In post 2519, VP Baltar wrote:But yeah, keep quoting a post from page 20 and acting like I felt exactly the same on page 83 after Ico had replaced out. Totally a good faith point.
How does him replacing out make him go from suspicious to null?
In post 1134, VP Baltar wrote:I guess if my vote is needed on the Ico wagon to finish it, I'm not opposed, but it feels slightly too popular for ambiguous reasons to me.
Textbook soft-defense of Ico by shading his wagon as "too popular" rofl
Yeah, crazy I said that and stand by it as my feeling at the time on that wagon.
In post 2519, VP Baltar wrote:But yeah, keep quoting a post from page 20 and acting like I felt exactly the same on page 83 after Ico had replaced out. Totally a good faith point.
How does him replacing out make him go from suspicious to null?
More intellectual dishonesty! I didn't say the replacement changed my read. I said 63 pages later and a completely different player in the slot and you're stating I couldn't possibly go from twinge of scumminess to a null read.
In post 2496, VP Baltar wrote:As far as this chainsaw stuff, you're just posting things you already said and acting like you're making new points. I found SA scummy, we tussled and I ended up townreading him out of it. So complete bullshit to call it chainsawing for Ico. His camped vote for 50 pages looked sketchy.
wait a second when did you flip to a townread on SA
In post 2528, VP Baltar wrote:More intellectual dishonesty! I didn't say the replacement changed my read. I said 63 pages later and a completely different player in the slot and you're stating I couldn't possibly go from twinge of scumminess to a null read.
More top shelf intellectual honesty!
you literally said you had ico null
not that his replacement changed your mind into nullreading him lol
In post 2496, VP Baltar wrote:As far as this chainsaw stuff, you're just posting things you already said and acting like you're making new points. I found SA scummy, we tussled and I ended up townreading him out of it. So complete bullshit to call it chainsawing for Ico. His camped vote for 50 pages looked sketchy.
wait a second when did you flip to a townread on SA
i'm not seeing it in your iso
Idk, I'm on my phone and trying to make dinner, I'm not going to look for posts right now. I very clearly went at it with SA and didn't find him scummy after some time had passed and I reflected on his play post that point.
If we are both town here, I'm going to be annoyed because this was how you tunneled me wrong in Hidden Temple.
Well that's why I was fine deferring to skitter about you but she finally gave me the green light today so it's not just me who thinks you are a baddie!