Thor wrote:@Richard - Flavor: I'm Robb Stark the king in the North. My vig is from my pet wolf apparently.
HAHAHAHAHAHAHA!
*clears throat*
Sorry. It's just...if you'd read the mini...yeah. Faraday clearly has a sense of humour.
I approve 100% of the vezo daykill. But damn it, why do players who are already obvtown have to be the ones with provable roles?
----------------------------------
FOS: anyone suggesting that Percy step forward,
for trying to get us to waste a chance at preventing a mislynch on a player who will be nightkilled eventually. Okay, if Percy is scum, then whose buddy do you think he is? Raivann's or danakillsu's?
I'd have rather waited to see who would put themselves forward and who would try to escape notice. So far, we've caught Benmage trying to pressure the Hand into stepping forward while not doing himself until anyone else did. (CSL actually came across as kind of genuine about wanting to prove himself.) But that horse has left the stables. The whole town has to do this together for it to work.
Step Forward
I think that SSBF should be nominated to prove himself instead of lynched. Right now, pretty much everyone would be okay with lynching him. He's also been the counterwagon to a Mafia godfather, and has links to the other flipped godfather. So it would be a good idea to have his alignment settled once and for all, and then concentrate on the other players in the game. Not only has everyone taken a stand on him, but afterwards, we can forget about him and start a fresh set of mobs to analyze. If he flips scum at the end of the day, then he gets "hacked to pieces" that night. But if he flips town, then we save ourselves what was a guaranteed mislynch.
Vote: SSBF
as most worthy.
----------------------------------
That said, if I had to vote for someone to
lynch
, it would actually be Benmage over CSL at this point. Not only because of how he tried to get us to waste our chance to clear someone on Percy. His play is all-around scummy.
(I had to leave Saturday night, and caught Benmage's spamathon. Since then, I've been debating how best to approach this. Never mind that I should really do a lynch mob analysis, which is more productive, instead of indulging my sadism in humiliating a scumbag who thinks he's a lot more competent as scum than he actually is. See, I'm not a very organized person. But trying to form a logical case out of the mess that is Benmage is a feat of organization. You can't just quote him and show all the times he's scummy. So much crap is flying out in all directions that it's hard to catch it all and contain it. What to do? To point out each of the dozens of times he claims he doesn't do something WHILE DOING IT IN THE SAME POST? To respond to every single one of his inane questions after I've accused him of deliberately spamming the thread with inane questions, even though it will just encourage him to fill the thread with more white noise and inane questions in response? To ignore most of it and just give a summary of my issues with him, with five zillion quotes illustrating each point?
Hint for next game, after you're lynched: I was not at all the best person on whom to try that act you pulled on I doubt it. For one thing, I'm not scum, so I won't immediately try to appease you and run away with my tail tucked between my legs. For another thing...let me put it this way. You see, you may have assumed that I'm easy pickings because my join date is October 2009, but I've had an intermediate amount of experience off-site. And as bad as I am at reading people, I'm not all that bad at debating when I make an effort. Particularly not with someone who can barely form complete sentences.)
I don't think your interaction with I doubt it was distancing (although it struck me at the time that I doubt it's reaction to Benmage was rather nonchalant), but I like you for a Greyjoy.
----------------------------------
Axelrod, unless you think there's any possible way that "drowned" wasn't a Greyjoy kill, then we know "poisoning" is a Lannister flavour. (In the mini, Cersei was the poisoner.) I'm not sure what happened to Budja on N1 (if he really suicided or it was a Greyjoy kill), but clearly, Raivann and I doubt it were vig/SK kills due to "hacked to pieces." Since SSBF is much more likely to be a Greyjoy than a Lannister, he probably wasn't behind the jvw kill.
But I can see one other good reason why someone would poison julienvonwolfe on N1 and LynchMePls on N2. A very good reason.
Care to reveal anything, Cow?
I'm officially saying it now, anyone pushing for percy to be investigated gets scum points in my book. First, Percy is not impossible to read, so I don't know why people feel that way. He may be more difficult, but I think if you look closely at his play it is easy to see if there is consistency or not. That's the key to percy-town vs. percy-scum. From what I have read so far, we're looking at Percy town here. The game would be much better served by investigating someone of a murkier (or lurkier!) alignment. 