Mini Normal 2171 | Boardgames | Game Over

[TheGoldenParadox]

it was 100% pooky, absolute kudos go there. that play was something i could have never anticipated myself. honestly, just honored to watch it happen.

[Mizzytastic]

At various points n1 mafia were killing Bob, FL, or no one. The protection was initially on TGP but they moved to Gamma then Johnny because they were concerned about action investigatives blowing the gambit.

Combined with FL considering Gamma instead of TGP that night could have gone so many ways

[Mizzytastic]

Also that's a great pagetop

[TheGoldenParadox]

thinking about nomming pooky for a scummie. can i nom for master strategist even though it's technically a town award?

[shellyc]

thinking about nomming pooky for a scummie. can i nom for master strategist even though it's technically a town award?

i think this is fine for kodak moment (?) because master strat is a town award
but im +1 for scummie nom with the no kill play

[Tayl0r Swift]

gg and thanks for modding

[shellyc]

my rvs lolsolving

if its pooky/osuka/ydrasse im putting this in my signature postgame

gutreads 2/3

[Battle Mage]

haha OMG, another swerve!

genius play, especially by Pooky - the Ydrasse buddying throughout....man

[shellyc]

has rolled scum a hilariously disproportionate number of times that it's almost a meme at this point (scum!shelly again)

no im not scum, I was always just nk-immune miller vig

oh and I promised to do this postgame:

1) What is your Favorite Board Game?
2) Favorite memory playing Board Games?
3) If you could live in the universe of a Board Game - which one would it be?
4) If you were stuck on a desert island with a few friends - and a large supply of food and water - which one board game would you like to have to play while you wait for rescue?
5) If you could pick one board game to never exist - what would it be?

1) Avalon if it counts as a board game because i prefer online avalon, or dixit.
2) probably game nights with friends and shouting all over each other
3) clue because i wanna be an nk-immune miller vig and murder people
4) deck of cards answer is good so im sheeping that
5) I don't despise one specific board game might get back to this tomorrow

[Battle Mage]

well i can live with losing to that...better update those stats

and yeah, no comment on the whole mech-solve thing. for once my paranoia was justified haha. well played scum

[Battle Mage]

and kudos to the mod as well, game feels balanced overall, ran at a good pace, and was enjoyable despite my mid-game rage.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

thanks for modding Mizzy!


@ Battle Mage I got u back for that last one

@ Flava Flav this was a ton of fun trying to mind-meld with you.

@ Shelly sorry for the early yeet =] I couldn't let you attack Ydra like that :3 - your reads were very good ^_^

[Flavor Leaf]

to be fair, I wasn't going for a full mech solve, I definitely mixed in with my own analysis.

The No Kill just really got past me as more than just a possibility. Pooky did well the earlier games to set that up to where anyone who would figure it out, it would be too late.

At least I town read BM correctly.

[Flavor Leaf]

thanks for modding Mizzy!


@ Battle Mage I got u back for that last one

@ Flava Flav this was a ton of fun trying to mind-meld with you.

@ Shelly sorry for the early yeet =] I couldn't let you attack Ydra like that :3 - your reads were very good ^_^

yeah, it got you killed, but it didn't matter if you died. the no kill really did well.

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

well i had to flail to make you think i cared about dying, if i went down too quietly you would've done a double take and realized something was wrong :3

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

you are very hard to trick :>

[Flavor Leaf]

i realized something was wrong for sure, I just couldn't figure out what it was. Taking the risk of going after Ydrasse even if something was figured out would have always probably gone a different way. Scum Doctor claiming Doctor straight up was also a weird move, but I guess they even claimed just protective at first, so there were hints, I just don't know if I would have ever taken the risk even if it came up simply because that's a hard one to be wrong on.

[Battle Mage]

the icing on the cake was that Pooky left us clues. the relationship with Ydrasse. the calm acceptance of Flavor Leaf's plan. the excitement and enthusiasm to the end, despite being flipped.

[Mizzytastic]

I thought you'd eventually reconsider because of the pairs of odd night and even night roles.

Also I think it was Pooky who actually said she was a doc and not just a protective first. I might have missed something cos not always fully reading but I remember thinking "oh god he slipped" at the time

Also the review thread should now be public

[Mizzytastic]

thinking about nomming pooky for a scummie. can i nom for master strategist even though it's technically a town award?

thinking about nomming pooky for a scummie. can i nom for master strategist even though it's technically a town award?

i think this is fine for kodak moment (?) because master strat is a town award
but im +1 for scummie nom with the no kill play

I don't exactly know how scummie nominations go - like, is it a one of us or a whole bunch of us thing - but I definitely agree it deserves mentioning. As for where to nominate it...

[12:43] Tom: i actually see no reason not to make it a goodfellas nom!
[12:43] Tom: the pooky/ydra synergy in particular
[12:43] Tom: they were vibin from the first moment
[12:43] Tom: and pooky didn't just mechanically drive town off a cliff
[12:44] Tom: he drove them off a cliff while setting her to deepwolf, and then positioned town in a way where they wouldn't stop to reevaluate the fact they were driven off a cliff by scum
[12:44] Tom: it only ever works as a team play
[12:44] Tom: i think it's a very fair goodfellas nom

[Gamma Emerald]

I’m just gonna be super fucking bitter if I can’t make use of the lesson I got from this game

[shellyc]

ok i may be confbiased being in a weird situation as the person deathtunnelling scum + the scum misexe but not to sound condescending to scum because the mech no kill was v good, I think looking back at this game towns overconfidence led to their downfall more than scum's play. All the TPRs outed themselves on D2 so nightplay was easy as scum from N2+. Pooky still ended up losing the duel in the first mylo, and ydrasse like. barely played after D1. (but in fairness the play was good)

I think scums mechplay through the no kill and protective claim to make fakeauto was reeeeally crucial more than any of the dayplay, and because Goodfellas should encapsulate both good dayplay and mechplay i think this isn't really a Goodfellas nom, but def go for kodak

[shellyc]

*(but in fairness the claim was good)

mizzy your modding was great btw, enjoyed the flavour a lot and the game was called at a good pace, with prompt vcs, prods and replacements!

[bob3141]

suprised no one spotted yds. Thought after my kill he was obvous scum as scum never kills me there before any protective during n3. My role dont threaten the doc so its not worth the risk of no kill. Ontop of the fact that town never has the same roles as scum and we had confirmed scum doc. odds some would design a boring setup like that is low.

[Gamma Emerald]

town never has the same roles as scum

not always true.