In post 5534, Ircher wrote:Why thestatusquo? I think he has had some good takes this game. On the other hand, it's clear my reads are really bad this game.
Changed my mind. Catboi is the easier elimination and just very likely to be scum.
In post 5549, Bell wrote:I agree that a town kitty is very useful though. I like catboi and think he's a good town player.
It's just that the basics tell me at least one scum was off both wagons and that replace outs are more likely to be scum than not. It's not a complicated read. But I find it very likely to be accurate.
there were only two players off of both wagons, Fire and notscience. i don't see why those basics apply here given almost all of the playerlist was on a wagon. Fire's slot was off the wagon because they were lurking.
i townread Fire's early game and the read kind of dropped off due to the inactivity, for context.
i think kitty will make himself very readable today if he'd like to see the morning, too.
"Sibling," Farkran asked, starting slowly.
"The CORE is full of lasers, and Chemist1422's entire existence depends on her eye. If she looks into a laser, she will almost certainly die. Did you think about that?"
"Oh yes, my brother. I love thinking about that."
In post 5549, Bell wrote:I agree that a town kitty is very useful though. I like catboi and think he's a good town player.
It's just that the basics tell me at least one scum was off both wagons and that replace outs are more likely to be scum than not. It's not a complicated read. But I find it very likely to be accurate.
"Are you...familiar with the pup of fire at all? Because such reasoning should hardly hold weight to those with any passing knowledge of his tendencies. Further, why is the lack of vote from
「WHITE FIRE」
on a wagon a sign of villainy when they appear to have gone totally absent from the game? The argument seems tenuous at best."
In post 5549, Bell wrote:I agree that a town kitty is very useful though. I like catboi and think he's a good town player.
It's just that the basics tell me at least one scum was off both wagons and that replace outs are more likely to be scum than not. It's not a complicated read. But I find it very likely to be accurate.
"Are you...familiar with the pup of fire at all? Because such reasoning should hardly hold weight to those with any passing knowledge of his tendencies. Further, why is the lack of vote from
「WHITE FIRE」
on a wagon a sign of villainy when they appear to have gone totally absent from the game? The argument seems tenuous at best."
In post 5552, Ircher wrote:Why the roleplay is very interesting, I don't think it helps us with regards to townreading you.
"I joined this adventure to have a good time, and I intend to do so regardless of what ludicrous accusations it may bring against me. A journey isn't worthwhile if you can't bring a bit of levity to it. Besides, I believe my good intentions should become perfectly clear in time regardless. If you wish for me to prove myself, tell me why you suspect me of being a Villain."
In post 5549, Bell wrote:I agree that a town kitty is very useful though. I like catboi and think he's a good town player.
It's just that the basics tell me at least one scum was off both wagons and that replace outs are more likely to be scum than not. It's not a complicated read. But I find it very likely to be accurate.
"Are you...familiar with the pup of fire at all? Because such reasoning should hardly hold weight to those with any passing knowledge of his tendencies. Further, why is the lack of vote from
「WHITE FIRE」
on a wagon a sign of villainy when they appear to have gone totally absent from the game? The argument seems tenuous at best."
So, you're attacking my argument.
"Yes? I know your conclusion is wrong, and the reasons you have used for it are rather poor. Would you mind answering my questions?"
In post 5566, Ircher wrote:VOTE: Something_Smart
I actually think this might be better.
Elaborate on the scum equity of S_S over Catboi please.
They're about equal but I'm inclined to maybe give catboi a benefit of the doubt as like I said, I was mildly town reading White Fire day 1, but I can't say the same for Something_Smart.
@catboi -- Give us some reads to work with. That's probably the most useful thing for you to do to show you are town.