Martyr Mafia - Game Over

[hp [leaves]]

Well, I got screwed out of a spot in the winning cult...

I'm still agnostic, damn it!

That was very bad move of you to vote X.

But I still won

[ortolan]

Also, question to the cult leaders. Why did you recruit who you did? Like, zwet and MafiaSSK for example...

[mykonian]

who had on any moment the feeling that I was cult?

[SilverPhoenix]

who had on any moment the feeling that I was cult?

Going with the obv Jews made you pretty obvious cult. Basically, we knew had a shot of winning last night depending on if we got our recruit.

[SilverPhoenix]

Here are my recruiting actions:

N0:

DGB

N1:

Jahudo

N2:

X

N3:

PiP/Gorrad

N4:

tajo

N5:

al_kohaulec

N6:

hp[leaves]

[hp [leaves]]

I was recruited for being the most obvagnoistic

[PokerFace]

So Qwints tried to get Jebus and failed since jebus was N.
Christianity went at the son

And thanks to the recruit list its pretty obv who was in what group and won with God (looker)

Here are my recruiting actions:
N0: DGB
N1: Jahudo
N2: X
N3: PiP/Gorrad
N4: tajo
N5: al_kohaulec
N6: hp[leaves]

I was the agnostic cop. I could investigate one player each night and determine if they were a cult recruiter or not. I won when I got two CL's lynched (they couldn't be nightkilled).

Lulz

[mykonian]

who had on any moment the feeling that I was cult?

Going with the obv Jews made you pretty obvious cult. Basically, we knew had a shot of winning last night depending on if we got our recruit.

the problem is...

I am not cult. So I did something very wrong.

[X]

Really wish he hadn't actually confirmed that I was CL.

This had no bearing on the game. We were outnumbered. You should have protected your recruit (zwet) the previous day instead of hiding for no reason. There was no reason to hide from the other cult when they didn't have a clear numerical advantage (and even if they did you're pretty much unavoidably screwed at that point anyway). Also, if you'd actually helped with a display of power at the start of day six we were (more) likely to win. I already had mykonian and Indigo Herron acting like potential Jews.

I was sad that I to tried to appeal to al_kohaulec's emotion when he stated a preference for the more numerous cult, then have him change his mind (when ironically we were in the minority) and vote for the "minority" cult.

Oh...wow. That makes altogether too much sense.

ortolan - see post 1958.

[PokerFace]

So Qwints tried to get Jebus and failed since jebus was N.
Christianity went at the son

And thanks to the recruit list its pretty obv who was in what group and won with God (looker)

Here are my recruiting actions:
N0: DGB
N1: Jahudo
N2:

X

failed he was jew

N3: PiP/Gorrad
N4: tajo
N5: al_kohaulec
N6: hp[leaves]

I was the agnostic cop. I could investigate one player each night and determine if they were a cult recruiter or not. I won when I got two CL's lynched (they couldn't be nightkilled).

Blatant open setup lie Lulz

[X]

This is the way I organize my thoughts, so in case anyone else wants to see it:

1.

qwints

, the

Christian Cult Leader

, died Day One
2.

Erratus Apathos

, an

Agnostic

, died Night One
3.

Jahudo

, the

Islamic N1 Recruit

, died Day Two
4.

Adel

, the

Jewish N2 Recruit

, died Night Two
5.

alvinz95

, an

Agnostic

, died Day Three
6.

Jebus

,

Nietzsche

, died Night Three
7.

Looker

,

God

, left the game Night Three
8.

ZSW

, the

Jewish N3 Recruit

, died Day Four
9.

pacman281292

, an

Agnostic

, died Day Five
10.

ortolan

, the

Jewish N5 Recruit

, died Day Six
11.

X

, the

Jewish Cult Leader

, died Day Seven

12.

SilverPhoenix

is the

Islamic Cult Leader

13.

DGB

is the

Islamic N0 Recruit

14.

Gorrad

is the

Islamic N3 Recruit

15.

populartajo

is the

Islamic N4 Recruit

16.

al_kohaulec

is the

Islamic N5 Recruit

17.

hp [leaves]

is the

Islamic N6 Recruit

18.

MafiaSSK

, the

Jewish N1 Recruit

, ostracized in Endgame
19.

Indigo Heron

, an

Agnostic

, ostracized in Endgame
20.

mykonian

, an

Agnostic

, ostracized in Endgame

[ortolan]

Adel: btw, the night I got recruited was after zwet died. I think we were screwed at that point anyway.

[PokerFace]

This game should have been called "Prophet Mafia considering all the religious leading. Also so I could tell it more easily apart from this game
http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=6818
where there was actual dieing for your cause.

Very Cool Game Gurgi. Hope someone re-runs this open setup so I can play it sometime.

[zwetschenwasser]

WAAAAA>>>>

[al_kohaulec]

who had on any moment the feeling that I was cult?

Going with the obv Jews made you pretty obvious cult. Basically, we knew had a shot of winning last night depending on if we got our recruit.

It didn't matter if we gained a recruit or not. We just had to target an agnostic to win. Since we culted, we had a majority. If our agnostic target was targetted by the other side, he would have died, and we would still have majority.

The only other option is we target somebody not recruitable, fail, and have an equal number of Islam and other players. So worst case scenario is we reach a stalemate.

So yes, hp leaves was recruited for being obv-agnostic. But I wanted him on my team anyways cause he's awesome.

So Qwints tried to get Jebus and failed since jebus was N.
Christianity went at the son

And thanks to the recruit list its pretty obv who was in what group and won with God (looker)

Here are my recruiting actions:
N0: DGB
N1: Jahudo
N2:

X

failed he was jew

N3: PiP/Gorrad
N4: tajo
N5: al_kohaulec
N6: hp[leaves]

I was the agnostic cop. I could investigate one player each night and determine if they were a cult recruiter or not. I won when I got two CL's lynched (they couldn't be nightkilled).

Blatant open setup lie Lulz

Say wha? Are you tryin to call me out?

[PokerFace]

Yes I am you are obv fake claiming since cop is not listed in the begining of this open setup!

Vote: Alkoscum

<<Really wishes he had joined and played this game. Was fun to follow along though.

[al_kohaulec]

Yes I am you are obv fake claiming since cop is not listed in the begining of this open setup!

Vote: Alkoscum

<<Really wishes he had joined and played this game. Was fun to follow along though.

You're gonna regret this when you lynch the cop.

I'd call you out as scum, but I think your just an ignorant townie, so I'll let it slide until everybody else is convinced that I am town and I see fit to lynch you.

[hp [leaves]]

So yes, hp leaves was recruited for being obv-agnostic. But I wanted him on my team anyways cause he's awesome.

=)

You had me fooled by your fakeclaim for a second. I never read the full Islam list.

[Zakeri]

Yo, Came back to apologize for literally disappearing off the site. I was going through a funk of some sort that made reading through these games almost impossible for me.

Which is why I didn't kill Jebus even though I should have. I didn't even see that someone outed him as unrecruitable until after day 2 started.