less scummy. If I were scum and I saw my partner acting like that, I'd scumread them to hell and back. The way Sirius is acting is going to get them lynched eventually, and if I knew they were scum I'd want to get ahead of that. Then again, if Sirius were town then I'd also want to try to get the free lynch in. If shelly is doctor, that means we have either cop or tracker. I'd say Sirius is an excellent target for them tonight.

Mild sus of Noraa, but I can't do anything more than reiterate what others have said. Lurking is innately scummy, but honestly Sceptorous just seems AFK. Semi-sus of Echo, not wanting to be town-read just feels weird. Scum wants to be town-read, but

so does town.

I take it mostly as humor but still feels weird. Frogster always contributes cogent information, but contributes infrequently. Town lean but I'm not committed to it yet.

I'd be down to kill JOYED. I've seen enough that I'm confident he's scum. However, I'm not going to vote yet, I'm waiting until everyone's satisfied with the body of analysis and willing to kill.