Silent Star 4: Yin and Yang

[clidd]

I'm not really in favor of it, but the intent to hammer thing and the lack of solving are probably somewhat scummy. His elim might give us info too.

This post, for example ^

[Ydrasse]

My problem with the scum!Infinity theory is that she could've just avoided posting sus stuff like "Ircher towny" and keeping coasting until forced to react to a wagon on her.

i mean she can’t do nothing either tbf, maybe she thought that simple whatever “weird” answers would be towny or something because they’re like, not going anywhere

and getting any reaction was like pulling teeth which says a lot

p-edit is that really a post that infinity would think is sus in the moment?

[Ydrasse]

like we can say “oh scum try to avoid saying scummy stuff” assuming perfect play

[clidd]

Overall the narrative of his play is +town I think

Not that it makes much sense as town, but it makes less sense as scum

Wrong post, i mean this one ^

[NorwegianboyEE]

Why would scum be scum and do scummy things?? ??

[Amy Dunne]

I'm not really in favor of it, but the intent to hammer thing and the lack of solving are probably somewhat scummy. His elim might give us info too.

This post, for example ^

She’s not wrong though because an Ircher scum flip would prove Yin is lying. Idk, I’m good with any of the three.

My main concern with Infinity is that she seems to be unhappy to be in this game. I don’t know how she feels about playing scum but I’m just picking up this sense that she’s not happy in this game. Ironically Tanner said that about me but I was just exhausted from being extremely confused overgamed but I’m just sensing unhappiness.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Like not everyone has the power to "ascend" when called out for being scummy and immediately fix all their mistakes and look like a town Norse god.
Only Chara can do that.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Sometimes as scum you just feel trapped and can’t do anything because you don’t feel strong enough to beat the town.
Infinity seems like that type of person.

[Amy Dunne]

i refuse to accept npctesting as a reason i need to hear why you think tanner is scum

The game and mechanics are centered around Yin and Yang.

There is potential for Yin to be spewing BS, but I have noticed a pattern around their responses. Patterns which are consistent.

Frankly i've already put too much effort into this game so now I'm lazy playing.

And what is the connection with Tanner? He doesn’t seem scummy to me, so I really don’t understand what you’re seeing?

[clidd]

Why would scum be scum and do scummy things?? ??

Scum is always scum but it's part of the game to avoid demonstrating that they are scum (and that includes trying to avoid posts that are can be seem as scummy). That's basic scumplay.

[Amy Dunne]

I'm not really in favor of it, but the intent to hammer thing and the lack of solving are probably somewhat scummy. His elim might give us info too.

This post, for example ^

She’s not wrong though because an Ircher scum flip would prove Yin is lying. Idk, I’m good with any of the three.

My main concern with Infinity is that she seems to be unhappy to be in this game. I don’t know how she feels about playing scum but I’m just picking up this sense that she’s not happy in this game. Ironically Tanner said that about me but I was just exhausted from being extremely overgamed but I’m just sensing unhappiness.

I hate autocorrect sometimes.

[NorwegianboyEE]

By your logic scum never makes scummy posts ever in history because scum always avoids doing anything scummy.

[Ydrasse]

i have to clock in now

get em norwee

[clidd]

Sometimes as scum you just feel trapped and can’t do anything because you don’t feel strong enough to beat the town.
Infinity seems like that type of person.

Yep, can occur depending on the person.

Not sure if Infinity is the case.

[NorwegianboyEE]

So Clidd. The scum are who then? MT and Tanner because they never do anything scummy?
Go in league with Nakata then i suppose.

[clidd]

By your logic scum never makes scummy posts ever in history because scum always avoids doing anything scummy.

Which is why I added "trying".

[clidd]

So Clidd. The scum are who then? MT and Tanner because they never do anything scummy?
Go in league with Nakata then i suppose.

Probably Nakata.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Scummy by definition is: "likely to come from the mafia allignment"
So saying a post is scummy directly means you’re saying: "coming from the mafia allignment", you can’t then turn around and say it actually makes them town.
Granted, the word you might be looking for could be: "anti-town" as both town and scum can do some extremely anti-town actions that doesn’t necesarilly prove whether their allignment is leaning one way or the other. Take N_M hammering for instance. He’d do it as scum and town. But it’s always anti-town.
So if you actually meant anti-town please consider using that word from now on or clarifying you didn’t mean that.

[clidd]

Ok, so what's your point?

[NorwegianboyEE]

Not sure if Infinity is the case.

Do you have meta evidencing Infinity is more likely town in this case?

[clidd]

No.

[Amy Dunne]

Alternatively, he could just be scum who made a simple mistake and decided to avoid/abandon the game (or had some outside interference), but that's not a satisfactory explanation given the way he navigated the suspicion on you.

Just remember: scum aren't perfect. They try, but they fail as well.

What do people think about this?

This was Clidd referencing Robert and Ircher’s reaction to that?

[Amy Dunne]

Alternatively, he could just be scum who made a simple mistake and decided to avoid/abandon the game (or had some outside interference), but that's not a satisfactory explanation given the way he navigated the suspicion on you.

Just remember: scum aren't perfect. They try, but they fail as well.

What do people think about this?

This was Clidd referencing Robert and Ircher’s reaction to that?

Actually probably NAI.

[NorwegianboyEE]

Ok, so what's your point?

That i disagree with your: "Infinity is town for making a scummy post" take.

[clidd]

Ok, so what's your point?

That i disagree with your: "Infinity is town for making a scummy post" take.

It's fine.