Mini Theme 2212: Ircher's Grand Idea Mafia: SCUM WIN

[Vaxkiller]

I still wann know Roberts role.

[Asteria]

Maybe my discard? It has a D1 vig

[Ircher]

Which players haven't claimed their role order? I know I haven't claimed mine.

I thought we agreed we weren't doing this unless it could out scum immediately?

I guess we're claiming picks now:
-town compulsive hidden N1 RC N2 tracker (etc)
-town D1 vig, N1 vig, D2 gunsmith (etc)
-mafia restricted joat
-cult leader

Did everyone seriously submit vigilante? Come on, there's plenty of other cool roles to choose. Like an Egotist for instance.

Aight instead of me reading why don’t someone just give me the rundown of the highlights of the day so far.

Happy scum day!

Anyway, that's easy:

1) I noted that there's only two octuplet voters in my entire ISO and I submitted both of them as possible roles. One is werewolf and one is town.
2) A wagon forms on xz, one of the two octuplet voters in this game. The other is SirCakez.
3) A day vig privately shoots xz for a mafia flip.
4) Flea decides to conftown both SirCakez (100% reasonable) and me (very ???) based off the xz flip.
6) VFP and Lustice Justice get into an argument. One of them replaced out.

That about covers everything worth noting.

[Maruchan]

psyche replaces VFP

[Psyche]

ah, what have i done!

[Almost50]

I'm not town locking the VFP slot for ducking out, I'm town locking it because now we know it was not theater as confirmed by the mod.

I am not locking him as Town for either of these. I am Town locking him because I am old enough that I actually watched the original Flipper series on the rerun (like.. maybe 10 years after it was originally aired for the 1st time).

[Almost50]

What I miss?

I picked town 1 shot time manipulator, town traitor,

jester

, and werewolf infinite shot day fruit vendor

Wait. WHAT??

@ItalianoVD

[Psyche]

Anyone else catching a weird bug with post #175? Iso seems to say Robert M Hunter made the post, pew pew meow. But just looking at page 8 identifies Vaxkiller's? Eh

[Almost50]

ah, what have i done!

You shot yourself in the foot. That's what.

[Psyche]

guillotina is lustice jeague tight?

[Almost50]

Anyone else catching a weird bug with post #175? Iso seems to say Robert M Hunter made the post, pew pew meow. But just looking at page 8 identifies Vaxkiller's? Eh

aaah.. erm.. I could've sworn a post by Robert did say that, and it was at the bottom of page 7 (post #174). I can't find it anymore. THAT is what triggered Vax to ask if Robert was claiming Vig.

[Almost50]

guillotina is lustice jeague tight?

Yup

[Psyche]

Robert Hunter is very probably not mafia; would be unwise even as a gambit to shoot a bud in the circumstances under which it happened. Not sure if there's a neutral role that could've performed the kill though as I haven't really looked at the role pool yet.

Cake is town.
Irch is very probably not mafia.

Lustice is next strongest not-scum read. Lustice's turn against xz03yx that seemed to swing the wagon against sircake seemed really genuine; the xz03yx post they singled out was genuinely sketchy and for the reasons specified. Nothing in the rest of their performance came off as disingenuous either, leading me to lean more toward an explicit townread rather than just a not-scum read. I have no solid approach to search out SKs this early though.

Flea is a weaker not-mafia read. Post 122 came off as genuine everything afterward read as consistent too.

I think I also townread Enchant but it's weaker; 187 seems to reflect a certain naivette I wouldn't expect of scum.

I'd honestly prefer to lynch any of the people I haven't mentioned yet. None have done enough for me to meaningfully differentiate between them besides some gross differences in amount of fluff.

[Maruchan]

Anyone else catching a weird bug with post #175? Iso seems to say Robert M Hunter made the post, pew pew meow. But just looking at page 8 identifies Vaxkiller's? Eh

175/176 are switched on post numbers in respective ISOs for me too

[Psyche]

Best bet atm is Asteria

VOTE: Asteria

Some okay-ish reasons:
- VCA (sircakez vote, then conveniently disappeared as discourse evolved toward his alternative)
- Apparently keeping up with the thread and engaged but not really generating content
- Consequently, I'm not seeing much sincere searching nor an excuse for that dearth

[Almost50]

OK.. I hadn't even paid attention to Asteria before, and yes the voting history doesn't look good for her at all

[Almost50]

That was supposed to include a vote

VOTE: Asteria

[Guillotina]

I scum read her earlier but I forgot why.

It was something about a yeet working for her, as if any yeet was ok for her.

Let's push there and see what's up.

VOTE: FLEA

[Guillotina]

I scum read her earlier but I forgot why.

It was something about a yeet working for her, as if any yeet was ok for her.

Let's push there and see what's up.

VOTE: FLEA

Ooops

VOTE: Asteria

[Almost50]

@Guillo: Dopes this look familiar?

Flea works for me

VOTE: Flea

Also, how about you switch accounts and save yourself, us & the mod the trouble??

[Lustice Jeague]

@Guillo: Dopes this look familiar?

Flea works for me

VOTE: Flea

Also, how about you switch accounts and save yourself, us & the mod the trouble??

OMG, I need to forget about Guillotina account as long as this game lasts. This is so embarrassing!

[Lustice Jeague]

@Guillo: Dopes this look familiar?

Flea works for me

VOTE: Flea

Also, how about you switch accounts and save yourself, us & the mod the trouble??

OMG, I need to forget about Guillotina account as long as this game lasts. This is so embarrassing!

VOTE: Asteria

[Asteria]

Best bet atm is Asteria

VOTE: Asteria

Some okay-ish reasons:
- VCA (sircakez vote, then conveniently disappeared as discourse evolved toward his alternative)
- Apparently keeping up with the thread and engaged but not really generating content
- Consequently, I'm not seeing much sincere searching nor an excuse for that dearth

I have 3 clears and 1 solid vca scumread which I think is pretty good. That's a little over a third of the players sorted.

[Enchant]

There we have.

Flea The Magician:

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, burning like paper.

ItalianoVD:

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, silentive even more than me.
Role picks:
1. Town JOAT
2. Town Vigilante Gunsmith Vanilla Cop Neighborizer Doctor Roleblocker
3. Alien Night Kill Immune Miller Vigilante
4. Mafia Strongman 2-Shot Vigilante

Asteria:

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, having wolf on avatar, confirmed werewolf
Role picks:
1. Town Compulsive Hidden N1 RC N2 Tracker (etc)
2. Town D1 Vigilante, N1 Vigilante, D2 Gunsmith (etc)
3. Mafia Restricted JOAT
4. Cult Leader

Ircher:

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, person without which game would't exist
Role picks:
1. Town Octuplet Voter
2. Werewolf Octuplet Voter
3. ???
4. ???

Lustice Jeague

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, WHO USES LINKS INSTEAD OF DIRECT STATEMENT
Role picks:
1. Town 3-Multishot Day Vigilante
2. Town Bulletproof Vigilante Miller
3. Mafia Doctor Switch
4. Bulletproof Ascetic Serial Killer

VFP:

Spoiler:

Claimed Hated Townie (?), Main shitposter
Rolepicks:
1. Hated Townie (???)
2. ???
3. ???
4. ???

Vaxkiller

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, didn't kill anyone yet (or did?)
Role picks:
1. Serial Killer Post Restrict Lie Detector
2. Town Post Restricted Lie Detector
3. Town RGB Cop
4. Mafia 2 Shot Vigilante

Robert M Hunter

Spoiler:

Claimed Day Vigilante, Psychopatic Cat
Role picks
1. Town 1-Shot Friendly Grandest Reroller
2. Town Reflexive Reflexifier
3. Egotist (Moderator chooses alignment.)
4. Neutral Survivor Shop Owner

No Mafia Picks. Strange. Is this even allowed?

T3

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, why these picks...
Role picks:
1. Vanilla Townie
2. Vanilla Townie
3. Mafia 2-Shot Vig Strongman
4. Peacemaker

SirCakez

Spoiler:

Claimed Octuplet Voter, probably most confirmed person here
Role picks:
1. Town 1-Shot Time Manipulator
2. Town Traitor
3. Jester
4. Werewolf Infinite Shot Day Fruit Vendor

Enchant

Spoiler:

Claimed NULL, I like this person!
Role picks:
1. Town Kamikaze
2. Town Desperado
3. Mafia Reflexive Condemnerizer
4. Condemner 1-Shot Day Vigilante

Almost50

Spoiler:

Claimed Bulletproof Miller Vigilante, probably not gonna die horrible

xz03yx

Spoiler:

Died as Anti-Town Werewolf Octuplet Voter, furry

Tried to collect it in one post.

If you didn't claim rolelist, you are not forced to tell ALL of them. Just tell non-town Rolepicks, so we can have idea what we can face. Mafia and neutrals already know what roles they get, you know. There's little reason to not tell.

[Psyche]

Best bet atm is Asteria

VOTE: Asteria

Some okay-ish reasons:
- VCA (sircakez vote, then conveniently disappeared as discourse evolved toward his alternative)
- Apparently keeping up with the thread and engaged but not really generating content
- Consequently, I'm not seeing much sincere searching nor an excuse for that dearth

I have 3 clears and 1 solid vca scumread which I think is pretty good. That's a little over a third of the players sorted.

if it's a solid scumread then where's the push to grow a wagon