Large Normal 232—Sibyl's Elegy [GAME OVER]

[WindowsXP]

yea im new this is my first game

No you're not the way you are confident about this traitor thing implies you think you have knowlege about forum mafia
Whats your main/site you came from?

[bloodhail]

She is probably the towniest for me and this was my reaction on her post before tgat, that she doent believe this claim,and i was confused too at that moment,because i didnt believe enchant who made e-1, and i was thinking tgat it can be their plan now with cabd,but then i made some analysis about possibility of this plan and i think that more chances tgat they are not together. If samantha insisted on hammering, maybe i would do that at that moment, trusting tgat she knows these people better. But then i got one more idea, that we ve got ne info and we need time to think and discuss,i began asking ppl to unvote

i see

okay that checks out you can be town

[bloodhail]

yea im new this is my first game

No you're not the way you are confident about this traitor thing implies you think you have knowlege about forum mafia
Whats your main/site you came from?

ive never played mafia before im new

[WindowsXP]

yea im new this is my first game

No you're not the way you are confident about this traitor thing implies you think you have knowlege about forum mafia
Whats your main/site you came from?

ive never played mafia before im new

doubt.jpg

[WindowsXP]

so you think there are at least 2 scums and 1 pr? what do you suggest? to elim someone among etine/kitty/t3?

i think mafia usually claims pr when run up so at least 1 is fake

[bloodhail]

good talk

[Vasex]

i think he is joking and testing you

[Marky Mark]

Mark, you are the third one asking about this)
Ok smth like this:
1) i wanted to finish day faster; i dont know for sure who is cabd, so i dont care much about him;
2) i wanted to add some pepper, to get more info from other actions, to get some scummy fails, like enchant did, voting on e-1 for his townie
3) in few moments (like in a moment after reaction of std or about that) i was thinking that me voting cabd can prevent some other votes, who dont want to vote in this direction maybe with me or if i just ask to vote smb loud this has opposite effect to others

It should be obvious that it was a fake, especially when i was joking about amount of votes or when i said that we should help Kitty and Anastasia to elim cabd (obviously joke, because they are scums for me), or just because cabd was null for me far away from bottom-scums from my list like kitty encgant and anastasia

Thanks for the explanation.

1.) Rushed days are not in the town's best interests
2.) Fair point
3.) You were voting cabd and yelling at everyone to vote him to make people not want to vote him?!??

[Marky Mark]

Like I get the whole running up a wagon to fish for reactions thing but that last point seems like a massive stretch and feels like retrospective justification

[Marky Mark]

VOTE: Vasex

Yeah, I'm not buying this and I was already starting to have my doubts about you

[Marky Mark]

yea im new this is my first game

No you're not the way you are confident about this traitor thing implies you think you have knowlege about forum mafia
Whats your main/site you came from?

ive never played mafia before im new

doubt.jpg

+1

[Andresvmb]

I’m going to be honest. I’m completely embarrassed we’re not executing T3. They’re so obviously Scum the claim really shouldn’t be saving them.

Look at 935, 969, 971, and tell me that’s the reaction of a player that has seen someone claim their role and is certain they’re Scum. Look this is my way of thinking about it, and it’s possible it’s coloring my view, but here it goes. I’m proud of games where I pick out 2/3 of the Team or something, or make one solid play that sets my team up. That’s what I live for. I don’t think of myself as strong enough or perceptive enough to provide complete solves, or absolutely murder all of the Scum, or mechanically provide perfect answers. So when presented with the opportunity to sacrifice myself for the execution of sure Scum, I take it. If a player claims my role under pressure and I’m suspecting them, I would out and bury them. No questions asked. And in a game this large, the fact that you make yourself such an obvious target means that there’s all kinds of information that could come out if. T3 is

not

acting this way at all. Instead of clearly pushing Kitty who is rapidly losing momentum, and provide either a claim, strong reasoning, or a laser focus, they switch to Enchant, claiming they Scum slipped. Not only is their play incredibly Scummy on its own - the Claim, and the immediate reaction, are spectacularly hard to believe.

Look, I’m fine with looking past the claim. At the end of the day my vote isn’t there. But I want to be crystal clear - T3 should get executed tomorrow. And I’m certain they’ll be around to tell us about their “check”.

[Vasex]

VOTE: Vasex

[Andresvmb]

ugh you know what
vote kitty
if kitty isn't scum vote me tomorrow i'm just a 1 shot bulletproof and after everyone RANDOLY scumreading it's not like mafia will ever try to kill me

Like how is this not just the most ridiculous thing ever?! To try and bury them after your silly reactions you claim Bulletproof?! Why would that make your voice more believable?

Anyway rant over. One of those two slots is Scum. It could very well be Kitty and I could just be way wrong which I have been hahaha so, that’s possible. I just don’t understand the thinking behind some of this at all.

[Andresvmb]

that could come out if.

*that could come out of it.

[Andresvmb]

vote enchant to see if there is a kitty enchant conspiracy without losing a possible 1 shot cop
i don't even know why i claimed i guess i was just annoyed that people were't voting kitty

C’MON MAN.

[Marky Mark]

Andre you are preaching to the choir mate. I've been voting there, but there just wasn't the town consensus to put a T3 elim through.

[Marky Mark]

I think people are leaning towards the "Leave it till D2 so that we at least get a result if they actually are town" strat, which I am fine with for Kitty, but meh I think that's giving T3 too much credit after the BP fakeclaim

[Kerset]

It nice Adre that you say all of this 5 days later, not when I needed more supporters to get T3 voted out.

[DrippingGoofball]

yea im new this is my first game

No you're not the way you are confident about this traitor thing implies you think you have knowlege about forum mafia
Whats your main/site you came from?

ive never played mafia before im new

DIE SCUM DIE

[Kerset]

At the moment i am open for all of {Enchant, Vasex, T3} but i am pretty sure that Enchant is the only one of them that can be realistically eliminated.

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: Vasex

[Nero Cain]

I mean you aren't even voting t3, andre

[Kerset]

ok maybe VOTE: Vasex can happen

[Cabd]

Wait I’ve gathered 4 votes purely amongst people I TR?

Those are rookie numbers.