I was suspicious of Elmo because his behavior and the behavior of the guy before him was a bit weird and they almost seem to be making a point to be unhelpful and do pretty much nothing so far this game.Battle Mage wrote:why would you target Elmo? Also, why would Dram block Plum?Vaya wrote:Elmo, and she was RB'ed by dram.
BM
Ok. Plum, Vaya, Why would you not have targetted HIM last night? That rolename is so obviously BS it's hilarious. xDSpyreX wrote:SP? I think. One of the damn million "town" roleblockers running around.
Because yesterday I was quite suspicious of YOU plum. SO I wasnt really buying the namecop mason daytalk claim.Plum wrote:Is that a call for a fullclaim, my friend?Battle Mage wrote:Ok, based on my LoS, and subsequent flips and comments, i'd say my 3rd suspect is Plum. KK flipping Mafia reflects badly on her, and my case on Sajin is undermined by KMD flipping non-Mafia. That said, her claim could get her out of trouble. If she and Vaya need to be tested, Plum should go first. Then again, meta-wise, im less sure.
Eh, a fullclaim will resolve this either way.
BM
DRAMONIC: Yesterday everyone put Milk in the 'prob Town if Tubby is telling the truth due to the Hider claim' bin. You KNEW that Milk was untargetable Night 1 and thus that Tubby's Hide attempt proved nothing about Milk's alignment. WHY did you not speak up about this???
Why, in your opinion? Or do you mean Rosso's, or what?Benmage wrote:Yes Elmo’s play is quite poor.
Why is that?VP Baltar wrote:Hidden double vote is a threat to the town until I see evidence that the scum can manipulate the votecount also.
Wow.. you've got aVP Baltar wrote:re:Kise's note theory-I think that is a bit of a stretch...though the death of Volkan isn't entirely lost on me.
Ok... Thanks to this post, my suspect list is: Benmage, chamber, milkshake, Snow Bunny, Sajin and tubby (in that order). Milk claims to be psychiatrist or Sane Modifier (I need clarification). Personally, if I was an SK and had knowledge of a curer, I'd jump on claiming in a heartbeat. It's much harder to win as SK so I'd defo convert to being town. Thing is, the claim kind of smells like boo-boo, so I'm still keeping her on my suspect list -- she's been there for a while... wait, milk is a she, right?chamber wrote:post
It's brilliant. KK had no reason to protect you from being lynched unless you're his buddy. I am a bit worried VP doesn't see this though.Benmage wrote:I cant believe your #1 read is that scribe thing....play better
SerialClergyman wrote:benmage, how have you missed all of this?
I thought Vaya did the action.... Yet Plum got blocked and no action...hence the confusion SC.dramonic wrote:one of them does the action at night, but they both receive the result.
At least that's what I understand...
You aren't active enough. Why did I make #2 on your list?Elmo wrote:Why, in your opinion? Or do you mean Rosso's, or what?Benmage wrote:Yes Elmo’s play is quite poor.
Still baffled at you....KK clearly didn't protect me saying I should be lynch to fulfill KmD's WC...how the fuck is that at all protecting me???KmD said the one he needs to kill is the SK...puhhleeeeassse elaborate more Kise...and not in 5 days.Kise wrote:It's brilliant. KK had no reason to protect you from being lynched unless you're his buddy. I am a bit worried VP doesn't see this though.Benmage wrote:I cant believe your #1 read is that scribe thing....play better
He didn't recommend that you be lynched. He wrote a note saying KMD would win the game > town if you were ever lynched. So it's protective in the sense that it attempts to scare everyone into NOT voting you. Why would KK go to these lengths for your benefit?Benmage wrote:Still baffled at you....KK clearly didn't protect me saying I should be lynch to fulfill KmD's WC...how the fuck is that at all protecting me???
Don't matter what KMD said, if that's even what he typed. KK tried to use a smoke and mirrors tactic (for what?) and I'm pretty sure he wouldn't just write a bunch of bullshit. What good would it do him to merely confuse town, when he should put those notes to use by assisting his mafia? And by assisting his mafia, I mean trying to protect you from being lynched.Benmage wrote:KmD said the one he needs to kill is the SK...
30 minutes, in yo face!Benmage wrote:puhhleeeeassse elaborate more Kise...and not in 5 days.
That's simply not true. Kmd was already dead when KK allegedly wrote the note. Therefore, he could not win if benmage was lynched. He was clearly trying to get benmage lynched if the note came from him. If KK wrote the note, then it is increasingly likely that benmage is prob town.Kise wrote:He didn't recommend that you be lynched. He wrote a note saying KMD would win the game > town if you were ever lynched. So it's protective in the sense that it attempts to scare everyone into NOT voting you. Why would KK go to these lengths for your benefit?
i think thats a lil rude,,chamber wrote:I think VP should just post everything, and his method of tabulation. All the raw data is in the thread anyway.
The second he's confirmed town I'll trust him to be secretive, until then I like transparency.tubby216 wrote:i think thats a lil rude,,chamber wrote:I think VP should just post everything, and his method of tabulation. All the raw data is in the thread anyway.
you never ask a magician to reveal his tricks
If i recall correctly, they do not have alignment confirmation of each other. Therefore, it's quite feasible that one is anti-town, especially given the role doesn't ring as particularly protown. I think we can give them another Day or 2, but after that, we will need to reassess. Ofc, if they dont investigate Sociopath tonight, i will happily string them up tomorrow.Elmo wrote: I kinda figure Plum, Vaya, Socio as town right now. I didn't especially want Plum's partner to claim, but I figure with Vaya out, she's likely town; VayaPlumScum can happily have that gambit paid of for the short term, as far as I'm concerned. I don't see any particular reason for a fullclaim unless Plum/Vaya want to.
