3d20 – The Great Board Game War [GAME OVER]

[SirCakez]

pagetop

[Dwlee99]

bruh my last game together u were scum lol

I was dog town wdym

[SirCakez]

shush

[Dragon of the West]

Last comment before I disappear again for a little while, I'm 99% sure cyrus62 didn't actually roll PGO or he didn't roll town.
JamesTheNames' explanation:
He at first just declared he rolled a 7 somewhere. I believe he intended to use this, to fake claim PGO at some point in the future. After people started to claim he had to insert the 7 somewhere, so he just put it at the front. I don't think he expected someone to realise it was PGO so early on, and hence the weird response when I outed it. I'm confident either a scum partner of his "rolled PGO", or nothing at all. He could definitely be lying about his role, and actually be the one who rolled a Mason-type for Dwlee99.

Cyrus definitely didn't say 7 with the intention to fake claim PGO in the future. It's just so unlikely he plans that far ahead to make a fake claim. James, I'm assuming you haven't played with Cyrus before, right? Stop trying to make him make sense, he never does even when he's town

[Dwlee99]

T3 I want your James townread explanation cause I feel like he is spending his time finding LHF or weird non-AI stuff to scumread people for. Messing up what modifier I rolled isn't scum-indicative but James thinks it is worthy of a vote.

[T3]

The Titus thing was a random thing, the claiming thing I stopped because people wer already claiming.

[T3]

T3 I want your James townread explanation cause I feel like he is spending his time finding LHF or weird non-AI stuff to scumread people for. Messing up what modifier I rolled isn't scum-indicative but James thinks it is worthy of a vote.

He is absolutely set in his ways of tunneling cyrus.

[Dwlee99]

T3 I want your James townread explanation cause I feel like he is spending his time finding LHF or weird non-AI stuff to scumread people for. Messing up what modifier I rolled isn't scum-indicative but James thinks it is worthy of a vote.

He is absolutely set in his ways of tunneling cyrus.

Did you read the last page

[redtea]

bit busy at the moment, will be around in the evening

[JamesTheNames]

T3 I want your James townread explanation cause I feel like he is spending his time finding LHF or weird non-AI stuff to scumread people for. Messing up what modifier I rolled isn't scum-indicative but James thinks it is worthy of a vote.

Actually it was a combination of both things I pointed out.

[Dwlee99]

Saying I'm mason is also not AI

[cyrus62]

so is there two town roleblockers and only 2 people rolled scum no one rolled cult or ww?

[cyrus62]

or alien

[Dwlee99]

I think that the mod likely changed alignments of some of the roles because 11v2 wouldn't be very balanced

[cyrus62]

I think that the mod likely changed alignments of some of the roles because 11v2 wouldn't be very balanced

so we cant go by the 1st dice?

[Dwlee99]

Not necessarily cause five roles had at least one dice changed.

[cyrus62]

Not necessarily cause five roles had at least one dice changed.

that makes it a bit tricky .

[cyrus62]

well im not going role fish lets just see who is shaded

[cyrus62]

well we know theres a cult bus driver .

[cyrus62]

i think any way lol

[JamesTheNames]

Stop trying to make him make sense, he never does even when he's town

All the more reason to hammer then?
Anti-town is anti-town. Even if a person always acts in an anti-town fashion or a weird fashion does not change that fact.

[JamesTheNames]

I'm not going to metadive. Without any changes made by Cook, there are 216,000 roles a single person can get, a number with 39 0s for combinations of 13 people. There are too many options for it to be reliable. If he does something scummy it is scummy regardless of if people think it is all a waste of time.

[Marashu]

After doing that and doing some pondering about mechanics, 3 things came to mind before anything else.
First of all, in 33 Dwlee tells us he rolled a Town Parity Cop with a Multitasking modification, as such, I put down the scores for such a role, in the list earlier.
The numbers he gave us were, [12, 8, 14] the 12 means Town, the 8 means Parity Cop, the 14 means Rampaging. Note, Rampaging, not Multitasking.

Secondly, in 14 we get told he rolled a Mason role, we don't have a Mason role revealed by anybody.

Thirdly, we are informed by redtea that there is a Mafia Fruit Vendor, I'm not going to say I don't believe this but for now I'll say I'm neutral on this claim. My reasoning for this is as follows, if we assume redtea initially rolled Town Fruit Vendor, and was then giving a non-Town role, him revealing the Fruit Vendor as Mafia, means the Fruit Vendor can no longer use their abilities, as they'd be seen as scum for doing so (correct me if I'm incorrect). So if there is a Town Fruit Vendor hiding out there somewhere, can you reveal yourself if so? If not I believe it is safe to assume redtea is telling the truth at least in terms of alignment.

It is possible that I might be able to give fruit. My role was not in the list. I suspect I might have cyrus' roll.

[Dragon of the West]

Stop trying to make him make sense, he never does even when he's town

All the more reason to hammer then?
Anti-town is anti-town. Even if a person always acts in an anti-town fashion or a weird fashion does not change that fact.

Just feels like a wasted lim tbh. Otherwise I'd just lim Cyrus as the very first lim in every game I'm in with him because he's always anti town

[JamesTheNames]

Stop trying to make him make sense, he never does even when he's town

All the more reason to hammer then?
Anti-town is anti-town. Even if a person always acts in an anti-town fashion or a weird fashion does not change that fact.

Just feels like a wasted lim tbh. Otherwise I'd just lim Cyrus as the very first lim in every game I'm in with him because he's always anti town

I suspect this is a policy matter we are going to just have to agree to disagree on.