Mastin wrote:I seriously doubt it. I think he just got lucky with a falseclaim...
I love it when people ignore the most obvious fact and instead choose to use wishful thinking that the guy 'just got lucky'. Fake claims are a big part of most theme games... i cannot stress that enough.
Mastin wrote:1: My traitor theory,
2: Mafia godfathers
3: Non-hollow mafia. We don't know for certain that Phil's killer was a hollow--
I don't see how the traitor explains Philly's role, a godfather would still probably be a hollow so it makes no sense either, and do you have any examples of non-hollow mafias that could be in this game? Aside from Uryu, who I highly doub is an anti-town force, I can't think of any non-hollow scum characters that make sense being here.
Mastin wrote:Nowhere does it say hollow.
No duh... The mod isn't going to tell us stuff like that. All evidence so far points to the scum being hollows, so that's a perfectly logical assumption. On another note, why are you bringing up "phillys killer" instead of just saying "mafia" do you know something we don't? It seems odd you would say it that way... almost like you know the mafia wasn't responcible for it...
Mastin wrote:The way it was phrased seemed almost an exact match to the way my role PM is phrased. I believed the claim was paraphrased because of how similar it was.
So you believed it was paraphrased, which means he changed it, and the changed form matched your Flavor so because it matched and you feel it was paraphrase you know it doesn't really match.. so you believed it? I don't think I'm getting something...