Titus v Nancy Drew (Game Over)

[Pink Ball]

Idk reading again now that you quoted everything it really looks like scum trying to get rid of town lol if you're scum you just made me change my mind about a nullread

Fey is 99.9999% town. I’m never limming her.
Krazy was trying very hard to get her vaniillaized which made absolutely no sense to me since it’s beyond obvious he would have to know NS was a one shot, so he obviously wanted to target Fey and probably switch her with Koba.

I was talking to Sarah

[Pink Ball]

My vote is on Sarah in spirit, Nancy may direct things.

I definitely hope that happens because I definitely didn’t sanction the last flip but PB hammered and I literally didn’t even know the day had ended until I read the pm in my inbox.

Nancy, you wanted Toog gone. I fucked up hammering 'cause I didn't notice it was a hammer myself, but you did want that flip

No that isn’t true, Koba definitely did though. I wanted the day to play out and hopefully lim the bus driver. Had I wanted Toog elimed, my vote would have already been on him and I would probably have been opposed after I read Kanna’s post.

You are right, I forgot you wanted the bus driver!! My bad

[Pink Ball]

My readlist is the same that you posted Nancy but with me on top and Pyro on the bottom with the other three; I mean that's my PoE readlist. clidd would be higher than Sarah, Kid and Pyro. That's my final PoE.

[Titus]

Cool, so Sara is in fact scum.

I would appreciate more votes on her, thanks.

No

, TOWN STUMP APPRECIATES

NOT

RUSHING THIS DAY!!

But all good things come from rushing the day.

[Titus]

That Toog elimination was great.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Idk reading again now that you quoted everything it really looks like scum trying to get rid of town lol if you're scum you just made me change my mind about a nullread

Fey is 99.9999% town. I’m never limming her.
Krazy was trying very hard to get her vaniillaized which made absolutely no sense to me since it’s beyond obvious he would have to know NS was a one shot, so he obviously wanted to target Fey and probably switch her with Koba.

I was talking to Sarah

Oh, nm then.

[Nancy Drew 39]

That Toog elimination was great.

Yes, because you set him up, killing Koba tells me that it’s very likely ungated.

[Pink Ball]

If I had to doubt my townreads:

clidd: the most solid argument is that Krazy did want this elimmed because clidd is great as town and it's a solid strategy to get rid of him as soon as possible, especially if the other possible eliminations are not strong players (like Italiano or 5uffering), and by "strong" I don't mean 'bad', but players who you want to keep around so you can eliminate later. clidd is not like them, he gets harder to eliminate as the game goes on. If you get rid of that interaction 'cause "hey it's scum, it's WIFOM!", then yeah, clidd could be scum because of what he has been pushing has been constantly incorred iirc, from start to finish. Want to scumread clidd? Call him out on a BoP.

Dunn: the only time I have imagined Dunn as scum is because of mechanics. One of Kid/Dunn could perfectly be scum because of the setup, if not both messing with us. But Kid looks worse, everytime.

Fey: I don't think so, pal. (Maybe if you want me to stretch it, it could be that the nightskip by Fey was not really Fey, but it was Titus; Titus got a 1-shot dayvig by exchanging it with a nightskip, and they're using it to give one if her teammates a solid fakeclaim. Fey is the bus driver! Yeah, see? Makes no sense)

Kanna: I've been saying it since I repped in, they're town and I'm great reading her. This is conftown so I'm not even bothering.

Morning Tweet: being a messenger is practically being a VT so it's not her role what makes her town, but I think that if the scumteam already had suspicions about Kanna's role (and that's why the first message was directed at her), then I think Kanna would be dead already to avoid having a conftown. I don't really have any concerns about MT right now, I really liked her posts today, so I don't have any doubts about her.

So as you can see, every reasoning to try to scumread my townreads are weak if not inexistent. Instead, the rest of the playerlist, my PoE, have a much more solid ground.

Pyro, for instance, has been constantly pushing Kanna and Pooky to make them claim. I still believe that Battle Mage's wagon formed in part because he was partially scumreading Pyro, so he was the best counterwagon to W&P.

Sarah's V I B I N G aesthetic and trying to slip away by going with the consensus are the biggest reasons to scumread her, and that reasons are bigger than anything I said about my townreads.

And Kid well, I think how Gamma tried to approach this game was scummy. Not much to say about that without re reading again.

[Starcrossed]

thank GOD we're conftown so pyro's game-long shitpush on us can come to an end. i'm taking a v/la, but i agree with the consensus POE. the points clidd makes in 6208 onwards makes me feel good about voting sarah today

{fey} mechtown
{morning, clidd} highest degree of soultown

{pyro, pink ball} town, but there's chance of scum here
{dunn, kidd} kind of... towny? but POE

{sarah} lack of towniness

~mitsuha

[Pink Ball]

Oh forgot to say: Dunn townslipped early game, that's why I've been calling him town practically since I repped in. Now's a good time to say it since now almost everyone have him as a townread and scum is not getting rid of him

[Starcrossed]

Kanna: I've been saying it since I repped in, they're town and I'm great reading her. This is conftown so I'm not even bothering.

yayyyy!

~mitsuha

[Starcrossed]

Oh forgot to say: Dunn townslipped early game, that's why I've been calling him town practically since I repped in. Now's a good time to say it since now almost everyone have him as a townread and scum is not getting rid of him

where did he townslip?

~mitsuha

[Starcrossed]

I also hardtownread Kanna

~Taki

[Starcrossed]

I also hardtownread Kanna

~Taki

~mistuha

[Pink Ball]

I'm undecided on Dunnstral this far

Why are you afraid to townread me?

Should I be? Reading back, I do like your take on the wagon formation, and I like your prodding onto Sherlock.

It feels like you keep saying I'm null like you have reservations about me in some way.

Do you have any particular feelings toward the people trying to figure out who you are an alt of?

I haven't seen anything from you that I find scummy if that's what you're asking.

I find the speculation about my identity amusing. I like you, so I'll confirm or deny any one guess you have if you have one.

Nah I don't/can't alt guess and don't care to out you either, that wasn't where I was leading with that

I was under the impression that the stumps knew all the alts in the game, but upon review of the rules it doesn't say that anywhere. I believe this was something that happened in the last game and I'm not sure if the tradition has been carried over

So I'm looking at these guys alt guessing and I'm wondering what it means for their alignment.

Here's the townslip.

Also if you read over D1, Dunn was pushing two confirmed scum, bot S&W and W&P

[Pink Ball]

If Dunn had a PT with either Nancy or Titus, he wouldn't have posted that. That's how I knew he wasn't either scum or mason.

[Starcrossed]

I also hardtownread Kanna

~Taki

~mistuha

~Taki

[Titus]

That Toog elimination was great.

Yes, because you set him up, killing Koba tells me that it’s very likely ungated.

What's ungated?

I was looking forward to vanillaizing green scum. A miselimination still is helpful though.

[Pink Ball]

Sorry Pooky I keep forgetting the name of your hydra, and I also started townreading your slot because of Kanna. I don't know how to read you

[Nancy Drew 39]

If I had to doubt my townreads:

clidd: the most solid argument is that Krazy did want this elimmed because clidd is great as town and it's a solid strategy to get rid of him as soon as possible, especially if the other possible eliminations are not strong players (like Italiano or 5uffering), and by "strong" I don't mean 'bad', but players who you want to keep around so you can eliminate later. clidd is not like them, he gets harder to eliminate as the game goes on. If you get rid of that interaction 'cause "hey it's scum, it's WIFOM!", then yeah, clidd could be scum because of what he has been pushing has been constantly incorred iirc, from start to finish. Want to scumread clidd? Call him out on a BoP.

Dunn: the only time I have imagined Dunn as scum is because of mechanics. One of Kid/Dunn could perfectly be scum because of the setup, if not both messing with us. But Kid looks worse, everytime.

Fey: I don't think so, pal. (Maybe if you want me to stretch it, it could be that the nightskip by Fey was not really Fey, but it was Titus; Titus got a 1-shot dayvig by exchanging it with a nightskip, and they're using it to give one if her teammates a solid fakeclaim. Fey is the bus driver! Yeah, see? Makes no sense)

Kanna: I've been saying it since I repped in, they're town and I'm great reading her. This is conftown so I'm not even bothering.

Morning Tweet: being a messenger is practically being a VT so it's not her role what makes her town, but I think that if the scumteam already had suspicions about Kanna's role (and that's why the first message was directed at her), then I think Kanna would be dead already to avoid having a conftown. I don't really have any concerns about MT right now, I really liked her posts today, so I don't have any doubts about her.

So as you can see, every reasoning to try to scumread my townreads are weak if not inexistent. Instead, the rest of the playerlist, my PoE, have a much more solid ground.

Pyro, for instance, has been constantly pushing Kanna and Pooky to make them claim. I still believe that Battle Mage's wagon formed in part because he was partially scumreading Pyro, so he was the best counterwagon to W&P.

Sarah's V I B I N G aesthetic and trying to slip away by going with the consensus are the biggest reasons to scumread her, and that reasons are bigger than anything I said about my townreads.

And Kid well, I think how Gamma tried to approach this game was scummy. Not much to say about that without re reading again.

+1

I like this post. Yes, Pyro sr Kanna is the most concerning thing for me about him. He should know better than anyone that this is 100% Kanna’s towngame here. Even when I wasn’t confident on Pooky, I had slight townpings on Kanna right out of the gate. I’m also slightly paranoid that he might have been trying to possibly mason hunt them. But the bad Kanna read is pretty much my main concern with that slot.

I think Dunn is super obvtown both by play and by role and I have reasons to townlock Tweetie now.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I also hardtownread Kanna

~Taki

[Fey]

Pyro's had the same read on Starcrossed as I did for this game, I think? I didn't push it too much because I thought it'd resolve eventually so, yeah.

[Pyro]

Okay, sorry, Starcrossed.

Pyro, for instance, has been constantly pushing Kanna and Pooky to make them claim. I still believe that Battle Mage's wagon formed in part because he was partially scumreading Pyro, so he was the best counterwagon to W&P.

Why do you keep bringing up that Battle Mage point? It's very obvious that Battle Mage was wagoned and killed because of Batsunami's hard push and I don't get this conspiracy theory you keep bringing up, like what's the evidence behind it?

Pedit: I did say Kanna's play was the best part of their hydra, Nancy, Pooky's absolute lack of interest and lack of interaction with you really threw me off though. I'd have expected him to be interacting with you a whole lot more and to be much more involved with the game unless he was a mason already interacting with you in a mason PR, or a vig intentionally lurking to avoid a nightkill

[Pyro]

*mason PT

[Pyro]

Pyro, for instance, has been constantly pushing Kanna and Pooky to make them claim.

Yes, this was intentional.