Warrior Cats Mafia [Day Three]

[Charloux]

So killing me or any leader before the theory is confirmed/demolished is stupid. There are 21 people here, you can't convince me nobody apart from me is scummy

[Frozen Angel]

The theory is bullshit

I also think killing leaders in day 1 might not be the best idea either for

another reason

and I initially voted you before I knew you were one

but I will not stand by and let you claim in the thread you or anyone else (even if it's me) is confirmed town for the wrong reasons.

[Cephrir]

charloux does kind of have a point though there has to be some mechanism to prevent scum from just shooting the leader target (i am making some leaps here because i think i have guessed how the mechanic works)

maybe the leaders already know what that is

and a protection mechanic (that we hypothetically might have or have not) will make either of us clear? It just make him more scummy for going out load about how confirmed town he is for being a leader while we both know the role has nothing to do with alignment

no, it wouldn't make you clear. it does seem like a possibility that you could all be town and i kinda see the merit in giving you all a d1 pass but i agree it would be a poor assumption.

[Cephrir]

oh, you don't know each other? wow, then we really should not be outing the remaining ones imo

[Frozen Angel]

oh, you don't know each other? wow, then we really should not be outing the remaining ones imo

its complicated

[Dannflor]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

cephrir do you have any reads yet

[Bell]

VOTE: Mastina

[Cephrir]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

cephrir do you have any reads yet

i am townreading bear, charloux, fa and mistyx

[Frozen Angel]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

that's exactly why I think it has to be called out to people who cant see full image

anyways

VOTE: Datisi

I can't believe I managed to catch up and even chat in real time tonight. see u all later

[Alisae]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

that's exactly why I think it has to be called out to people who cant see full image

anyways

VOTE: Datisi

I can't believe I managed to catch up and even chat in real time tonight. see u all later

y r u voting datisi

[Frozen Angel]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

that's exactly why I think it has to be called out to people who cant see full image

anyways

VOTE: Datisi

I can't believe I managed to catch up and even chat in real time tonight. see u all later

y r u voting datisi

read my posts in last page

[Something_Smart]

I highly doubt that Ydrasse intended for the leaders to be a mason group but did not explicitly make them so. I would imagine that the setup contains some counterplay to the issue Charloux brought up.

If nothing else, you can target a scummy player for it, which should stop scum from just killing them.

[Mistyx]

@marashu if you see this when you're catching up why did you prioritize the pt over the main thread if you were having trouble parsing alignments there

[Mistyx]

speaking as someone who's spent half the game making baseless mechanical assumptions without info we should probably stop making baseless mechanical assumptions without info

[Dannflor]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

cephrir do you have any reads yet

i am townreading bear, charloux, fa and mistyx

can you elaborate on misty

[Mistyx]

goodfeels ceph ss titus val
weird tier below but still leaning good charloux
badfeels norwee marashu

not as much as i'd like but it's good enough for now

gonna walk my dog back after

[Cephrir]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

cephrir do you have any reads yet

i am townreading bear, charloux, fa and mistyx

can you elaborate on misty

honestly i see her solving the game and having any town motivation and my previous experience was watching her mail in a scum game in ktane that was so obvious i was voting her uninterrupted for like, 4 game days

[Alisae]

I see why Charloux is thinking the way he is and I think it's towny but I wouldn't put any stock in it. I think making an assumption like that is going to be about as useful as assuming there's exactly one scum in each neighborhood.

that's exactly why I think it has to be called out to people who cant see full image

anyways

VOTE: Datisi

I can't believe I managed to catch up and even chat in real time tonight. see u all later

y r u voting datisi

read my posts in last page

I get your concerns but can't town do that stuff as well?

[Mistyx]

ktane was not one of my better performances but at this point ive just accepted that i play worse on this site as both alignments

[Frozen Angel]

I get your concerns but can't town do that stuff as well?

I should be in bed but I am not so I answer. the back track specially felt unnatural. the vote felt a sudden stance change and felt fabricated. the whole agenda seems with extra intentions - I mean with another intention than solving because you cant see how he gets there. a wagon is formed he is against it and pushes hard against it and then suddenly finds a very small excuse and jumps on the wagon himself and before anything deep or meaningful happens jumps off it for no reason.

so I'm concerned for the progress he made with his mindset and I think its worth investigating

[Dannflor]

alisae do you explicitly town read datisi or just not scum read him and want to give him time

[Alisae]

I'm happy with their play to the point where I'm not voting it but it's something I'll probably be keeping my eye on as more phases of the game passes. If he's town the townread should just get stronger and stronger

[fireisredsir]

honestly i see her solving the game and having any town motivation and my previous experience was watching her mail in a scum game in ktane that was so obvious i was voting her uninterrupted for like, 4 game days

this was also most of my reason for townreading misty fwiw

she's probably more capable than that as scum but in that it just didn't feel like there was any solving happening under the hood at all, and here it does. but also just like a relaxedness of not needing to force anything

[fireisredsir]

I'm happy with their play to the point where I'm not voting it but it's something I'll probably be keeping my eye on as more phases of the game passes. If he's town the townread should just get stronger and stronger

i don't really get what this means

like what makes you think he's town

or what makes you not think he's scum, at least, since you keep pushing back on people suspecting him

[Datisi]

I get your concerns but can't town do that stuff as well?

I should be in bed but I am not so I answer. the back track specially felt unnatural. the vote felt a sudden stance change and felt fabricated. the whole agenda seems with extra intentions - I mean with another intention than solving because you cant see how he gets there. a wagon is formed he is against it and pushes hard against it and then suddenly finds a very small excuse and jumps on the wagon himself and before anything deep or meaningful happens jumps off it for no reason.

so I'm concerned for the progress he made with his mindset and I think its worth investigating

i hate to bring up this point

actually no i don't

do you think i don't know how to fake basic progressions as scum?