Open 825 - PYP X/Y: HoS_S [game over!]

[Datisi]

vote count 1.02

with 14 votes in play, it takes 8 to make a decision. day 1 ends in (expired on 2021-09-03 17:20:00).

yeet

ManateeGal [3]:

PenguinPower, Gamma Emerald, Harvey and Haley

Flea The Magician [1]:

Bee

Gamma Emerald [1]:

Titus

Titus [1]:

Enchant

the worst [1]:

Cat Scratch Fever

not voting [7]:

Flea the Magician, Something_Smart, Thor Ragnarok, House, the worst, Miss Midnight, ManateeGal

mod notes

~ the worst and ManateeGal have (expired on 2021-08-26 12:00:00) to confirm their role pm before i start looking for replacements

flavour

[Harvey and Haley]

Your list is upside down!

what do you make of me voting manatee then?

Bee's reversed list would put you and ManateeGal towards the top; wouldn't it be more interesting to direct this question towards me?

-Harvey

[Cat Scratch Fever]

why?

I don't think Enchant read past iterations of PYP if he thought people would always first pick vig. I think scum almost certainly would have looked at what numbers and roles people have picked in past games.

[Bee]

*Interesting* comments going on here.

[Cat Scratch Fever]

Enchant, do you have any particular reason for the Titus vote?

Bee is Vigilante 100%.

Why would you reveal that?

-Harvey

It's obvious, every

townie

worth salt pick Vig.

Actually Enchant, do you think scum would also have first picked vig? Why assume Bee is town?

[Enchant]

No, i don't think so. One kill in early game doesn't make much difference. It could be used for SURPRISE in the end... But nah, because it's strange to not shot things as Vig-Townie.
Expect for 3-Night vig, which is same as 1-Shot vig, but probably made specially to not make this strange.

If digging deep, it's obvious who have PRs. So if one makes really insane shots as Vig which benefit mafia more, i believe we find him fast.


Also, i assume everyone as town, unless there's reason for otherwise.

[Flea The Magician]

VOTE: Flea the Magician

Fight me.

Spoiler: When you're as cute as this? {large image}

[Flea The Magician]

VOTE: Harvey and Hayley

[Gamma Emerald]

There’s no such thing as a bad vig shot.

And I don’t think there is unless they try to claim something that someone else took. But otherwise they can either true claim or VT and we won’t know until night actions.

I disagree, I've seen a bad vig shot firsthand

also I think scum have enough wiggle room to know what should possibly be a safe claim to make? There's room for error I guess but I feel like the fact they get to coordinate factors into this

Just narrowing the POE...! I don’t think I’ve ever successfully shot scum as vig.

And yeah, maybe after a bit they’ll have fake claims if they want. I’ve never paid attention to runs of this setup but do scum generally go for claiming roles they don’t have or is it played safe?

I've shot scum a few times as vig, it's fun
but I've also made some pretty dumb shots, as well as seen dumb shots made by others

[Miss Midnight]

why?

I don't think Enchant read past iterations of PYP if he thought people would always first pick vig. I think scum almost certainly would have looked at what numbers and roles people have picked in past games.

Good logic. Early townreads for me on you, Enchant, and Bee.

VOTE: ManateeGal

[Gamma Emerald]

Your list is upside down!

what do you make of me voting manatee then?

Bee's reversed list would put you and ManateeGal towards the top; wouldn't it be more interesting to direct this question towards me?

-Harvey

nah
I think it's reasonable to expect an early distancing vote

[ManateeGal]

VOTE: mantaeegal

no aquatic mammalian alliance?

[PenguinPower]

VOTE: mantaeegal

no aquatic mammalian alliance?

you stole my number

no alliance.

also birds are not mammals

[ManateeGal]

hmph.

VOTE: pemguinpower

[PenguinPower]

can't even spell my name right

smh

[ManateeGal]

can't even spell my name right

smh

[Enchant]

Could scum pick same number with someone?

Otherwise all samenumber pickers can't be both mafia i think.

[Gamma Emerald]

Could scum pick same number with someone?

Otherwise all samenumber pickers can't be both mafia i think.

yeah
I've seen scum deliberately pick the same number as a distancing move before in this sort of game

[Enchant]

Sacrifice PR chances for that?...

... Honestly brilliant. No one expect that.

[Harvey and Haley]

Good logic. Early townreads for me on you, Enchant, and Bee.

Can you explain the Bee townread? Thanks.

-Harvey
(Also my partner is Haley not

Hayley

)

[Gamma Emerald]

Sacrifice PR chances for that?...

... Honestly brilliant. No one expect that.

in a setup like this I guess that wouldn't be as advised, the instance I mentioned was in a smalltown role madness game

[Something_Smart]

I've seen scum deliberately pick the same number as a distancing move before in this sort of game

I wouldn't expect them to do that while choosing multitasking.

[Thor Ragnarok]

Greetings Asgardians

[Thor Ragnarok]

Scum probably went low to get better roles to win, so I estimate 2 or 3 scum in these players:

Bee 5
the worst 3
Cat Scratch Fever 3
Enchant 4
House 4

[Gamma Emerald]

tbh I'm maybe curious as to what led Flea to pick 13
that's a number I think you pick for a reason