Open 853 - PYP X/Y S_S [game over!]

[Enchant]

Jelous.

[Enchant]

Jealous*

[Gamma Emerald]

I could if I bothered too but it’s pretty well known by Titus and Gamma especially. I’d rather see if they back it up to read them. If they say it’s a lie then they are sus and I can be bothered to go get it. If they tell the truth saves me time.

this post confuses me for some stupid reason
it goes back to implo's point about "why would town, or anyone really, say upfront what response they would find suspicious?"
and I'm not even really sure what you're on about so I'd rather you post examples first before I say whether you're right or not. I think in general your idea that being nice is suspicious is kinda off-base though. It's probably player-dependent to a large degree.

[Gamma Emerald]

If you scumread 6 people in a 3 scum game that means you're wrong

It’s a POE

Some are obviously town but it’s a PoE not a solve. If I had a 6 player solve I would be wrong.

I do want to ask, what does PoE mean to you? When I think PoE, I think it means... well, they're the only people left who could be scum, so we can just lim them all and by process of elimination we'll hit all the scum. "If we lim all the people in the PoE we should be in good shape". which... this seems... like just a list of an arbitrary number of people who (presumably) are at the bottom of your reads list.

for me a PoE solve pretty much just relies on having a majority of slots sorted as town
I did see someone (think it was dwlee) say they had PoE read with only like 3-4 confident TRs, but idr their alignment in that game. It was funny tho

[Save The Dragons]

VOTE: mathblade

[Aristeia]

I think mathblade is much more likely to be bad!town than scum.

if mathblade is scum and hem is town, I don't think mathblade WKs him, scum!blade p much takes any mislim he can get so HEM is almost always a better lim than mathblade.

[Gamma Emerald]

Gamma Emerald
Harley Quinn
Aristeia
Save The Dragons
Ausuka
Roden

Bellaphant
Malakittens
Enchant
Dwlee99
implosion

humaneatingmonkey
Titus
MathBlade

this feels like where my reads are at rn
I intend to sanity check myself on some of this soon, obv titus + HEM is kinda wack but that bottom area is just the people I find have been the most suspicious

[Save The Dragons]

i just feel like a giant pi symbol is painted on a cloud that is blocking out the sun and covering the land in darkness that is ravaging the land and bringing suffering to all but in the final hour of glory my bracelet turns into a shining sword a beacon of light and on magic wings i fly up to the cloud and pierce it in twain destroying the darkness

i like the hem wagon too, maybe i should be more patient.

[MathBlade]

@math, what have Roden and the mala slot done to escape your Poe?

Mala has IRL stuff so she’s impossible to read
Roden just seems to be hunting I am not sure how to explain other than Roden doesn’t seem scummy

[MathBlade]

I could if I bothered too but it’s pretty well known by Titus and Gamma especially. I’d rather see if they back it up to read them. If they say it’s a lie then they are sus and I can be bothered to go get it. If they tell the truth saves me time.

this post confuses me for some stupid reason
it goes back to implo's point about "why would town, or anyone really, say upfront what response they would find suspicious?"
and I'm not even really sure what you're on about so I'd rather you post examples first before I say whether you're right or not. I think in general your idea that being nice is suspicious is kinda off-base though. It's probably player-dependent to a large degree.

That’s not what you said in the game where Titus was scum though recently?

[Gamma Emerald]

I think you're probably taking me out of context

[Bellaphant]

Gamma Emerald - I thought they were scummy earlier in day phase but are now null
Harley Quinn - my heart likes this slot but I think it's play style
Aristeia - town. The numbers stuff was bad but again, massively improved
Save The Dragons - null scum. like hem, lots of posts, can not actually tell you what they think about anything
Ausuka - town, but also my heart loves this slot
Roden - null scum

Elephant
Malakittens - aren't here
Enchant - bait
Dwlee99 - ???
implosion - town

humaneatingmonkey- prolly scum
Titus - wary of this slot, could be scum
MathBlade - town

this feels like where my reads are at rn
I intend to sanity check myself on some of this soon, obv titus + HEM is kinda wack but that bottom area is just the people I find have been the most suspicious

I would color this but I'm a luddite

[MathBlade]

I think you're probably taking me out of context

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p13371669

You tell me.

[MathBlade]

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p13371701

[Gamma Emerald]

???
imo that's a massive contradiction to the point you're making here. Titus was being exceptionally not-nice and was scum.

[MathBlade]

???
imo that's a massive contradiction to the point you're making here. Titus was being exceptionally not-nice and was scum.

That is my point exactly

Default is not nice

[Save The Dragons]

Save The Dragons - null scum. like hem, lots of posts, can not actually tell you what they think about anything

i mean i keep voting hem and mathblade that should give you a pretty clear idea

[Bellaphant]

Hem isn't here, math is probably town, I don't want to read pages of you (or anyone) bickering with math. What are your thoughts outside of those two slots?

[Save The Dragons]

Hq is pretty town

I liked their recent posting wrt HQ and dwlee

Ari no longer gives me heartburn

anyone else think roden should have done more by now? I think that's the main one i'd like to pursue

take your pick

[Bellaphant]

Eh, I actually agree with a lot of that. Can you explain why hq is town instead of just....nice?

It's weird, I see a.few people feeling bad about Roden bit not much pressure. Are people just resigned to a hem elim.today?

[Save The Dragons]

i like HQs posting

[implosion]

I wouldn't say "resigned to" a hem elim; i would say "enthusiastic about".

[Gamma Emerald]

???
imo that's a massive contradiction to the point you're making here. Titus was being exceptionally not-nice and was scum.

That is my point exactly

Default is not nice

no it isn't??????

[MathBlade]

???
imo that's a massive contradiction to the point you're making here. Titus was being exceptionally not-nice and was scum.

That is my point exactly

Default is not nice

no it isn't??????

It just is and I proved where you said Titus treats me like that every game

It’s what everyone does.

Math is ridiculous.

I could say the sky is blue or cloudy or whatever with a photograph but then we’d still get Math is moonlogicky.

[Gamma Emerald]

ffs