Why? They’ve been saying what appears to be contradictory things?
Flavor Leaf vs. Hectic [Game Over]
Forum rules
- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
Why is that suspicious? We’re obviously not going to ask for Starcrossed or Tweetie and probably Ydrasee.In post 4807, Firebringer wrote:
This one.In post 4806, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:or was it just that I named Skitter/Chara for your walls on?- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
I’m thinking now my initial read on you was correct.
- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
Bookmarking this for next game.In post 4822, Flavor Leaf wrote:
I put Ydrasse and Hopkirk in there because I thought they were Hectic picks. I didn't get Ydrasse.In post 4818, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:
This is pretty interesting, maybe as the town stump I would choose to have 3 masons, and submit my candidates for the 4 most likely scum picks and 3 least likely scum picksIn post 1, Krazy wrote:Once the town stump has determined how many masons they want, they submit a list of that many players plus four. (Ex: If the stump picked three masons, the stump would submit seven names.) This will be their mason pool.
The moderator(s) will take this list and remove the scumteam.
-P- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
Other than the blatantly obvious fact that you’re dead wrong on us, why isn’t it possible for Tweetie/Chara to be TvT?In post 4833, skitter30 wrote:
Ok sounds good: look in xtoxm/venus/chara/tweetie and note that tweetie/chara are not tvtIn post 4830, Flavor Leaf wrote:and ill take skitter reads into consideration if town.
It’s posts like these that make me doubt you. Why? Because it looks like you could be possibly chaining miselims here with Tweetie/Chara. It’s townie to say that a slot isn’t SvS but scummy to say that it isn’t TvT.- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
Because town!you either figures it out by now or at least waffles on us, neither of which I’m seeing here.In post 4838, skitter30 wrote:
Ah that one. I think mostly cuz it isnt a mafia game, didnt feel like a real game.In post 4836, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:
I'm very glad it's out of your memory, I just recalled the name of the game: Blood on The Clocktower. Xtoxm modded, I tunnelled you and NahdiaIn post 4831, skitter30 wrote:I, uh, actually went looking for this game and i'm not sure what this is >.>extremelyhard throughout the friggin game remember?
-P
Either way i dont really mind u smumreading me here, but i'm kinda, like, not sure why u are even?- Starcrossed
-
Starcrossed Goon
- Starcrossed
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 977
- Joined: January 15, 2021
kanna is here and she SPEEDREAD this game
i could not disappoint boon after he said he missed me. also i got prodded %_%
i think chara is likely to be drafted and i don't know why they're particularly townie? skitter is also likely to be drafted but i think she's more town than chara. i have no strong scumreads, only townreads of varying strengths
hi alisae!!
~mitsuha- Starcrossed
-
Starcrossed Goon
- Starcrossed
- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
That’s the main reason for me but far from the only one. I think saying that there’s no possibility that Chara and Tweetie could be TvT definitely pings. I also didn’t like her reaction to FL’s Xtoxm post. I think that town!her either reacesses that read or doubles down on it but instead she just sounded irritated.In post 4840, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:
Almost purely out of your read of my slotIn post 4838, skitter30 wrote:Either way i dont really mind u smumreading me here, but i'm kinda, like, not sure why u are even?
-P
Why no, either “you could be right FL”? or “No FL, I feel extremely confident on Xtoxm!scum” but just straight up irrititation?- Starcrossed
-
Starcrossed Goon
- Starcrossed
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 977
- Joined: January 15, 2021
i'm sorry i'm bad i like you guys a lot and i miss you too %_&
also HECTIC HECTIC notice me! i haven't talked to you in this game! hectic hecitc
~mitsuha- Starcrossed
-
Starcrossed Goon
- Starcrossed
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 977
- Joined: January 15, 2021
- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
Can you explain why? Because I’m having real trouble believing that town!Skitter still thinks there’s a world where were still scum here?In post 4858, Starcrossed wrote:kanna is here and she SPEEDREAD this game
i could not disappoint boon after he said he missed me. also i got prodded %_%
i think chara is likely to be drafted and i don't know why they're particularly townie? skitter is also likely to be drafted but i think she's more town than chara. i have no strong scumreads, only townreads of varying strengths
hi alisae!!
~mitsuha
I still think Chara’s town but will be uberpissed if this is the 2nd game in a row where they’ve hard pocketed me but I trust you more than almost anyone in this game, so please tell me what you think I’m not seeing?- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
We need to hydra sometime soon, after things get a little less crazy for me. <3In post 4861, Starcrossed wrote:
i'm sorry i'm bad i like you guys a lot and i miss you too %_&
also HECTIC HECTIC notice me! i haven't talked to you in this game! hectic hecitc
~mitsuha- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
I miss him too. :/
- Starcrossed
-
Starcrossed Goon
- Starcrossed
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 977
- Joined: January 15, 2021
oh no please don't trust me, my reads aren't good...In post 4863, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:Can you explain why? Because I’m having real trouble believing that town!Skitter still thinks there’s a world where were still scum here?
I still think Chara’s town but will be uberpissed if this is the 2nd game in a row where they’ve hard pocketed me but I trust you more than almost anyone in this game, so please tell me what you think I’m not seeing?
i don't think skitter townreading you is super alignment indicative. i think she's towny for being invested in the game and general solving, and in a vacuum, i think she's doing more than chara
can i get a tldr on chara!town?
~mitsuha!- Starcrossed
-
Starcrossed Goon
- Starcrossed
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 977
- Joined: January 15, 2021
of course <3In post 4864, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:We need to hydra sometime soon, after things get a little less crazy for me. <3
i always miss takiIn post 4865, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:I miss him too. :/
~mitsuha- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
I’m torn on them after Pokemon Battles. Well for one, tr my paranoia on them because Pooky did that in a previous game. Shiro had a strong gut tr on them but he’s also been wrong. They sounded more engaged than they were in PB but I also remember that Pooky had better reads than me in both Dung games. I also feel it’s a bit disingenuous for Skitter to be questioning our sr on her when she knows - barring a strong reason other than that to obvtown a slot - it’s town indicative for me to sr anyone who’s making a bad push on my slot.In post 4866, Starcrossed wrote:
oh no please don't trust me, my reads aren't good...In post 4863, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:Can you explain why? Because I’m having real trouble believing that town!Skitter still thinks there’s a world where were still scum here?
I still think Chara’s town but will be uberpissed if this is the 2nd game in a row where they’ve hard pocketed me but I trust you more than almost anyone in this game, so please tell me what you think I’m not seeing?
i don't think skitter townreading you is super alignment indicative. i think she's towny for being invested in the game and general solving, and in a vacuum, i think she's doing more than chara
can i get a tldr on chara!town?
~mitsuha!
What I like best about Skitter is her claim.
@Chara, if you’re town here, I think you should claim.
If it actually is Chara, then I’m obviously reading someone else wrong. I guess Skitter would probably be cleared by Chara flip and vice-versa. I feel extremely confident on Tweetie!town.
One thing sticks out to me was that Chara reacted very differently to srs on them in PB. They didn’t seem to have much of a reaction, here otoh, they actually sounded pissed.- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
\o/In post 4867, Starcrossed wrote:
of course <3In post 4864, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:We need to hydra sometime soon, after things get a little less crazy for me. <3
i always miss takiIn post 4865, Venus Mars and Pluto wrote:I miss him too. :/
~mitsuha
He’s deeply missable.- Venus Mars and Pluto
-
Venus Mars and Pluto Mafia Scum
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1682
- Joined: July 24, 2020
- Location: our Solar System
In post 3138, Chara wrote:i'm not sure what to do with myself here. anyone want a second opinion on something?
i'm thinking Sailors hydra is town.In post 3304, Chara wrote:i'm also not really convinced on Gamma scum. i don't have any great reasoning, but it just doesn't seem to fit. that's taking Dann into account, and Gamma's recent posts.
pedit: hm.In post 3393, Chara wrote:i don't think i can read Tweet properly, if that list was apparently so towny.
though i recognize it's a bad idea to base that feeling on Tweet's scumread on me including that i'm disconnected with the game right now, when she's also feeling that way and is apparently town. :/
but i don't have a strong reason to SR her. i guess i'm just upset with the state of things.In post 3405, Chara wrote:thank you both. <3 Ydrasse i care you too
skitter, i'm sorry you're sad. i really am town here. i just had a short scumgame finish, i don't know if it would help but i'll leave that there.In post 3413, Chara wrote:i'm upset that skitter and Tweet think i'm scum. it is silly, i know.
Tweet's read is fair, i suppose, considering i also SRed her, though i thought i explained why that was. but seeing that reason along with being disconnected when she's also feeling that way is a little... presented without irony i'm just going to frown at it.
and this game has reminded me that a lot of things the majority of players look at in mafia when determining reads are tools i don't use/don't agree with the significance of.
just, seeing several players all agree that X action is scummy, or Y action is towny, it makes me feel very misaligned with the meta as a whole when i don't agree.
i know i shouldn't be bogged down in it.
pedit: this was a response to Nancy.In post 3420, Chara wrote:FL please i can't handle you scumreading skitter when i only changed my read on her because i felt stupid for scumreading her p l e a s eIn post 3435, Chara wrote:
and you've been saying this all game, yes.In post 3424, skitter30 wrote:
Sorry i dont mean to upset u ... i'm just having a hard time seeing u as town rnIn post 3413, Chara wrote:i'm upset that skitter and Tweet think i'm scum. it is silly, i know.
you really can't see me acting this way as town? whatever this way is?
I really think Chara is town here. I know I’m town and Tweetie seemed really genuine to me, so I think Skitter’s solve is very likely wrong.In post 3477, Chara wrote:i'm town, Pooky!!!!!!!!!!
Who am I reading wrong in this game?- Glory and Mel
-
Glory and Mel Goon
- Glory and Mel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 565
- Joined: January 12, 2021
maybe its like
{Venus, Chara, Catboi} or instead of Catboi maybe Fire?
Either way like i think i townread everyone else and fl wants to protect ydra for some reason so...
Ydrasse - ???
Glory and Mel (Gamma Emerald+Alisae) - town
Venus Mars and Pluto (Nancy Drew 39, Auro, and Shiro) - ???
Morning Tweet - Maybe town based on interactions but if things start flipping town and things go wrong maybe i need to think about this
Titus - town
Xtoxm - town
Starcrossed (Pooky+Kanna Hydra) - town
Hopkirk - town
Lunar Martian - town
chkflip - town
Dannflor - scum
Firebringer - ???
skitter30 - town
unwnd - town
RCEnigma - town
catboiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii -guttown but not strongly caring about it
Chara - ???- Glory and Mel
-
Glory and Mel Goon
- Glory and Mel
- Glory and Mel
-
Glory and Mel Goon
- Glory and Mel
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 565
- Joined: January 12, 2021
can we just go chara then?In post 4833, skitter30 wrote:
Ok sounds good: look in xtoxm/venus/chara/tweetie and note that tweetie/chara are not tvtIn post 4830, Flavor Leaf wrote:and ill take skitter reads into consideration if town.
dann voted tweetie and chara supported tweetieCopyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
- Glory and Mel
- Glory and Mel
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Starcrossed
- Starcrossed
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Starcrossed
- Starcrossed
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Starcrossed
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto
- Venus Mars and Pluto