I mean, yes, they're the protagonists, but that doesn't mean they don't make sense as the scum team. If you were doing a Godfather themed game, wouldn't you want the - *googles the movie* - Corleone family to be a scum team? (I'm assuming the answer is yes, but I do not know anything about the Godfather)In post 445, Shrek wrote:cause theyre the protagonists of the show and also a sample scum pm was for the witches i think
Mini 2237: Scarlet Witch Alternate Reality Mafia - Game Over
Forum rules
no??? theyre the protagonistsIn post 450, Zyla wrote:I mean, yes, they're the protagonists, but that doesn't mean they don't make sense as the scum team. If you were doing a Godfather themed game, wouldn't you want the - *googles the movie* - Corleone family to be a scum team? (I'm assuming the answer is yes, but I do not know anything about the Godfather)In post 445, Shrek wrote:cause theyre the protagonists of the show and also a sample scum pm was for the witches i think
- Guillotina
- Guillotina
-
Guillotina
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2746
- Joined: November 2, 2020
That's because I don't know that you are scum, I suspect you to be scum dude. If I knew you were scum, you'd be dead already.In post 412, Roden wrote:If I'm scum with an agenda and you're town, I don't have to understand why you're pushing me because obviously I am your enemy. Town can't plead with scum to try to understand them because scum's objective is to deceive and kill despite knowing the truth. So why are you pleading with scum to understand your perspective?In post 410, Guillotina wrote:No, I'm implying that you are scum with an agenda. I've been very clear that I don't town read you.In post 398, Roden wrote:Actually if you genuinely believe that I never considered to understand why you're pushing me, that implies you think I'm town.
If I'm not a town read, then you're slipping that I'm town through TMI.
1) The only difference between town and scum is TMI.
2) If scum can do it, so can town, except TMI.
3) The best way to tell the truth in a game of lies is by lying and the best way to lie in a games of lies is by telling the truth.
2) If scum can do it, so can town, except TMI.
3) The best way to tell the truth in a game of lies is by lying and the best way to lie in a games of lies is by telling the truth.
- Guillotina
- Guillotina
-
Guillotina
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 2746
- Joined: November 2, 2020
If I'm gonna be the yeet, please be it today. Don't make me high effort, try to solve the game and still end up getting chopped, this is a 10-day phase game, don't make me waste my time.
1) The only difference between town and scum is TMI.
2) If scum can do it, so can town, except TMI.
3) The best way to tell the truth in a game of lies is by lying and the best way to lie in a games of lies is by telling the truth.
2) If scum can do it, so can town, except TMI.
3) The best way to tell the truth in a game of lies is by lying and the best way to lie in a games of lies is by telling the truth.
I don't see a scenario - unless Vision/Wanda have needlessly complicated powers - where Vision/Wanda are the bad guys in the game. Unless the whole point of the game is that since the townies are based off of Westview citizens, they'd also want Wanda/Vision out too. But that seems a little outlandish compared to the previous possibility where SWORD & witches are the teams.
I thought about it hard on why this role could exist...and I'm not seeing many town uses for it (again - under the assumption that V&W are town roles - if you flip this, the rationale is much weirder). That being said, I think it's a bold/weird scumclaim for D1 so I'm not really ready to hop on that train of thought too tightly.
Finally, I wondered what is the use of it at the end of the day. It's not a normal role which makes me think there are inherently non-normal roles in this game outside of the weak role.
Kind of just rambling at this point but don't have much time/energy to really correct any dumb setup mistakes here. Like I said I'm trash at that sort of thinking.
I thought about it hard on why this role could exist...and I'm not seeing many town uses for it (again - under the assumption that V&W are town roles - if you flip this, the rationale is much weirder). That being said, I think it's a bold/weird scumclaim for D1 so I'm not really ready to hop on that train of thought too tightly.
Finally, I wondered what is the use of it at the end of the day. It's not a normal role which makes me think there are inherently non-normal roles in this game outside of the weak role.
Kind of just rambling at this point but don't have much time/energy to really correct any dumb setup mistakes here. Like I said I'm trash at that sort of thinking.
- mastina
- mastina
-
mastina She
- False Prophet
- False Prophet
- Posts: 16052
- Joined: October 7, 2016
- Pronoun: She
- Location: Between Snohomish and Monroe, WA
- Contact:
Realtalk; are you reading what I am saying???In post 411, Guillotina wrote:That is even worse, I think both of them could be scum, associating me with them implies that I'm bussing my partners for no reason whatsoever. I've scum read them based on interactions with you and now YOU think I'm scum with them.In post 403, mastina wrote:I don't? You're mutually exclusive with both Roden and T3.In post 390, Guillotina wrote:Wtf? HEY! In what world do you believe that im scum with Roden?
The Audacity!
I said that you cannot be scum with T3.
I said that you cannot be scum with Roden.
You cannot be scum with either.
One of them being scum means that you cannot be on their scumteam.
One of them being scum means that you cannot be their partner.
However, this is multiball. Just because you're not scum with T3, and just because you're not scum with Roden, doesn't mean that you can't be scum.
You can be town!
If T3 and Roden both flipped scum, in fact, you'd be the hardest of hard clears.
But until such a time, you can still be scum. Just not WITH T3 or Roden.
(BTW phoneposting so forgive my slowness and bad formatting.)
- mastina
- mastina
-
mastina She
- False Prophet
- False Prophet
- Posts: 16052
- Joined: October 7, 2016
- Pronoun: She
- Location: Between Snohomish and Monroe, WA
- Contact:
Ditto this.In post 420, T3 wrote:Roden's claim feels believable? But also he's such a minor character, I could see that as one of scum's fakeclaims.
Is more or less what I thought.
- mastina
- mastina
-
mastina She
- False Prophet
- False Prophet
- Posts: 16052
- Joined: October 7, 2016
- Pronoun: She
- Location: Between Snohomish and Monroe, WA
- Contact:
Respectfully, no.In post 432, Shrek wrote:VOTE: mastina[/b]
answer my question and elaborate on your townread of galron
Galron looks town enough to me even without my assumption. I see no need to out my assumption today.
Now this is interesting - you don't need to answer if you feel as if I'm prying here but have you seen the show and is this person a good SWORD person (i.e. Jimmy Woo or the lady at the end who helps out with the space tank)?In post 457, Enchant wrote:In my flavor, SWORD doesh't look like scum, because i collaborating with one of these agents. I even know this name, but i don't want reveal it yet.
- mastina
- mastina
-
mastina She
- False Prophet
- False Prophet
- Posts: 16052
- Joined: October 7, 2016
- Pronoun: She
- Location: Between Snohomish and Monroe, WA
- Contact:
Worthless if Wanda and Vision are town (why does a town role need to find town?), too OP if Wanda and Vision are scum (why would a town role be able to out an entire scumteam?).In post 462, Hiraki wrote:Mastina what do you think about the role though?
So either way, makes nominally more sense as a scum role. I can SEE Rodens claim being town, but I think scum is overall more likely.
BTW, current feels:
2/3 scum in {Roden, T3, Guillotina},
Element scum,
Zyla scum.
You are right.In post 461, Hiraki wrote:Now this is interesting - you don't need to answer if you feel as if I'm prying here but have you seen the show and is this person a good SWORD person (i.e. Jimmy Woo or the lady at the end who helps out with the space tank)?In post 457, Enchant wrote:In my flavor, SWORD doesh't look like scum, because i collaborating with one of these agents. I even know this name, but i don't want reveal it yet.
- CheekyTeeky
- CheekyTeeky
-
CheekyTeeky
- Survivor
- Survivor
- Posts: 12090
- Joined: September 3, 2017
If scum could explain why Roden was so eager to claim to clear himself. Rolefishing.In post 463, mastina wrote:So either way, makes nominally more sense as a scum role. I can SEE Rodens claim being town, but I think scum is overall more likely.
<3 xx
In post 420, T3 wrote:Roden's claim feels believable? But also he's such a minor character, I could see that as one of scum's fakeclaims.
In post 421, T3 wrote:I really just want to lim Roden here.
This is such a confusing line of posts? You think I could be fake claiming because my role is a minor character, yet you're claiming Norm who has zero plot relevance? Mine actually has plot relevance in the first episode and could easily be Masons with the character who plays his wife, so it would be so unnecessarily risky to fake claim this guy.In post 419, T3 wrote:I'm Abilash Tandon/Norm. VT
I have no idea why you still want to elim me here if you believe my claim anyway.
Really?In post 454, Guillotina wrote:That's because I don't know that you are scum, I suspect you to be scum dude. If I knew you were scum, you'd be dead already.In post 412, Roden wrote:If I'm scum with an agenda and you're town, I don't have to understand why you're pushing me because obviously I am your enemy. Town can't plead with scum to try to understand them because scum's objective is to deceive and kill despite knowing the truth. So why are you pleading with scum to understand your perspective?In post 410, Guillotina wrote:No, I'm implying that you are scum with an agenda. I've been very clear that I don't town read you.In post 398, Roden wrote:Actually if you genuinely believe that I never considered to understand why you're pushing me, that implies you think I'm town.
If I'm not a town read, then you're slipping that I'm town through TMI.
What's this post then?In post 230, Guillotina wrote:You got the story crooked. I caught you and i cant wait for your flip and bet that best town performance nominationIn post 227, Roden wrote:Guillo fuming that he got caught early lol
Why does your very first post claim that I'm obvscum?In post 61, Guillotina wrote:Mastina is town. They were fast to break RVS off, negating wolves the chance to blend in.
Roden is obvious scum
VOTE: Roden
Assuming Wanda/Vision aren't scum, it let's me find the real ones and confirm them as town.In post 463, mastina wrote:Worthless if Wanda and Vision are town (why does a town role need to find town?), too OP if Wanda and Vision are scum (why would a town role be able to out an entire scumteam?).In post 462, Hiraki wrote:Mastina what do you think about the role though?
So either way, makes nominally more sense as a scum role. I can SEE Rodens claim being town, but I think scum is overall more likely.
BTW, current feels:
2/3 scum in {Roden, T3, Guillotina},
Element scum,
Zyla scum.
How is it rolefishing?In post 467, CheekyTeeky wrote:If scum could explain why Roden was so eager to claim to clear himself. Rolefishing.In post 463, mastina wrote:So either way, makes nominally more sense as a scum role. I can SEE Rodens claim being town, but I think scum is overall more likely.
To add to this, why haven't you tried to meta me yet? You usually love using meta and dumping meta analysis posts in the game.In post 469, Roden wrote:In post 420, T3 wrote:Roden's claim feels believable? But also he's such a minor character, I could see that as one of scum's fakeclaims.In post 421, T3 wrote:I really just want to lim Roden here.This is such a confusing line of posts? You think I could be fake claiming because my role is a minor character, yet you're claiming Norm who has zero plot relevance? Mine actually has plot relevance in the first episode and could easily be Masons with the character who plays his wife, so it would be so unnecessarily risky to fake claim this guy.In post 419, T3 wrote:I'm Abilash Tandon/Norm. VT
I have no idea why you still want to elim me here if you believe my claim anyway.
In post 186, T3 wrote:I am.In post 168, Roden wrote:You're playingIn post 145, T3 wrote:The way Roden is playing rn and actively gunning for people for shit reasons means he's probably scum. I also get why mastina says Roden feels different to Yakra.verydifferently this game.
These two posts feel a lot less congruent now that you're claiming VT.In post 419, T3 wrote:I'm Abilash Tandon/Norm. VT
you know you kinda said the same thing in corno trigger about somebody who was town when you were scum well trying to aim at one of the other people just like your doing now . At t3 do a meta dive of mistina . Check the game corno trigger.In post 458, mastina wrote:Realtalk; are you reading what I am saying???In post 411, Guillotina wrote:That is even worse, I think both of them could be scum, associating me with them implies that I'm bussing my partners for no reason whatsoever. I've scum read them based on interactions with you and now YOU think I'm scum with them.In post 403, mastina wrote:I don't? You're mutually exclusive with both Roden and T3.In post 390, Guillotina wrote:Wtf? HEY! In what world do you believe that im scum with Roden?
The Audacity!
I said that you cannot be scum with T3.
I said that you cannot be scum with Roden.
You cannot be scum with either.
One of them being scum means that you cannot be on their scumteam.
One of them being scum means that you cannot be their partner.
However, this is multiball. Just because you're not scum with T3, and just because you're not scum with Roden, doesn't mean that you can't be scum.
You can be town!
If T3 and Roden both flipped scum, in fact, you'd be the hardest of hard clears.
But until such a time, you can still be scum. Just not WITH T3 or Roden.
(BTW phoneposting so forgive my slowness and bad formatting.)