Newbie 2027 | Doggos | Town Win

[EchoVision]

I don't care if we eliminate shelly or if we eliminate Plus, but one of them has to go. It's a throw of tremendous proportions if we don't take our guaranteed one-for-one and go on. Town can only afford two missed eliminations. Are we really going to go for a

complete guess

Day 1 instead of the 50/50?

So obv. shelly + Plus are one town, one scum. Of the remaining:

I don't like Redados b/c I feel like he's trying to pocket me and b/c he gave no warning for the 'hammer' (fake hammer b/c everyone miscounted b/c of Echo's unvote)

I don't like Noraa b/c every time she posts it confuses me... very weird play, especially on insistence that shelly and plus might be two town.

I don't like Sirius b/c it seems like his primary goal is just to see people elimmed. Only shows up to defend case against person on chopping block and vote for new person.

I don't like Echo b/c he's rude af. Dude chill out. Nothing really AI about being rude but I don't like the way he plays. Raising people's hackles doesn't help you find scum, if anything it muddies the waters. I also don't like that he's open to a kill outside of the two entangled players. I'd rather kill shelly than not kill plus or shelly.

yeah i get it we have a guaranteed 1for1 but if we can prove that 1 is town and 1 is scum without a flip, then we won't mislynch one of them
sure we might mislynch someone else, and that's the issue

i don't know if you mean you don't like the slot or you think the slots scum, so i'm gonna go off of the latter

noraa: i don't see how confusing posting is AI, especially when it's coming from someone who has repeated she's a newbie multiple times
it's the newbie queue and she's trying to learn, hence her "confusing" playstyle
not sure how that's AI still

sirius: this is the one read I agree with, he might get better as time goes on and he can gamesolve more; some people just can't play d1 well but then they pop off on other days
i don't think we should hang this slot today, but it's def someone to keep our eyes on

echo: aren't you a little experienced in mafia to do an OMGUS in the newbie queue
sure i didn't vote you, but i said i didn't like your slot for town a few times and lo and behold here i am on your scum list now when just a few hours ago i was on your town list
not to mention your blurb on me basically reads "what he's done isn't alignment indicative, but i still think he's scum for that reason"

also i'd appreciate it if you didn't tell me how to play the game thanks

[EchoVision]

if we do lynch outside of the counter claims it’s gonna have to be fast, should prob start discussion about it now

i don’t like nikahangs slot as town

lurker was replaced echo keep up with the times lol

yes i know it was but i didn't remember the guys name just his picture so i went with calling it nika's slot

[EchoVision]

I like a Mundivore/Plusjoyed scum team.

[Noraa]

I think I had a sr on redados long before u did @shelly
I could've remembered wrong but that's how I remembered it

[EchoVision]

noraa stop being naïve, they’re not both town

yeah wtf noraa WE'RE NOT BOTH TOWN

T^T I'm getting yelled at for trying to believe in my reads

at least for me, one of the things i learned quick is that my reads are very often wrong
which sucks but you gotta be able to be fluid in a game like this

[Redados]

Noraa, I really don't like your playstyle. I don't think it's alignment-indicative necessarily, but I really am not a fan of how you are playing.

hm I will listen to constructive feedback. tell me what's wrong with my play style

I'm having a hard time articulating it, so I'm going to go through your posts and pick out the ones that I don't like. I want to stress that I don't think your playstyle is alignment-indicative as in I'm not necessarily scumreading you just because you're posting things that I don't like. I just don't like it.

What is crumbing? also what's (self)meta? I can't find definitions for these in the abbreviations wiki doc

Crumbing is when you say stuff that you can point back to prove your point. Like if on Day One I say "hey, neighbor" and then on day four I quote it and say, see, I was crumbing the role Town Friendly Neighbor

that's sounds stupid af

crumbing just sounds stupid and a scumtell almost

Reason I don't like: bad takes

I just describe a situation in which town loses from this plan and then PLUS immediately says "I like this plan"

bad timing ig

nah

Not that it matters since I'll be elimed soon, but my elim pool today is just shellyc, and my elim pool tomorrow is (72o, froster)

Bro if I had god tier persuasive skills, I would try to not have an elim today cuz I feel like no elim is better than killing a townie(some people had valid points against this but like ) But it seems a lot of peoples opinions r set in stone at this point and I hate it but also i don't know what to do. Now's about the time when I low-key wish I was an SE that knew wtf I was doing.

no elim is BAD

T^T new replacement doesn't like my reads

"I want to no lim" is not a read! No lim is BAD

but I mean I feel like limming a pr is worse than not limming at all ... right?

I think this is a straw man. It's not like you're advocating for lynching scum while I'm advocating for lynching a PR townie. It's much more nuanced than that. We have battling roleclaims. The fact that you break it down like this makes me upset.

...I'm a noobie.

eh I still like plus more :3 im not happy with how you hammered someone the day you replaced in. in fact I would almost say that's a scumtell

I've asked this a bajillion times and if you answered I missed it; how is this a scumtell? I didn't replace in and naked vote. I caught up on the whole thread and responded to stuff in chronological order. I deserve to participate in the game and your attitude towards this makes me upset.

watch shelly be vt
I was right about plus so I believe I'm also right about shelly

Shelly has claimed a power role. She is either the doctor or some sort of scum. There is no way that she can be a vanilla townie.

There's some more stuff in your ISO but I think I've already responded to all of it.

[Noraa]

if we do lynch outside of the counter claims it’s gonna have to be fast, should prob start discussion about it now

i don’t like nikahangs slot as town

lurker was replaced echo keep up with the times lol

yes i know it was but i didn't remember the guys name just his picture so i went with calling it nika's slot

I still get the two new ones confused and shelly legit just told me which one mundivore was and I have already forgotten. Whatever I'm just gonna not think of them as nikahang and sceptorus, its far too confusing

[EchoVision]

I don't understand why your telling me this and its making me question your intentions a shit ton please stop. I literally asked Mundivore why they think ur attempting to pocket them and you come over here and tell me why. I'm having a terribly hard time trying to understand what in the world ur trying to do with this

what
noraa
redados gave you the reason why mundivore thought redados was pocketing him
what do you mean dog

[Redados]

I think I had a sr on redados long before u did @shelly
I could've remembered wrong but that's how I remembered it

Order of operations:
1) Shelly goes to sleep
2) I replace in
3) I talk
4) You scumread me
5) Shelly wakes up
6) You brag to Shelly about scumreading me before she did

[shellyc]

I think I had a sr on redados long before u did @shelly
I could've remembered wrong but that's how I remembered it

Order of operations:
1) Shelly goes to sleep
2) I replace in
3) I talk
4) You scumread me
5) Shelly wakes up
6) You brag to Shelly about scumreading me before she did

lol

I expressed an SR on Sceptorus early on let me find it

[EchoVision]

Like the 4th time I've said this, but it honestly makes no sense why shelly would counter claim here. Does she think she can get away it when I flip? It seems super cocky to think so.

thank you for TMI-ing

it makes 0 sense because I'm town here and claimed to get rid of you

Shelly it's starting to get on my nerves that you think it's ok to just throw this game away. Regardless of alignment, fake claiming here is just really dumb or cocky that you think you can live when I flip green.

this post makes me cringe
i don't like it

[Redados]

if we do lynch outside of the counter claims it’s gonna have to be fast, should prob start discussion about it now

i don’t like nikahangs slot as town

lurker was replaced echo keep up with the times lol

yes i know it was but i didn't remember the guys name just his picture so i went with calling it nika's slot

I still get the two new ones confused and shelly legit just told me which one mundivore was and I have already forgotten. Whatever I'm just gonna not think of them as nikahang and sceptorus, its far too confusing

It's in the first post if you need a refresh:

Newbie 2027 | Doggos

Hosted by JacksonVirgo

Backup Hosted by the worst

Player List

Sirius9121*	ISO
Noraa	ISO
Mundivore	ISO	Nikahang
shellyc	ISO
Redados	ISO	Sceptorus
PlusJOYED	ISO	XrCyclone, MiniMegabyte
EchoVision (SE)	ISO
Frogsterking (SE)	ISO
72offsuit (SE)	ISO

* means a prod. Three prods means force-replacement

Player List

Spoiler: Living

Sirius9121
Noraa
Nikahang
shellyc
Sceptorus
PlusJOYED
EchoVision
Frogsterking
72offsuit

The Graveyard

Spoiler: Dead

JacksonVirgo - Killed by Life N0 -

Moderator

Logbook

Spoiler: Events

[shellyc]

3. sceptorus has been producing almost 0 content and agreed with the views by others, scummier at the moment

here we go

[Noraa]

I don't understand why your telling me this and its making me question your intentions a shit ton please stop. I literally asked Mundivore why they think ur attempting to pocket them and you come over here and tell me why. I'm having a terribly hard time trying to understand what in the world ur trying to do with this

what
noraa
redados gave you the reason why mundivore thought redados was pocketing him
what do you mean dog

I don't like that he answers when I'm asking someone else why they r in a way slightly sring him. that seems protown at first glance but I think its not that simple

[shellyc]

this post makes me cringe
i don't like it

great that you don't like the posts by this outed scum

[Frogsterking]

I think I had a sr on redados long before u did @shelly
I could've remembered wrong but that's how I remembered it

Order of operations:
1) Shelly goes to sleep
2) I replace in
3) I talk
4) You scumread me
5) Shelly wakes up
6) You brag to Shelly about scumreading me before she did

lol

I expressed an SR on Sceptorus early on let me find it

To be fair, I believe

I

was the first to express an SR on Sceptorus.

[shellyc]

I don't like that he answers when I'm asking someone else why they r in a way slightly sring him. that seems protown at first glance but I think its not that simple

noraa fence sitting again

noraa / plusjoy is my solve

[shellyc]

To be fair, I believe I was the first to express an SR on Sceptorus.

how is it protown to brag about when you SR-ed someone

[Redados]

I think I had a sr on redados long before u did @shelly
I could've remembered wrong but that's how I remembered it

Order of operations:
1) Shelly goes to sleep
2) I replace in
3) I talk
4) You scumread me
5) Shelly wakes up
6) You brag to Shelly about scumreading me before she did

lol

I expressed an SR on Sceptorus early on let me find it

It's okay to scumread Sceptorus, I won't be offended

To be fair, I believe I was the first to express an SR on Sceptorus.

how is it protown to brag about when you SR-ed someone

It was a joke and it made me chuckle

[Noraa]

I think I had a sr on redados long before u did @shelly
I could've remembered wrong but that's how I remembered it

Order of operations:
1) Shelly goes to sleep
2) I replace in
3) I talk
4) You scumread me
5) Shelly wakes up
6) You brag to Shelly about scumreading me before she did

lol

I expressed an SR on Sceptorus early on let me find it

"6) You brag to Shelly about scumreading me before she did "
no just no

@shelly does it matter if u sr'ed sceptorus? I thought he was town most of the time and prolly just busy with life. A whole new person replaced in. U shouldn't let ur reads on the lurker influence the replacement cuz whatever tf the one before did means absolutely nothing once the new ones in.

[shellyc]

It does matter because it's the same player slot

both of them are the same alignment and role

[EchoVision]

VOTE: Noraa

Heavily considering a Noraa/Shelly Scumteam.

interesting... so why vote noraa here instead of shelly?

[Noraa]

ur point isn't valid. otherwise every time there's a wagon, every single person besides the first one to jump on is sheeping the first one

[Noraa]

VOTE: Noraa

Heavily considering a Noraa/Shelly Scumteam.

interesting... so why vote noraa here instead of shelly?

cuz I said we should lynch him for not trying to help town or inputting anything useful

[Noraa]

VOTE: Noraa

Heavily considering a Noraa/Shelly Scumteam.

interesting... so why vote noraa here instead of shelly?

cuz I said we should lynch him for not trying to help town or inputting anything useful

if I remember correctly he did this to someone else that suggested voting him as well. he just votes straight back. this shows he has no interest in finding scum, he's just here to idk troll everyone or something.