revO emaG - TENET

[Something_Smart]

I don't think killing Noraa-slot is really what I would call low info.

Killing a newly-replaced-in secret alt who's a potential wildcard, maybe.

[petapan]

midwaybaer what are your reads right now

i'm breaking my self-imposed post restriction to do this to you

Mostly the same as my read list from yesterday. I don’t really scumread anyone though which is a little disappointing. Wondering why TENET was killed.

Deacon superbowl
Flavor Leaf(?) Noraa(?)
Firebringer Gamma/DEB Dandelion
skitter peta
SS LLD
Hmm I don't feel super good about this. Maybe one scum in second/third tier idk
Deacon and superbowl don't need too much explanation. superbowl scumcasing a general LHF in Gamma seems townie?
I think Flavor is slightly townie for using ":/" in reaction to me shading him. I feel like he would be more lighthearted about that as scum. Noraa is well... I guess she can live for now.
Firebringer has been making solid posts. I have him a bit lower because his playstyle makes me naturally paranoid. I'm wondering why he doesn't want to get turnstiled anymore? Gamma's rage feels pretty real, but I'm not sure how alignment indicative it is. Pretty much just sheeping Deacon on Dandelion. My personal read there is null.
My personal read on skitter is slightly townie, but I guess I'll trust the crowd? Everyone else I don't really townread either.

okay, let's talk about this. why is deacon at the top? why is LLD at the bottom?

are you really that surprised by the tenet kill? we were just in a game where we shot a replacement night 1 as scum

[Something_Smart]

Or maybe they thought the replace-out spewed the slot as town.

[skitter30]

I don't think killing Noraa-slot is really what I would call low info.

Killing a newly-replaced-in secret alt who's a potential wildcard, maybe.

Ya that's my point

[Deacon Blues]

Yeah that points to scum in the influences and/or widely townread ppl

You made this same point in your first post of the game day.

I thought it looked pretty facile!

When bork and I saw the reverse NK, we figured scum wanted to paint this picture.

[Something_Smart]

Yeah, I think I agree. If it was a scum kill, scum think they're in a good spot.

Since the two people receiving the most pressure are now both decent townreads for me, that interpretation is pretty plausible.

[skitter30]

Fwiw i actually think he's less genuine here than there @ss

Pooky i do think eod was ++scum

Who besides us are you scumreading?

I didnt say i scumread u
My reads are largely where they were yesterday, notable changes include pooky going down, and fire and ss going up

Pedit yes i'm aware that people are going to say i did that to create that narrative etc etc etc i dont really care, i would bet that's why it happened.

[petapan]

replacement kill doesn't necessarily point to townread players being scum. it simply means that scum likely weren't feeling significant pressure in this thread on day 1. that can be townreads or people who were less active but not getting voted.

[midwaybear]

okay, let's talk about this. why is deacon at the top? why is LLD at the bottom?

are you really that surprised by the tenet kill? we were just in a game where we shot a replacement night 1 as scum

Deacon's entrance seemed townie aka the way they reached out to everyone. I would expect them to be more go-with-the flow as scum. LLD hasn't pinged town yet, but it is all relative.
Yeah, I'm surprised by the kill. I expect I would have been surprised in 2180 too if I was town there.

[petapan]

alternately pooky killed it because he thought it was hectic

[midwaybear]

That's sort of a meme kill and would still point towards scum being in a good spot.

[Deacon Blues]

Yeah, I think I agree. If it was a scum kill, scum think they're in a good spot.

Since the two people receiving the most pressure are now both decent townreads for me, that interpretation is pretty plausible.

who were you replying to here?

[skitter30]

Scum dont make that kill without feeling like they're in a good spot

[Firebringer]

That's sort of a meme kill and would still point towards scum being in a good spot.

as other said, not really a meme kill when u have a replacement wild card, and it does indicate scum in the wide townreads.

[petapan]

okay, let's talk about this. why is deacon at the top? why is LLD at the bottom?

are you really that surprised by the tenet kill? we were just in a game where we shot a replacement night 1 as scum

Deacon's entrance seemed townie aka the way they reached out to everyone. I would expect them to be more go-with-the flow as scum. LLD hasn't pinged town yet, but it is all relative.
Yeah, I'm surprised by the kill. I expect I would have been surprised in 2180 too if I was town there.

just the entrance? i feel like that'd be an easy post to make as either alignment. what about the rest of their content?

again why exactly were you willing to vote FL yesterday despite him being high up in your reads list?

[Firebringer]

UNVOTE: midwaybear

i think midway is definitely overacting this "ohh its a weird kill guys" bit.

[midwaybear]

No, I mean peta's theory that scum!Pooky killed the alt because he thought it was Hectic. You only make that kill as a joke and when you are in the position to do things like that.

[Deacon Blues]

petapan doing tlaloc's work.

[Something_Smart]

When bork and I saw the reverse NK, we figured scum wanted to paint this picture.

I mean, if that's why you made the NK, well I would welcome your elaboration

Otherwise, that theory seems like a bolt from the blue. Why would killing Tenet, whose death could be explained any number of ways, work for this purpose better than killing someone like me? (That aside from the fact that kills of this nature are pretty rare in my experience.)

[SirCakez]

Rules clarification - roles can only target Operatives in their own timestreams unless it says otherwise in the role.

[Something_Smart]

alternately pooky killed it because he thought it was hectic

Or anyone else who knows Hectic did that? Why Pooky specifically?

[Firebringer]

UNVOTE: pooky

Rules clarification - roles can only target Operatives in their own timestreams unless it says otherwise in the role.

Pooky is in this timestream wtf

[Something_Smart]

who were you replying to here?

Skitter

[midwaybear]

just the entrance? i feel like that'd be an easy post to make as either alignment. what about the rest of their content?

again why exactly were you willing to vote FL yesterday despite him being high up in your reads list?

I haven't really been paying super close attention to their posts, but I do think they passed off a decent vibe D1. I will read their posts start of today.
About Flavor, it really was Flavor Fever as he says. I thought he was openwolving a bit with the skitter push, and Pooky's vote was a sort of spark.

[petapan]

just the entrance? i feel like that'd be an easy post to make as either alignment. what about the rest of their content?

again why exactly were you willing to vote FL yesterday despite him being high up in your reads list?

I haven't really been paying super close attention to their posts, but I do think they passed off a decent vibe D1. I will read their posts start of today.
About Flavor, it really was Flavor Fever as he says. I thought he was openwolving a bit with the skitter push, and Pooky's vote was a sort of spark.

why do you say that, when skitter was low on your reads list as well? why did you ask this?

I do want us to come to some kind of consensus on skitter sometime soon too.

where did you start distrusting his push on skitter?